CO2 and You and Me ~ by Bruce Kershaw

~ while ~

climate change ~ is: real

~

July 23, 2014

~

Climate Science and Climate Religion

are two different things,

one is based on tested fact the other on true belief.

~

Science is tested and debated

~ while ~

Religion is not tested and debated ~

Religion is Preached and Believed

~

Prediction is not fact or knowledge

~ while ~

True ~ Belief

in self-debunked

~ Peer-reviewed ~

flawed ~ computer ~ prediction

is:

test proven religion not science of the scientific method.

~

Ignoring all test proven knowledge for belief in debunked prediction

is ~ not

Science of the Scientific Method

~

To:

carbon ~ based

Kim Davitt and Lora Weir

breathing ~ oxygen

made from

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2)

eating ~ carbon based food

made from

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2)

caused by the Carbon Cycle caused by this Carbon based Earth and the Sun

~

The Climate Prediction

is

self-debunked

and

Proven ~ Flawed ~ Hypothesis

~

tested knowledge ~ is: test proven fact

~ while ~

belief ~ is: make believe

~ while ~

prediction ~ is: belief ~ not ~ tested knowledge

~ while ~

debunked prediction is not reality

~

…do you want tested reality or make believe ?

~

Climate Religion will not debate their Religion in Public

~ proving ~

their Religion is a Religion not Science

$50,000

~ Reward ~

for the proof

Carbon is Pollution

and

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

~

July 21, 2014

~

climate change ~ is: real

~

There is tested reality

and

there is make believe ~

while

 there is belief as reality

~ untested ~

~

…bad ethics or bad science

~ or ~

both

~

To:

Dr. Reese Halter

From:

Dr. Bruce A. Kershaw

~

Reese,

don’t ~ tell ~ me

~ prove it ~

beyond ~ your ~ words of belief

~

Reese,

I heard you on MSNBC ~ on the Ed Show today ~

the Ed ~ show ~ is:

very much a show ~ not ~ Test Proven Factual Knowledge ~ News

~

Reese,

you are full of Baloney too,

just like Mr. Ed

~

Reese,

~ are you lying or just a bad Geologist ~

because

any ~ good ~ Geologist knows ~

the frozen ground has thawed many times between the last twenty major Ice Ages

just in the last two million years,

like 135,000 years ago when the Ocean was 20 meters higher than today,

or

~ 1000 years ago ~

when Montana had California Climate for 200 years,

Melting Glaciers and thawing frozen ground very rapidly

~

Reese,

$50,000

~ Reward ~

for the proof

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Warming

of this Carbon based Earth.

~

~ words prove nothing

~ while ~

the words

maybe ~ and ~ likely

~ as stated by some Scientist ~

Politicians ~ Journalist

the U.N. IPCC and EPA

prove nothing in

Fact Tested Science Knowledge

of the Scientific Method.

~

Climate Science ~ vs ~ Climate Religion

~

don’t tell me Carbon based Humans cause all climate change

~ prove it ~

as we are now Pumping CO2 in to the Ground ~

turning under ground drinking water ~ in to an Acid

for decades

to retrieve more oil from old oil wells.

~

climate change ~ is: real

while

debunked computer prediction is not real

~

I can not

~ predict ~

the future

~ can ~

You

?

~

My on going Investigation ~

since the spring of 2007

~ proves ~

there is zero ~ test proven science knowledge

 in climate religion.

~ while ~

climate change ~ is: real

~

I wonder how much Money MSNBC

Paid

Dr. Halter

to miss inform the Public in Geology and Climate Science ?

while

Ed Schultz

is a Test Proven Lair in Science

everyday

~

Maybe Ed should do what I have been doing every day since 2007 ~

Investigate the Science

~

Climate Warming is Real

while

Ed Schultz is not

~

Ed Schultz and Dr. Reese Halter

will not debate their test proven Religion in Public

~ proving ~

it is a Religion not Science

~ they will not debate their make believe ~

while

climate change ~ is: real

~*~

bruce@co2u.info

~*~

July 16, 2014

~*~

my body is 20% carbon

made from carbon based oxygen

while I breathe oxygen

made from carbon based oxygen

caused by the

Carbon Cycle

causing the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

on this

Carbon based Earth

~

carbon based oxygen ~ CO2 ~ carbon dioxide

~

The purest form of Carbon is Diamond made from Coal

~

climate change ~ is: real

~*~

while

Carbon based Humans

do not control

this universe of energy and nature

~ while ~

debunked

Peer-reviewed Computer Prediction

is ~ not

Scientific Knowledge

of ~ the

Scientific Method

~

~ throwing away ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

for

personal ~ feelings

of

Belief

in self-debunked computer prediction

is

Religion

not

Science

…as

Julie Baughman

and the

Helena ~ Montana

Independent Record

continue to

Brain Wash the public with their test proven debunked words of belief,

while providing zero Scientific Fact to support their true belief in debunked prediction.

~

debunked hypothesis ~ is: not ~ knowledge

~

~*~

climate change ~ is: real

~*~

~

To:

Dr. Linda Rudolph

linda.rudolph@phi.org

~

Linda,

the warmer the air is at the

Equator

of this Carbon based Earth

the more of the Ocean will evaporate in to the atmosphere

~ containing ~

50 to 70 times the CO2 level than the Atmosphere

~ from ~

~ Variable ~

un-measurable

on going Volcanic activity

below Sea level

on going

for billions of years

~ causing ~

acidification

of the Ocean

over billions of years

while

~ causing ~

the

First Atmosphere

while

~ causing ~

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

over hundreds of millions of years

~ causing ~

all

Carbon based Life

on this

Carbon based Earth

over

the last 600 Million years

above Sea level

~

Water Vapor and Carbon based Oxygen

~ is:

the by-product of warming by

the ~ variable ~ hot churning liquid core of this

Carbon based Earth

and by the

very

~ Variable ~

increasingly

warmer

Energy of the Sun

causing the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

~ Cycle ~

above sea level

causing

all

Carbon based Life

on this

Carbon based Earth

~

There is a continuous Variable of 3 million miles between the Earth and Variable Sun,

effecting the density of the Atmosphere

effecting the Variable Ozone Hole

effecting how much energy inters and escapes the Atmosphere

~ while ~

all the above Science Knowledge is completely Ignored by Climate Religion,

all climate history with more than a dozen climate variables

and 178 years of CO2 Chemistry

is

Completely Ignored

by

Climate Religion

~

Personal feelings of belief ~

do not debunk test proven scientific fact ~

tested science knowledge debunk feelings of belief

~ as true believers ~

continue to reject test proven knowledge for their personal feelings of

~ Belief ~

in

debunked ~ hypothesis

while

looking the other way

~ when ~

test ~ proven

Fraud is committed in Climate Science

~

~*~

climate change ~ is: real

~*~

~

Dear Jonathan,

I question and test knowledge

while

you believe in belief

~

~ science is: to know ~

Make ~ Believe

proves nothing in Tested Science

~ because ~

Make Believe is:  not ~ Knowledge

~

Science is tested and debated ~ not ~ belief in debunked hypothesis

~

Personal Emotional Feelings of Belief in something you can not prove with Knowledge

is:

Religion

~ not ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method

~

~ Science is based on tested knowledge not personal feelings of Belief ~

~

In Response to the Letter to the Editor

in the Helena Independent Record

July 14, 2014

by

Jonathan Matthews

of

Carroll College

Helena ~ Montana

~

Jonathan,

~ Belief ~

in debunked computer prediction

as ~ proof

Carbon based Humans

~ cause all Climate Change ~

only proves one thing in Tested Science of the Scientific Method ~

test proven stupidity.

~

I have Investigated Climate Warming since the spring of 2007

~ while ~

you

Jonathan

are a Preacher for Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

~

I challenge Jonathan Matthews

to an open public debate in

Carbon Science

Carbon Dioxide Science

Climate History

with

more than a dozen climate variables

and

178 years of test proven chemistry

that ~ debunk

the self debunking computer prediction

that Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change

with

a

$50,000 Reward for the Tested Knowledge

beyond belief in debunked prediction

proving

Carbon based Humans ~ cause ~ all Climate Change

~

 Jonathan will not debate his debunked Climate Religion

~ but ~

Jonathan will continue to preach his debunked belief ~

proving

Jonathan’s personal emotional feelings of belief

is:

a Religion ~ not ~ Tested Science Knowledge.

~

Before you can prove by scientific method

the

Hypothesis

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

~ regardless ~

of

Carbon based Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

~ causes ~

Atmospheric Warming

you ~ must ~ first

~ debunk ~

178 years of Test Proven Chemistry ignored by Climate Religion

and the last 2 million years of Climate History ignored by Climate Religion

along with more than a dozen Climate Variables ignored by Climate Religion

all  proving ~ CO2 ~ causes cooling not warming

debunking

the

self-debunking computer prediction

~

~ dry ice cools the air up to ten times faster than frozen water

~ while cooling the air up to 20 times longer than frozen water.

~

evaporated

water vapor and CO2

caused by the warming of the atmosphere by the

Sun

~ causing ~

what goes up ~ must ~ come down

~ while ~

the Purest form of ~

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

is called

Dry Ice

~

CO2 is the by-product of Energy

and

the by-product of Atmospheric Warming

~

CO2 can not generate new Energy,

CO2 can only absorb and release pre-existing Energy

~

CO2 can only Transfer Hot and Cold

all ready in the Atmosphere

CO2 can not add or subtract Energy

from the X amount of Energy

entering and escaping the Atmosphere

~ while ~

 hot Air expanding rises

~ while ~

very heavy cold dense Air takes the place of the hot Air rising

cooling the lower atmosphere

~ while ~

increased levels of -200 degree CO2

from the upper atmosphere

takes the place of hot air rising

the CO2 cools the Air up to ten times faster than the Frozen Water

while

crashing toward the Earth by the vacuum left in the lower atmosphere

caused by the hot air rising

containing Water vapor

containing 50 to 70 times the level of CO2 than the Atmosphere

~

Reality is testing knowledge to find the Truth

while

~ belief is ignoring tested knowledge ~

ignoring the Tested Truth

~

Carbon based Humans causing Climate Change

on this Carbon based Earth

is based on Belief in debunked prediction not tested knowledge

~

Jonathan Matthews

believes there is a God

but

can not prove there is a God

~

That is called Religion not Science

~

Jonathan Matthews

believes Humans cause Climate Change

but

can not prove Humans cause Climate Change

~

That is called Religion not Science

~

Jonathan Matthews

has rejected the Scientific Method

for

Belief

in debunked prediction

~

debunked ~ prediction

that will not allow Jonathan to see the test proven reality

while

miss-informing the Public

with the blessing of the Helena Independent Record

who have earned zero right to Scientific opinion

with their zero Comprehension of Science and the Scientific Method

~

Believing

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change

does not

~ prove ~

in Tested Science

that

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change

~

debunked ~ hypothesis

does not prove

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change

~

~*~

climate change ~ is: real

~*~

~

July 9, 2014

Helena ~ Montana

the record high for today was 101* in 1886

the expected high for today is 88*

~ the truth is ~

the high for today was 89*

~ the prediction was wrong by one degree ~

climate change effects

.5*

while

the

Ocean has risen 350 feet

in the last 26,000 years

while the Ocean was 20 meters higher 135,000 years ago than today

while the Ocean is rising slower than other times

~ between ~

Ice ages

of

the last 20 Ice ages of the past 2 million years

~

The first Atmosphere

on this Carbon based Earth

was

Water Vapor and Carbon based Oxygen

~ causing ~

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

caused

by

male and female

plants and trees

~

Water Vapor

(H2O)

~ and ~

Carbon based Oxygen

(CO2)

make this

Carbon based Earth

Very Green

and full of

Carbon based Life

for the past 600 million years above Sea level

~

Carbon based Life ~

is:

the by-product of

Carbon based Energy

caused by this

Carbon based Earth

causing the

Carbon Cycle

causing the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

Cycle

~

since 1835

by tested knowledge of the scientific method

Carbon based oxygen causes cooling not warming ~

supported by

Climate History with more than a dozen Climate variables

~

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

is: the by-product of Energy

not

the

Cause of Energy

~

Carbon based Oxygen

is the by-product of Climate Warming not the cause ~

while

…debunked ~ flawed

computer ~ prediction

~ hypothesis ~

does not prove Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change

~

to:

Climate ~ Religion

~

Climate Change is Real

but

~ when you refuse to look at the tested knowledge that debunks Your true belief ~

that is Religion

~ not ~

Science of the Scientific Method

~

…science is to know ~ through ~ tested knowledge

~ while ~

all truth is tested not believed

~

belief ~ is ~ religion

~ not ~

Tested Knowledge ~ or ~ Tested Reality

~

science ~ is: to ~ know

~ not ~

to ~ make ~ believe

~

Testing knowledge is how we find ~

Reality ~ beyond ~ Belief

~

~*~

climate change ~ is: real

~*~

~

To:

Eric Boehert

of

Media Matters

From: Dr. Bruce A. Kershaw

~

Eric,

Climate Change is Real

for

Billions of Years

before

Carbon based Life

on this

Carbon based Earth

while

Belief in Scientifically Debunked

self-debunking flawed computer prediction

does not prove

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

or

Carbon based Humans

cause

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~

Ice core samples

~ debunk ~

CO2

causes

Warming

along with the last 2 million years of climate history

with more than a dozen climate variables

along 178 years of test proven chemistry

~ ignored ~

by climate religion

~

$50,000

Reward

~ for ~

the proof

~ beyond belief in self-debunking flawed computer prediction ~

that

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Change

of this

Carbon based Earth

~

Eric,

did you know ~

at one time

on this

Carbon based Earth

that

97% of Scientist

~ believed ~

Bloodletting was good for killing Illness

while

in ~ reality

bloodletting killed more Carbon based Humans than did the illness

~

Eric,

I wonder how many

Tests and Experiments

~ You ~

have performed

in

~ Carbon ~

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2)

and Climate Science

in your Life time

or

the number

of

Science Papers You have Reviewed

Analyzed

and Tested ?

~

~ I began my Science Investigation in the spring of 2007 ~

~

… science is wrong more often than right …

through the Scientific Method

~

Knowledge is found through Tested Failure

~ not ~

Belief in Debunked Prediction.

~

~ beyond belief in debunked hypothesis ~

…most of the methane in the atmosphere

comes

from the Floor of the Ocean and the Leaves of Trees.

~

…beyond ~ staged ~ Political Media Belief ~

there is reality.

~

Eric,

….do you want my 2 cents worth ?

~

~ science knows ~

Carbon based Humans

on this Carbon based Earth

do not cause all or any Climate Change

~ while ~

some

Carbon based Humans

who would fail grade school science

~ believe ~

Carbon based Humans ~ cause ~ all ~ Climate Change

~

…while you choose to believe ~

I choose to know…

~

Climate Knowledge ~ vs ~ Climate Belief

~

Eric,

Is there test proven reality beyond ~ the ~ self-debunking prediction ?

~

I will argue Tested Reality

~ while ~

you argue debunked Belief

~

Eric,

…there is nothing beyond belief in debunked computer prediction

to prove Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Change.

~

…maybe it is time for ~

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

to look at the Tested Science Knowledge

and stop ~ believing ~ in test proven ~

Political Media Hearsay

~

Eric,

what is the bases for your true belief in

~ debunked ~

Computer Prediction

~

Eric,

Life is a Test

~ while ~

most Carbon based Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

would ~ fail ~ the

Science

~ test ~

as

we are all

~ still ~

Breathing Oxygen

~ caused ~

by

the Carbon Cycle

~ caused ~

by

Carbon based Oxygen

CO2

~

Eric,

please explain

how

your belief in debunked prediction

~ debunks ~

the last 2 million years of climate history

~ with ~

more than a dozen climate variables

along with

178 years of test proven chemistry

that

debunk

your belief

in self-debunked

flawed

Computer

~ prediction ~

~

Eric,

why ?

is this

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~ ignored~

by your Religion.

~

Eric,

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

~ refuses ~

to debate their

debunked

Belief

proving their Belief

is a Religion not Science

~

science is to know

science is tested and debated

~ not ~

belief

~

Eric Boehert

has failed grade school Science

and has earned zero right to Scientific opinion,

Eric Boehert

is a test proven Lair in Science

~ who can prove nothing in Science ~

Eric Boehert

is a proven fraud in Science.

~

My on going Carbon and Climate Science Investigation

since the spring of 2007

has proven

there is nothing beyond

self-debunking flawed computer prediction

and

~ debunked ~

Political Media Hearsay

to prove

Carbon based Humans

cause

all or any

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~

~*~

climate change ~ is: real

~*~

~

To:

Stan Frasier

and

~ the ~

Independent Record

Montana Cow Girl

and

Vigilante

of Helena Montana

~

From:

Dr. Bruce A. Kershaw

Helena ~ Montana

~

In response to the

~ Letter to the Editor ~

to the Helena IR

by Stan Frasier

~

Curbing Carbon Pollution

~

~ stating ~

Carbon ~ is: Pollution

~

Carbon is not Pollution

on this Carbon based Earth

where everything

Living and not Living

has Carbon in it

~

Carbon

causing the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

causing

all Carbon based Life and Energy

on this Carbon based Earth

above Sea level for the past 600 million years

~ is not ~

Pollution

~

Climate Change is Real

~ while ~

Test Proven ~ Climate Religion

will not acknowledge

Test Proven ~ Scientific Fact

that debunks their Climate Religion

~

Climate Change is Real

~ while ~

Belief in ~ incomplete ~ self-debunking ~ Computer Climate Prediction

that ~ did ~ not

incorporate or acknowledge

the last 2 million years of Climate History

that ~ did ~ not

incorporate or acknowledge

more than a dozen Climate Variables

that ~ did ~ not

incorporate or acknowledge

the last 178 years of test proven CO2 Chemistry

~ while ~

each and all of the above

~ debunk ~

Climate Religion

~

~ self-debunking Computer prediction ~

known as

Ouija Board Science

by the Legal and Scientific Community

~ called ~

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

is ~ not

Real

~

Climate Change is Real

~ while ~

Four Dozen

NASA Scientist

disagree

with

Climate Religion

~

Climate Change is Real

~ while ~

over

9,000 PhD’s

of

over

30,000 Scientist

that I know of

disagree

with

Climate Religion

~

Climate Change is Real

~ while ~

There is no Scientific Consensus in self-debunking Computer Prediction

~

Climate Change is Real

~ while ~

Political Media Paranoid Climate Opinion Belief in

debunked computer prediction

is:

~ not ~

Test Proven Scientific Fact

~ of ~

the

Scientific Method

~

Climate Change is Real

but

not caused by

Carbon based Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

~

Climate Change is Real

for the last 4.6 Billion Years

~

Climate Change is Real

~

$50,000

Reward

for the proof

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change

~

Climate Change is Real

for the next 4.6 Billion Years,

by then

the

Progressively Evolving

Variable

~ Sun ~

that

continues to be Warmer and Brighter over time,

will have Vaporized this Carbon based Earth.

~

I Challenge

Stan Frasier

to an open public debate in

Test Proven Science

that

debunks

Stan Frasier and his

Climate Religion

~

Stan Frasier

will not debate the Test proven Science Knowledge

of

the scientific method

that

debunked his Religion

~

Stan Frasier is a Test Proven Liar

~ caused ~

by his ~

lack of knowledge

in Carbon ~ Carbon based Oxygen and Climate Science knowledge

~

~ Knowledge ~

that I have been apart of ~ for ~ the past 38 years

~

debunked Climate hypothesis

is:

~ not science ~

science is: to know

~ not ~

make believe

~

belief in debunked prediction is not Real or Reality

or test proven knowledge.

~

Political Media Climate Religion

does not comprehend

the tested knowledge

~ while ~

Ignoring

the

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

that

debunks

~ their ~

Test Proven

Religion

~

If Carbon is Pollution

on this Carbon based Earth

~ then ~

Stan Frasier ~ is: Pollution

~ because ~

Stan is 20% Carbon

made from

Carbon based Oxygen

breathing oxygen

made from carbon based oxygen

caused by the carbon cycle

~

Carbon based Oxygen is:

CO2

Carbon di-oxide

di ~ is: 2

oxide ~ is: oxygen

~

The Democratic Party is a Political Religion

The Republican Party is a Political Religion

~

Those

Carbon based Humans

who

~ believe ~

Carbon is Pollution

and

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

Climate Change

are a part of

Test Proven Climate Religion

~ not ~

Science

~

hearsay belief in debunked prediction is not knowledge

~

the first atmosphere

on this carbon based earth

was

Water Vapor and Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

causing

the

Carbon Cycle

causing

all

Carbon based Life

and

Energy

~

Stan Frasier

can ~ not

Prove

Carbon ~ is: Pollution

or

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

Climate Change

~

To:

Stan Frasier

and

the

Helena

Independent Record

Montana Cow Girl

and

Vigilante

~  $50,000  ~

Reward

~ for the proof ~

beyond

belief in debunked hypothesis

that

Carbon ~ is ~ Pollution

and

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

Climate Change

~

~ debunked ~

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

will continue to grow

~ because ~

it is based on

Belief

~ not ~

Test Proven Fact

~

Spending ~ Trillions

to reduce

the Cause of all Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth is:

stupidity

~ like ~

Bloodletting

and

Hunting and Burning Witches at the Stake

~

Political Media Climate Religion

~ refuses ~

to look at

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

of

The Scientific Method

that

debunks

their Belief

Proving Their Belief is a Religion not Science

~

science is to know

knowing

Climate Change is Real

while

knowing

there is zero knowledge

beyond

flawed incomplete self-debunking hypothesis

to prove

Carbon based Humans

cause all or any climate change

on this carbon based Earth

~

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

is

Proven

to

Harm Nature ~ not ~ Help Nature

~

Stan Frasier

~ is ~

a

test proven

Preacher

for

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

~ not ~

a Scientist of the Scientific Method

who will not debate his Religion ~ proving it is a Religion.

~

~*~

climate change ~ is: real

~*~

~

~

life is a test to find reality

~ knowing ~

knowledge is tested not believed

~

~ what is and what is not…

~

I am a Scientist testing for knowledge

finding ~ belief

~ in ~

debunked ~ prediction

~ not ~

finding

test proven fact.

~

Political Media Paranoid

Climate Religion

does not

Comprehend

the Scientific Method

~ or ~

…moving oxygen generates energy.

~

…expressing knowledge not belief ~

~

the word

~ likely ~

proves nothing in tested science knowledge

of

the Scientific Method

~

Climate Paranoia is caused by belief in a lack of test proven knowledge

of

the Scientific Method.

~

…belief in debunked computer prediction

~ is ~

not ~ knowledge

~ or ~

tested reality

~

finding reality ~ beyond ~ belief

~ in ~

debunked computer prediction

~

I do not ~ believe ~ this carbon based Earth is flat

~ because ~

I ~ Know ~ it is not

~ because ~

science is: to ~ know

~ not ~

to ~ make ~ believe

~

bruce@co2u.info

~

George was right ~

…here comes the Sun”

~

Climate Change is Real

~ while ~

Flawed Incomplete ~ self-debunking ~ Hypothesis

~ does not prove ~

Carbon based Humans ~ cause ~ Climate Change

~

Belief in ~ debunked ~ Computer Prediction

does not prove

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

All ~ or ~ Any

Climate Change

on this

Carbon based Earth

~

Smoking is bad for you Mr. President,

~ so ~

why

~ do you Smoke ?

~

Mr. President

if you are in need of a good Science Adviser ~

I can help you.

~

Mr. President

If there was no Carbon ~

on this Carbon base Earth,

there would be no ~

Carbon based Earth

~ causing ~

the Carbon Cycle

~ causing ~

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

cycle

~ causing ~

all Carbon based Life and Energy

above and below

Sea level

on this

Carbon based Earth

for the last 600 million years above Sea level

~ where ~

everything Living and not Living has Carbon in it ~

~

Your body Mr. President is 20% Carbon

made from Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Mr. president ~

you are Breathing O2 Oxygen

made from

~ CO2 ~

Carbon based Oxygen

carbon di-oxide

~ caused by ~

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

~ Cycle ~

that you

Mr. President

and

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

~ do not ~

Comprehend

~

Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

~ are ~

a moment in time

~ where ~

Climate Change is very Real

for the last 4.6 billion years

~ while ~

you Mr. President of the United States

~ believe ~

Carbon based Humans ~ cause ~ all ~ Climate Change.

~

~ belief is religion not science ~

~

~ science is to know ~

Prediction is not Knowledge

~ Debunked ~

Flawed Computer Prediction

does not prove

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Change

while

words ~ of ~ belief

prove nothing in Tested Science Knowledge

~

Mr. President

how does Carbon based Oxygen cause Climate Warming ?

~

The President can not explain how Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

the cause of all the Oxygen we Carbon based Humans Breathe

and the cause of all the Carbon based Food we Carbon based Humans Eat

~ CO2 ~

the Cause of all Carbon based Life and Energy

on this Carbon based Earth

~ is the cause ~

of

All

Climate Warming

~

Mr. President

your advisers in Science ~ are ~ Big Dummy’s in Science

Mr. President

do you always believe everything you are told to believe

~ with zero ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method ?

~

Mr. President

Climate Change is not a ~ Hoax ~

Climate Change is ~ Real ~

~

The Hoax Mr.President

~ is You ~

believing ~ and ~ blaming

~ Carbon based Humans for all Climate Change ~

after 4.6 billion years of

Very Extreme

Progressively Evolving

Climate Change

~

The President can not prove

with his Words of Political Media Belief in ~ debunked ~ Flawed Computer Prediction

that

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Change.

~

The President believes in something he can not prove with Science,

that is called Religion not Science.

~

The President of the United States is a Preacher for

~ Test Proven ~

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

~

The President has yet to provide anything beyond

Belief in Words of Belief

to Prove

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Change.

~

Mr. President

$50,000 Reward

to Your Favorite Charity

for the Scientific Proof

beyond your Personal Feelings of ~ Belief ~ in ~ debunked ~ Flawed Computer Prediction

~ that ~

Carbon based Humans

on this

Carbon base Earth

~ cause ~

all ~ or ~ any

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~

To: Everyone Breathing O2 made from CO2

while

Eating Carbon based Food made from CO2.

~

Carbon based Oxygen

CO2

Carbon Dioxide

is not

Poison and Pollution,

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

is not

Poison and Pollution

on this Carbon based Earth,

where everything

Living and not Living

has carbon in it..

~

$50,000

~ Reward ~

for the proof

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

Climate Change

on

this

Carbon based Earth

and the

Proof

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

~ Cycle ~

causing all Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth

~ is ~

Poison and Pollution

~

The President

and

Political Media Journalist

who would obviously fail grade school Science

can prove nothing in

Tested Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method

~

Climate Change is Real

~ while ~

Climate Religion can prove nothing beyond ~

Their Paranoid Belief ~

~

… in the Scientific Community ~

Science is Tested not Believed

~

~ don’t tell me ~

Carbon based Humans cause all Climate Change

on this Carbon based Earth

~ prove it ~

beyond your personal feelings of belief

~ in ~

debunked flawed computer prediction

~

… when is

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion ~

going to debate ~ their ~ true belief ?

based on debunked prediction

~

Test Proven Knowledge

debunks the ~ Belief ~

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Change

~

Climate Change is Real

Climate Change caused by Carbon based Humans is

a Test Proven Religion ~ not ~ Tested Science of the Scientific Method

~

Test Proven Science enforced by the EPA since the 1970′s

proves CO2 causes Cooling not Warming

while

the United Nations has recently Stated to the World

as CO2 levels continue to increase

the rate of Climate Warming continues to Slow down

Validating

178 years of Test Proven CO2 Chemistry

while debunking Flawed Computer prediction

based on self-debunking

Flawed Incomplete Hypothesis

~

It is a Belief Humans cause Climate Change

~ not ~

knowledge of science

~

science ~ is: to ~ know

~

I ~ Bruce A. Kershaw

was Licensed

~ by ~

The

STATE

~ of ~

CALIFORNIA

~ in ~

1976

~ to test ~

repair and certify

Atmospheric

Emission Controls

~

~ reality is tested not believed ~

~

~ is ~

Al Gore

your god and reality ?

~

Climate Change is: Real

~

Climate Religion

is

~ caused ~

by

Test ~ Proven

Morons ~ in ~ Science

~

The President of the United States is a Law Professor

and

a Test Proven Fool in Climate Science

~

… can reality survive ~

debunked reality ?

~ while ~

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion committing Fraud in Science

~ looks ~

the other way.

~

I began my on going investigation of Climate Science in the spring of 2007

and

~ maybe ~

both sides of the story or argument should be seen, told, and heard ?

~

Lighting is caused by moving oxygen generating a Field

~ caused ~

by this

Carbon based Earth Rotating

at

1000 miles per hour

the Lighting

causing NOx

causing

O3 Oxygen called Ozone

caused by

Sun Energy

Separating the Nitrogen from the Oxygen

that bonded together

at

2500 degrees and hotter

causing

the Progressively Evolving Variable Ozone layer causing a Variable Ozone Hole

over hundreds of millions of years

~ while ~

-200 * F

CO2

from the upper atmosphere

is

cooling the air

ten times faster than frozen water

while

Crashing back toward this Carbon base Earth ~

to take the place of hot air rising.

~

I am

~ completely ~ totally ~ against ~

Political Parties of any kind

~ because ~

right now

~ We have ~

Test Proven Morons in Science

running ~ the

United States Government

~

~ everything ~

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

~ Ignores ~

and

does not want you to know ~

~

science is: to know

~ while ~

Laws are based on Hearsay ~ not ~ Test Proven Fact

~

Proven Fact Tested Science knowledge of the Scientific Method

~ debunks ~

the word

~ likely ~

~

The Official Scientific Statement for their many years of Climate Science

by the United Nations IPCC

~ is:

the

Word of Belief

It is Likely Humans Cause Climate Change

that is the UN IPCC

Scientific Proof

Carbon based Humans cause all Climate Change

One Word of Belief

Likely

~

The Word of Belief ~ Likely ~ has been

~ debunked ~

by Test Proven Knowledge

~

There is nothing beyond ~

the

word ~ of ~ belief

~ likely ~

to prove Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

after 4.6 Billions of Years of

~ very extreme ~

progressively

Evolving

Climate Change

~

Rejecting Test Proven Science Knowledge

~ before ~

Testing the Science Knowledge

~ for the belief in the word likely ~

is Religion

~ not ~

Science of the Scientific Method

~

Why do Climate Change Attorneys

~ block ~

my e-mails ?

~ when ~

I offer a

$ 50,000

Reward

for the proof

Carbon based Humans

~ on this ~

Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

all or any

Climate Warming

~ of this ~

Carbon based Earth ?

~

To:

Michael Gerrard

~ Director ~

Columbia University

Center for Climate Change Law

$50,000 Reward

~ for ~

Proof

beyond the belief in debunked computer prediction

~ that ~

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

all or any

Climate Warming

~ of ~

This Carbon based Earth

~

~ no one is denying ~

Climate Change

while

~ no one can prove ~

Climate Change

is caused by

Carbon based Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

after 4.6 billion years of very extreme Climate Change

~

Jeffrey Sachs

Earth Institute

Columbia University

~ is ~

a test proven

~ phony in science ~

a Test Proven Preacher,

not a Scientist of the Scientific Method.

~

I Challenge

Columbia University

Science and Law

to

an open public debate in

the

Laws of Climate Science

with

a

$50,000 Reward

for the tested proof only Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

all

Climate Change on this Carbon base Earth

as

Preached by Climate Religion

after 4.6 billion years of ~ very extreme ~ Climate Change

~ before ~

there were

Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

~

~ Columbia University ~

will not debate ~ their ~ Test Proven Religion

based

on hearsay ~ not ~ test proven fact.

~

Ignoring Test Proven Knowledge

~ for ~

Personal Feeling of Belief in ~ debunked ~ Prediction,

is not Science.

~

Climate Science ~ debunks ~ Climate Religion

Climate Science

~ debunks ~

Test Proven Fraud in Science

~

~*~

~

To:

United States Senator

Representing

Special Interest Groups

~ not ~

The Government

of

The State of Montana

United States Senator

John Walsh

~

~ we are no longer ~

The

Republic

~ of ~

The

United States

~ of ~

America

~

U.S. Senators

are no longer chosen

by their State Government to

~ Represent ~

the

State Governments of the United States

in the United States Senate

~

That was the original intent and purpose of the U.S. Senate

to represent state governments

making the States United.

~

U.S. Senators no longer take orders from their states ~ they no longer represent,

they now give orders to the states ~ they no longer represent.

The Senate now controls the States ~ the ~ States no longer control the Senate.

~

~ we are now the ~

Un-United States of America

~ because ~

State Governments

no longer

Own

and

Control

the

United States Senate

~

K-Street

Wall-Street

and

Special Interest Groups

now own

the

Senate

~ of ~

The Republic

~ of ~

The

~ un ~

United States

~ of ~

America

~

Money and Greed

now own the most powerful body on the Carbon based Earth

~

Thanks to the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Amendment

things are far worse not better,

in

America

~

~*~

~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

~

Climate Change is Real

and

Carbon is not Poison and Pollution

on this

Carbon based Earth

~

~*~

Climate Science

~ vs ~

Climate Religion

~*~

~

Belief in

self-debunking Computer Prediction

that

does not Incorporate or Acknowledge

Climate History

or

more than a dozen

Climate Variables

or

178 Years of Test proven CO2 Chemistry

 is

Religion not Science

~

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon Dioxide

is:

the continued by product of atmospheric warming

for billions of years

~ not ~

the cause of atmospheric warming

~ causing ~

the

First Atmosphere

on this Carbon based Earth

~ causing ~

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

on this Carbon based Earth

~ causing ~

All Carbon based Life and Energy

on this Carbon based Earth

for the past 600 million years above Sea level

on this Carbon based Earth.

~

Self-Debunking

Published

Peer-reviewed Computer Prediction

does not and can not debunk

Scientific Fact

~

Climate Religion is ~ not ~ based on Knowledge,

Climate Religion is based on Ignoring Knowledge

~

~ 1,000 Years ago ~

Montana had California Climate

for 200 years

~ debunking ~

Michael Mann and his Bogus Hockey Stick

~

Prediction based on Belief

while

ignoring

Scientific Fact

is

Religion ~ not ~ Knowledge

~

Michael Mann will not debate his Religion

~ proving ~

it is a Religion

~

Climate History ~ debunks ~ Climate Religion

with more than a dozen

Climate Variables ~ debunking ~ Climate Religion

with test proven

CO2 Chemistry ~ debunking ~ Climate Religion

while four dozen

NASA Scientist ~ disagree with ~ Climate Religion

while

over 9,000 PhD’s

of

over 30,000 Scientist

that I know of

Disagree ~ with ~ Climate Religion

~

Michael Mann

has

zero credibility in the Scientific Community beyond Climate Religion.

~

Michael Mann and his Hockey Stick is Test Proven Fraud in Science.

~

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

is:

Test Proven Fraud in Science.

~

You can not Stop a Paranoid Religion based on belief in debunked prediction

with

Test Proven Science

~

Climate Religion will not debate their Religion

~ Proving it is a Test Proven Religion ~

~

In the Supreme Court of the State of Montana

Climate Science ~ vs ~ Climate Religion

Climate Religion

~ Lost ~

~

Carbon based Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

~ causing ~

Climate Warming

~ is ~

debunked

Hypothesis

debunked

unproven theory

~ not ~

Test Proven Fact

~

Climate Change ~ is: Real

~

This Second day of Summer in the Northern Hemisphere,

the Second day of Winter in the Southern Hemisphere,

as more -200 * CO2 from the upper Atmosphere

comes Crashing toward the Earths Poles,

cooling the Air ten times faster than frozen water,

to fill the Void left by the hot Air rising into the -200 * Atmosphere.

~

June 22, 2014

~ the ~

Bent Shoe ~ Astor Load

Scratch Gravel Hills

Helena ~ Montana

the expected high for today is 73* F

the record high for today was 102* F in 1900

the record low for today was 33* F in 1942

~

Politicians and Journalist are not Scientist

and have earned zero right to Scientific opinion,

while a hand full of billionaires own the

Political Media World.

~

The Progressively Evolving Variable Sun

is:

Hydrogen Atoms

Colliding

so hard and fast

causing

Light and Heat Energy

causing

Helium

~

I have worked in Carbon and Atmospheric Emission Science

every work day of my Life for the last 38 years,

my work involves diagnostics

incorporating

Physics

Chemistry

Heat Transfer Science

Atmospheric Science

Atmospheric Emission Science

Computer Science

Electrical Science

Mechanical Science

Electrical Mechanical Science

Hydraulic Science

~ to name a few ~

~

I work with Carbon Piles and Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ everyday.

~

I have Investigated Climate Science Knowledge since the Spring of 2007

for many hours ~ on going ~ everyday.

I have made well over 25,000 request,

with a reward

to University’s

to Climate Scientist

to Climate Change Attorneys

to Politicians

to Journalist

for the Science Knowledge Proving beyond their Personal Feelings of belief

in

debunked Computer prediction,

that Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Warming,

of this

Carbon based Earth

and

so far nothing beyond Feelings of belief in debunked computer prediction,

while the only thing that can be proven is Fraud.

~

~ the ~

1896 Arrhenius Paper

is: a

~ incomplete ~

self-debunking

Science Paper

that proves nothing but fraud by those who use it

~ as ~

Proof Humans cause all or any Climate Warming

~

Michael Mann

and his bogus Hockey Stick has been Debunked by Reality,

as Michael continues to preach his proven Fraud and Lies.

~

Al Gore and Bill Nye

~ committed ~

Test Proven Fraud together

while showing the world a bogus Scientific Experiment,

while climate religion looks the other way.

~

All of Al Gores Words of Belief have been Debunked with Test Proven Fact,

while climate religion looks the other way.

~

Words written or Spoken

~ prove nothing ~

Words prove nothing in Science

Words of Belief prove nothing in Science

Words of Belief in debunked prediction prove nothing in Science

Words of Belief in debunked computer prediction prove nothing in Science

of

The Scientific method

~

The Statement by the United Nations IPCC

has changed from ~

it is

~ very likely ~

Humans cause all Climate Change

to

~ extremely likely ~

Humans cause all Climate Change,

that means we have gone from a strong belief to a firm belief

Humans cause all Climate Change.

~ Words of Belief ~

is ~ not

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

~ proving ~

it is still

just a hypothesis ~ Humans cause any Climate Warming

~ not ~

a Test Proven Scientific Fact,

while

~ Test Proven Knowledge ~

like

Climate History

more than a dozen

Climate variables

and

178 Years

of

Test Proven Chemistry

Ignored by ~ so called ~ Climate Scientist

~ debunks ~

the self-debunked hypothesis prediction

that

Humans cause all Climate Change

after 4.6 billion years of very extreme Climate Change.

~

very likely and extremely likely

are words of belief

not

Hard Scientific Fact

~

Climate Scientist

Ignoring all Science Knowledge

for

Belief in Prediction

is not Science

~

~ debunked ~

Computer Prediction and Ouija Board Prediction is not Scientific Fact.

~

The most recent statement by the United Nations IPCC

~ is:

as CO2 levels continue to Increase

the rate of Climate Warming continues to Slow.

~

The United Nations IPCC

has not proven with Test Proven Science Knowledge

~ Humans cause any Climate Warming ~

beyond their self-debunked hypothesis belief in prediction.

~

Why will No One on this Carbon based Earth

debate their Personal Feelings of Belief ~

that

Carbon based Humans cause all Climate Change ?

~ because ~

they have nothing beyond belief in self-debunked Computer prediction to debate.

~

~ NOx ~

Emission Science Enforced by the EPA,

since the 1970′s

that the EPA does not comprehend

~ proves ~

CO2 causes Cooling

~

When you replace 1% of the Nitrogen

in a 14.7 to 1

air to fuel mixture in a

Internal Combustion Chamber

with 1%

2,500 degree F

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

~

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

is:

2 oxygen atoms ~ based ~ to 1 carbon atom

Carbon ~ di – oxide

di ~ is ~ 2

oxide ~ is ~ oxygen

two oxygen atoms bonded to one carbon atom

C ~ O2

~

the explosion temperature of the combustion chamber drops 500*

to lower NOx

to lower O3 Oxygen

called Ozone at ground level

to reduce Respiratory illness

~

O3 Oxygen ~ Ozone ~

is a very important part of the Atmosphere and Nature,

as we reduce the production of Ozone for the sake of  wellness for Carbon based Humans,

Proving what is Bad for Carbon based Humans is Good for Nature,

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon Dioxide

~ causing ~

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

~ Cycle ~

is

Good for Nature and Good for Carbon based Humans,

on this Carbon based Earth.

~

The United Nations and EPA is Run by Politicians and Attorneys

who have ~ Failed ~ Grade School Science.

~

~*~

~

my body is 20% ~  C ~ Carbon

while I breathe ~ O2 ~ Oxygen

made from Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2

caused by the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

~

Carbon based Oxygen is the by-product of Atmospheric Warming not the Cause

~ causing ~

All Carbon based Life and Energy on this Carbon based Earth

~ while ~

off-setting Atmospheric Warming.

~

carbon based oxygen

is:

the by-product of energy and can not generate new energy,

CO2 can only transfer pre-existing energy,

not adding or subtracting energy in the atmosphere.

~

~*~

~

bruce@co2u.info

~

~*~

~

Joan Walsh

joan.walsh@salon.com

~ is ~

a Test Proven Fool in Science

~

Climate Change is Real

~ while ~

Science is: to know

~ by ~

Looking ~ beyond ~ Belief

~

If you do not look beyond ~

Your

Personal Feelings of Belief in Debunked Prediction

then you do not know

~ Reality ~

~

The Statement being made by many,

that 97% of Scientist agree that Humans are Responsible for all Climate Change

is:

a Proven Lie

and regardless of the Lies,

when the top 1% ~ with ~ test proven fact

~ disagree ~

with the bottom 99% ~ with ~ only debunked Political Media Belief,

then there is no Scientific Consensus,

then there is only Paranoid Political Media Climate Religion,

based only on Belief in Debunked Prediction.

~

After 4.6 Billion Years of Very Extreme Climate Change

for more than a dozen reasons ignored by Climate Religion

~ before Carbon base Humans ~ on this Carbon based Earth ~

Climate Change

is not going away,

until the Progressively Evolving Variable Sun,

becoming Warmer and Brighter

~ everyday ~

over billions of years

Vaporizes this Carbon based Earth.

~

~*~

~

To: Mark Hertsgaad

~ Journalist ~

Mark,

$50,000

Reward

for the Scientific Proof

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change.

~

Mark ~

You would fail the same test I passed in 1976

in the State California

to be Licensed and Certified

to test

to diagnose

to repair

and

Certify

 Emission Controls

in

The State of California

~

Mark,

You are not a Scientist,

You have zero credentials in Tested Carbon and Climate Science,

You have earned zero right to any Scientific Opinion,

You are a Test Proven Liar and Fraud in Science,

You can Prove nothing

but

Your stupidity in Science Knowledge,

I challenge you to an open Public Debate in Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method.

Dr. Bruce A. Kershaw

~

Mark will not debate his debunked belief in debunked prediction,

while Four Dozen NASA Scientist,

over 9,000 PhD’s

of over 30,000 Scientist that I know of ~

dis-agree with Mark’s Stupidity in Science,

but Mark thinks he is Much Smarter than the Working Scientist

~ he Ignores ~

for his True Belief in Debunked Prediction.

Mark has zero Comprehension of the Scientific Method.

Mark is a test proven Preacher for

Political Media Climate Religion

~

Mark Hertsgaad

Rejects Test Proven Knowledge

for

Debunked Hearsay Belief

~

Mark

and his

Political Media Climate Religion

will continue to Ignore

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

of

The Scientific Method

for their

Personal Emotional Feelings

of

~ Belief ~

in debunked hypothesis prediction.

~

Political Media Climate Religion

can prove nothing with Science.

~

~*~

~

4.6 Billion years of very Extreme

Climate Change

will continue on this

Carbon based Earth

~

This Carbon based Earth

causing

the

Carbon ~ Cycle

causing

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

causing

all Carbon based Life

for the last 600 million years above Sea level,

will be here long after Carbon based Humans are long gone,

with continued Climate Change.

~

~*~

~

Ignoring

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge for Belief

~ in ~

Debunked Prediction

is:

~ Religion ~

~

~ Ice core Samples prove Ice Ages with higher levels of CO2 in the air than today ~

~

Jeffrey Sachs

Earth Institute ~ Columbia University

~ You are a Test Proven Lair ~

Jeffrey Sachs,

I Challenge you to an Open Public Debate in Carbon and Climate Science

with a $50,000 Reward

for the Proof Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming.

~

Jeffrey will not Debate his very debunked Belief in debunked prediction,

as he Ignores Test proven Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

~

~*~

~

I am looking forward to owning and driving a Electric Car,

~ not to save the planet

~ but ~

to save money

~ because ~

buying a new Electric Car

~ means ~

the amount of new energy required to build the new electric car,

~ just to drive it off the show room floor ~

is the amount of energy needed to drive the old car for three years.

Those Carbon based Humans

who buy new cars

to save this Carbon base Earth from Carbon,

are test proven Hypocrites and Fools in Science.

~

~ Reality ~

Knowledge ~ debunks ~ Belief

~

Test Proven Climate Science Knowledge

with more than a dozen climate variables

debunking Humans cause climate change

is:

~ ignored by climate religion ~

~

~ Climate History ~

4.6 billion years of very extreme climate change

with 20 Ice ages just in the last 2 million years

with 20 Global Warming periods,

some Warmer than this Warming period

debunking Humans cause climate change

is:

~ ignored by climate religion ~

~

178 years of Test Proven Chemistry

proving CO2 causes cooling not warming

debunking Humans cause climate change

is:

~ ignored by climate religion ~

~

NOx Emission Science Chemistry

enforced by the EPA

since 1970′s

proving CO2 causes cooling not warming

debunking Humans cause climate change

is:

~ ignored by climate religion ~

~

Debunked Computer Prediction

debunking Humans cause climate change

is:

~ ignored by climate religion ~

~ as ~

the True Believers of Political Media Climate Religion

continue to Believe in debunked computer prediction

~ proving ~

Political Media Climate Religion is Very Real

~

To:

United States

Senator

~ of ~

Montana

John Walsh

~

$50,000

~ Reward ~

for ~ the

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method

~ proving ~

Carbon based Humans

~ on ~

this

Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

all ~ or ~ any

Climate Warming

~

~*~

Taking a Poll of Carbon based Humans

who do not Comprehend Climate Science

who have not Tested the Climate Science

who would Fail Grade School Science

is a invalid poll in Tested Science Knowledge,

it is a Belief Poll of Political Media Belief and is meaningless in Science.

Polling of Hearsay Belief proves nothing in Science.

Bloodletting is Hearsay Belief ~ debunked ~ by Test proven Fact.

Political Media Climate Belief is ~ debunked ~ by Test Proven Fact.

~

No One Who was Polled

Reviewed ~ Analyzed ~ and ~ Tested ~ the ~ Science

~ Knowledge ~

beyond

Their Personal Feelings of Belief

in

Debunked ~ Prediction

~

~*~

~

To:

Ed Schultz and MSNBC

Ed,

why do you call those who do not deny Climate Change

deniers of Climate Change ?

Ed,

I do not deny Climate Change

and I do not deny Test Proven Climate Science,

while you Ed

deny Test Proven Climate Science for Climate Religion.

Ed,

you believe in Debunked Computer Prediction

as proof Carbon based Humans cause all Climate Change.

~

Social Political Media Hearsay Belief

is not Test Proven Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method.

Ed is a Test Proven Lair in Climate Science.

~

I Challenge Ed to an Open Public Debate in Climate Science,

~ and just like all the other True Believers ~

Ed will not Debate his Belief in debunk Prediction,

proving it is a Religion not Science.

~

Ed and MSNBC

$50,000

Reward

for the Proof

~ beyond ~

Your Personal Emotional Feelings of Belief

~ in ~

Debunked Computer Prediction

~ proving ~

Carbon based Humans ~ cause ~ all or any ~ Climate Change

~ on ~

this

Carbon based Earth

~

~*~

~

To:

Scott Rutherford

Director, Marketing, Communications & Public Relations

~ for ~

UC Irvine Extension

Scott,

Thank you for your e-mail ~

requesting I remove you from my e-mail list,

while providing me with the legal action you will take against me ~

after I e-mailed you one time and if I e-mail you again.

~

Scott, after I send this to you,

I will remove you from my mailing list.

~

~ Obviously ~

Scott is not very good at Public Relations

Scott’s second e-mail to me ~

after asking me not to E-mail him

States

~ he is not interested in my nonsense ~

~

Scott is a True Believer ~

~ of ~

Debunked Computer Prediction

not a Scientist of the Scientific Method,

he rejects knowledge before testing it.

~

~ Belief in Prediction ~

Computer prediction or not

debunked prediction or not

Prediction

~ is ~

Belief

Belief is Religion ~ not ~ Test Proven Science Knowledge.

~

UC Irvine must be much better at Preaching how to Believe ~

instead of

Teaching how to Know

~

Belief is Religion

Science is to Know

~

closed minds reject knowledge

open minds test knowledge

~

True Nonsense

is:

Belief

in Debunked Computer Prediction

~ while ~

Rejecting

Test Proven Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

~

Scott has Rejected Fact for Feelings

~ that ~

is:

Religion ~ not ~ Science

~

Scott Rutherford

~ of ~

UC Irvine

is:

a test proven fool in Science

~ with ~

very poor communication skills.

~

~*~

~

To:

The President

~ of ~

The Republic

~ not ~

democracy

~ of ~

The United States

~ but ~

after the

Seventh Amendment

to the

U.S Constitution

we are now

the un-united states

~ of ~

America

~

Mr. President

words prove nothing

~ in ~

Tested Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method.

~

Like most Politicians and Journalist

the President of the United States is not a Scientist.

The President has earned zero right to any Scientific Opinion of any kind ~

The President of the United States

is:

~ thanks ~

to the stupidity of the the White House Advisers in Science

Brain Washing the President

the President is now a Preacher of Climate Religion.

~

The President of the United States of America

is:

a Test Proven Fool and Fraud in Science of the Scientific Method.

~

President Obama

$50,000

Reward for the Proof

~ beyond ~

Your Personal Emotional Feelings of Belief

in debunked computer prediction

~ that ~

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

Climate Change

~ while ~

You

Mr. President

~ Ignore ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

~ that ~

debunks

Your Test Proven Religion

~

The President can Prove Nothing in Science beyond his Personal Feelings of Belief,

in Debunked Computer Prediction

~ while ~

 I can Prove Fraud

~

Mr. President

the cause of the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

~ Cycle ~

Causing all Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth

is ~ not

Poison and Pollution

~

~*~

~

~ Climate Change is Very Real ~

I do not deny Climate Warming,

after 4.6 billion Years of Very Extreme

Climate ~ Change

~ but ~

The University of California Irvine

Can ~ Not ~ Prove

Carbon based Humans ~ cause ~ Climate Warming,

nor can any

~ University ~

on this Carbon based Earth,

Preaching Belief instead of Testing Fact.

~

I Challenge U.C. Irvine

to an open Public Debate in Carbon and Climate ~ Emission ~ Science.

~

U.C. Irvine will not debate ~ the ~ Debunked Hypothesis Prediction,

that Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming,

just like all the other University’s and Schools in the United States,

I have e-mailed since the Spring of 2007

~

Climate Warming and Cooling

of ~ this

Carbon based Earth

~ is ~

Very Real

~ but ~

not ~ caused ~ by

Carbon based Humans

~

If you do not Comprehend the Scientific Knowledge

~ then ~

You have Zero Right to Scientific Opinion

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

~

… common sense ~ debunks ~ make believe

~

To:

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

~

Debunked Peer-reviewed Computer Prediction

~ Proves ~

Carbon based Humans

do ~ not

~ cause ~

Climate Warming

of ~ this

Carbon based Earth

~

If Political Media Climate Religion

can not debunk ~

the last 2 million years of Climate Change History,

more than dozen known Climate Variables,

178 years of test proven ~ CO2 ~ Chemistry,

proving CO2 causes Cooling ~ not ~ Warming

along with NOx Emission Science Chemistry Enforced by the EPA since the 1970′s

proving CO2 causes Cooling not Warming,

~ as ~

all of this Test Proven Knowledge is

Completely Totally Ignored by Political Media Climate Religion

Proving it is a Religion ~ not ~ Tested Science Knowledge

~ then ~

Political Media Climate Religion

can not prove ~ beyond ~ Their ~ debunked ~ hypothesis ~ belief ~

CO2

~ or ~

Carbon based Humans ~ cause ~ Climate Warming

of ~ this

Carbon based Earth

~

Political Media Climate Religion will not

~ debate ~

~ or ~

~ acknowledge ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

~ that ~

debunks their Belief,

proving

it is a Religion

~ not ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

~

~*~

~

Friday ~ June ~ Thirteenth

2014

~

… belief in hearsay is ~ not ~ Reality

Belief does not debunk ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

of the Scientific Method

~

The Record High for today ~ here ~ where I am sitting was 94* in 1914

the Record Low for ~ here ~ today was 33* in 1969,

the expected High for today ~ here ~ is 69*

the expected Low for ~ here ~  today is 42*

~

1,000 years ago ~

Montana had California Climate for about 200 years.

~

We are living in one of the Gentlest

 Weather Pattern Cycles

of the Carbon based Earths 4.6 Billion year History,

the further back in time we go ~

the more severe the Climate and Weather on this Carbon based Earth ~

~ but ~

Thanks to the Moon moving further away,

over billions of years

slowing the rotation of this Carbon based Earth

reducing Gravity

contributing to less severe Climate and Weather,

along with more than a dozen progressively evolving Climate Variables

contributing to Climate Change

like the Sun becoming Brighter and Warmer

over the last 4.6 billion years of Climate Change.

~

This is

Climate Knowledge Ignored by Climate Religion

~

I was born on March 27 1956

I have worked in Atmospheric Emission Science Professionally everyday since 1976

I began My Climate Science Investigation in the Spring of 2007

~ My Investigation is on going ~

Dr. Bruce A. Kershaw

bruce@co2u.info

~

science is: to know

… science is knowledge ~ not ~ Belief

you can not debunk knowledge with make believe.

~

Hypothesis is Hypothetical Conjecture

~ not ~

Test Proven Fact

~

Prediction is Hypothesis

~ not ~

Test Proven Fact

~

Computer Prediction is: Programmed Belief in Prediction

~ not ~

Test Proven Fact

~

~ Belief in debunked Peer-reviewed Computer Prediction is Religion not Science ~

~

Science is admitting ~ when you are wrong.

~

… preaching and believing in something you can not prove is called Religion

~ not ~

Science

~

The by-product of all Carbon based Energy

from with in and on this Carbon based Earth

is:

the cause of all Carbon based Life

causing new energy

causing new life

~ called the ~

carbon ~ oxygen ~ hydrogen

~ cycle ~

~

If you do not comprehend this ~

then you are not smart enough to be a Scientist ~

of the Scientific Method,

and have zero right to any ~ Scientific Opinion.

~

If

we are going to Teach Science ~

~ then ~

it must be Science we are Teaching,

~ not ~

how to believe in belief

~

… learning how to test the knowledge

~ not ~

how to believe

~ in ~

Political Media Hearsay

~

Why do Politicians and Journalist

refuse to look and see beyond their Belief ?

~

Today

We the People

of the

~ Republic ~

of the

United States of America

find Reality in numbers in a Computer

while

for

far too many

Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

Reality

is

Looking for Clean Drinking Water

up to six hours a day

every day.

~

Climate Change is: Real

~ and ~

Political Media Climate Religion is: ~ Very ~ Real

~ but ~

Their

Belief in ~ debunked ~ Computer Prediction

is: not ~ Real

~

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon Dioxide

is:

~ the ~

Test ~ Proven

by-product of Climate Warming ~ not ~ the cause of Climate Warming

~ and ~

Test ~ Proven

to cause

Cooling ~ not ~ Warming

in Lab Chemistry Testing since 1835

~

The U.N. IPCC

~ and ~

United States

Environmental Protection Agency

~ and ~

Political Media Climate Religion

~ have yet ~

to provide Science Knowledge beyond

Their ~ Belief

in

Debunked Computer Prediction

to Prove

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon Dioxide

~ or ~

Carbon based Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~

Common Sense ~ debunks ~ Make Believe

~

Kyla Maki

kmaki@meic.org

of the

Montana Environmental ~ miss ~ Information Center

is a

Test Proven Liar in Science

~ because ~

Kyla

~ truly ~

believes in debunked computer prediction,

while rejecting Test Proven Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method.

Kyla,

please forward to me your last Test or Experiment with Carbon

and with Carbon based Oxygen (CO2)

Thank You

~

Kyla,

I challenge you to an open public debate in Carbon and Climate Science,

with a $50,000 reward for the Tested Proof Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change

and

for the Tested Proof Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2

~ the cause of all Carbon based Life and Energy on this Carbon based Earth ~

is:

Poison and Pollution.

~

Kayla will not debate her Religion,

because

Kayla can not Explain ~

what she believes is Science

~ while ~

never testing it,

to see ~ to know.

~

Political Media Climate Religion has yet to provide any Test Proven Science Knowledge

beyond their belief in ~ debunked ~ Peer-reviewed Computer Prediction

to prove Carbon based Humans cause any Climate Warming,

while Test Proven Carbon and Climate Science and Climate History ~

debunk their Hypothesis and Public Statements.

~

Science is not Prediction

~ Peer-reviewed or not ~

Science is to know not make believe

~

Who is Paying the Montana Environmental Information Center to Lie to the Public

and to the Politicians they Lobby ?

~

There should be a Legal Penalty

~ for ~

Committing

~ to ~

Proven

Deliberate Political Media Fraud in Tested Science Knowledge.

*

~*~

June 2014

~

The

Bent Shoe ~ Astor Load

~ Scratch Gravel ~

Science ~ Report

by

The Scientific Method

~

~*~

~

science ~ is: to ~ know

~

Belief ~ in ~ Political Media Opinion

is ~ not

Fact in Science or Law

~

Belief in Debunked Political Media Opinion is Religion ~ not ~ Knowledge

~

There are Tens of Thousands of Working Scientist

that I know of

just

in the USA

who know ~ what I know

~

… most of the Carbon based Humans on this Carbon base Earth ~

Eating Carbon based Food made from Carbon based Plants and Trees,

while the Carbon based Humans are Breathing Oxygen

made from the Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~

~ caused ~

by the Carbon based Plants and Trees Breathing the Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~

do not have a ~

Carbon based House made from Carbon based Wood to live in ~

or ~ Carbon based Wood to burn to survive the cold of Climate Warming,

while we are turning Carbon based Corn ~ food ~ into Fuel ~

Fuel when burned producing more CO2 not less CO2

~ than ~

Carbon based Hydrogen ~ HC ~ Hydrocarbon ~ Gasoline ~

~ then ~

Pumping the Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2

in to the ground

~ then ~

the CO2 finding its way to underground drinking Water

~ then~

the CO2 turning the under ground drinking Water ~ into an Acid

~ while ~

Thousands of Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

who have no Drinking Water

~ Starve to Death Every Day ~

on this Carbon based Earth of this Carbon based Universe.

~

How is the Cause of all Carbon based Life and Energy,

~ the cause of all the Nature ~ we Live in and Breathe ~

on this Carbon based Earth,

Poison and Pollution

?

The Cause of the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

~ causing ~

all Carbon based Life

on this Carbon based Earth

is ~ not

Poison and Pollution

~ while ~

Political Media Climate Religion is Preaching their debunked Hearsay Opinion Belief

to all Carbon base Humans on this Carbon based Earth

that

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2

is Poison and Pollution

and

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

All ~ Climate Change

~

Climate Religion is Stating ~

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

CO2 ~ the ~ cause of all Carbon based Life and Energy

on this Carbon based Earth

~ regardless ~

of

Carbon based Humans

~ is ~

Poison and Pollution

~ based ~

on ~ their ~ Belief

in

Debunked Hearsay Opinion ~ not ~ Fact,

this is the equivalent of stating clean drinking water is Poison and Pollution.

~

Bloodletting and Hunting and Burning Witches at the Stake

was based on Belief in Hearsay Opinion ~ not ~ Test Proven Scientific Fact.

~

The First Atmosphere

~ caused ~

by this Carbon based Earth

was all Water vapor and

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon Dioxide

~

One Carbon Atom and Two Oxygen Atoms

together

is

C ~ O2

~

Today the Atmosphere

~ is ~

of ~ 100.00 % dry air

~

Nitrogen ~ 78.09 ~ caused by decomposing Soil ~

one day ~

Nitrogen will be all the Atmosphere

~

Oxygen ~ 20.95 ~ caused by the Carbon Cycle ~

over Hundreds of Millions of years,

made from Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~

caused by

Carbon based Plants and Trees Breathing the Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2

~

Argon ~ 00.93 ~ from outer space

~

Water vapor ~ ……….. ~ 5 times the volume of ~ CO2 ~

from the evaporation of Water

~ the Ocean containing up to 70 times the level of CO2 than the Atmosphere,

from Volcanic activity below Sea level.

~

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon Dioxide ~ 00.04

~ caused ~

by this Carbon based Earth

mostly from un-measurable Volcanic activity

from 300 plus Volcanoes at this time

~ out of Thousands of CO2 outlets  ~

24/7

below sea level,

along with about 50 major un-measurable Volcanic eruptions per year below Sea level,

releasing CO2 into the Ocean and into the Atmosphere for Billions of years,

along with CO2 from Melting Ice containing trapped CO2,

the Evaporation of Lakes and Rivers and Streams containing CO2,

and from Volcanic activity above Sea level.

Today the Ocean contains up to 70 times the level of CO2 than the Atmosphere,

from on going un-measurable Volcanic activity below Sea level

24/7

Acidifying the Ocean over Billions of years.

~

CO2 is the by-product of Warming not the Cause of Warming

~

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon dioxide

~ caused ~

by Carbon based Humans is: 000.004

of

100.00 % of the Atmosphere

and is:

~ nothing ~

~

~ Carbon based Oxygen ~ caused by ~ Carbon based Humans ~

is the equivalent

~ of ~

a sewing thread

down the middle of the 50 yard line of a football field

~ if ~

the Atmosphere was the size of a football field

~ while ~

CO2 ~ is ~ still

~ in test proven chemistry ~

since 1835

~ the last 178 years ~

Test Proven to cause Cooling not Warming

~

~ Frozen CO2 is called Dry Ice ~

since the 1920′s

~

~ as ~

Frozen ~ CO2

from the upper Atmosphere

~ continuously ~

comes crashing toward the Earth as hot air rises

The Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon dioxide

Cools the Air 10 times Faster than Frozen Water

~

The U.N. IPCC

is stating

it is

Extremely ~ Likely

Humans ~ cause ~ Climate Change

~

That Statement is based on Belief and Proves

~ nothing ~

in Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge of the Scietific Method

~

The most resent Scientific

Statement

by

The United Nations IPCC

~ is ~

… as CO2 levels continue to increase

the rate of Climate Warming continues to Slow.

this supports 178 years of test proven chemistry

Ignored by the UN IPCC

~

… from Ice core Samples we know ~

here have been Ice Ages with higher levels of CO2 in the Atmosphere than today,

the Ocean was 20 meters higher 135,000 years ago than today,

while the Ocean has risen 350 feet in the last 26,000 years ~

~

We know from our DNA Funeral ~

there were as few as 15 breeding Woman left ~

on this Carbon based Earth ~

after a Super Volcano 74,000 years ago.

~

All the Gases in the Atmosphere absorb and release hot and cold ~

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon dioxide

~ is ~

the by-product of energy

and can not produce or generate new energy

CO2 can only absorb pre-existing energy then release the per-existing energy,

not adding or subtracting from the X level of Energy

that enters and escapes the atmosphere,

through the continuously Variable Ozone hole,

effected by the 3 million mile Variable between the Variable Energy of the Sun and Earth,

effecting the density of the Earths Atmosphere,

as all the Gases are heated ~

then expand while rising into the cold air,

causing a void to be filled by sub-zero air.

~

When CO2 absorbs more energy than the surrounding Gases,

the surrounding Gases will be cooler not warmer.

CO2 transfers Heat from the lower atmosphere to the upper atmosphere,

then sub-zero air takes it place,

while the frozen CO2 from the upper Atmosphere

cools the Air 10 times faster than Frozen Water

when returning to the lower Atmosphere.

~

Debunked ~ Computer ~ Prediction

based ~ on

~ Incomplete ~

Flawed and Self Debunking Science

does not prove Carbon based Humans cause ~ any ~ Climate Warming.

~

… there is more science missing from the debunked

Peer-reviewed Computer Climate Predictions

than in the debunked Peer-reviewed Computer Climate Predictions.

~

Prediction is not Knowledge

Prediction is Belief

Computer Prediction is called Ouija Board Science by the working Scientific Community

~

The

~ Political Media Opinion News is:

~ not ~

based ~ on

Test Proven Scientific Fact ~

it is based on un-tested Political Media Hearsay Belief in debunked Opinion

~ causing ~

Political Media Climate Religion

~

This Un-Tested Hearsay is Rejected by

Four Dozen NASA Scientist

over 9,000 PhD’s

of over 30,000 Scientist

that I know of ~

~

There is no Scientific Consensus,

there is a Political Media Consensus of Belief in Hearsay Opinion,

Debunked by Test Proven Scientific Fact

~

~*~

Chris Matthews

of

MS

Micro Soft

NBC

is not a Scientist and has Failed Grade School Science

Chris Matthews

is:

a Test Proven ~ Pathological Lair

who can prove nothing beyond

Debunked Prediction

and

Debunked

Political Media Hearsay

~*~

~

$50,000

~ Reward ~

for the

~ Proof ~

Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

Climate Change

~

~*~

~

~ I am not a Democrat or Republican ~

The Democrats

are test proven fools in Science.

The Republicans

preach one thing and then do the opposite.

~

I am a Scientist of the Scientific Method

for Truth in Science Knowledge

~

I don’t like the Koch Brothers ~

and

I am not for Big Oil and Energy Company’s

~

King George Bush

his First big mistake was letting 9/11 Happen

his Second big mistake was invading Afghanistan,

King Georges third biggest mistake was Iraq.

~ while ~

Al Gore

is:

a Test Proven Fraud in Science

~ while ~

Political Media Climate Religion

looks the other way.

~

I am for Clean Energy

~ while ~

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

the Cause of the Carbon Cycle

Causing the Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

and

All Carbon based Life and Energy

on this Carbon based Earth

is not Poison and Pollution

~

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2

~ is ~

the test proven

by-product of Warming

~ while ~

causing

Cooling ~ Off-setting ~ Warming

in Test Proven Science.

~

The last 2 million years of Climate History debunks CO2 causes Climate Warming,

with more than a dozen Climate variables debunking CO2 causes Climate Warming,

along with 178 years of test proven chemistry debunking CO2 causes Climate Warming

~ and ~

NOx

Emission Science Chemistry

~ enforced by the ~

United ~ States

Environmental Protection Agency

since the 1970′s

to lower Ozone at ground level

~ Proves ~

CO2

~ causes ~

Cooling ~ not ~ Warming

~ debunking ~

the hypothesis

CO2 ~ causes ~ Warming

~ this is:

Test ~ Proven ~ Science ~ Knowledge

Enforced by the EPA

that

the EPA does not comprehend or acknowledge.

~

The EPA is a Political Body not a Science Body ~

~

The United Nations

is:

a Political body ~ not ~ a Science Body

~ while ~

all of this Tested Science Knowledge is Ignored by Climate Religion

~

Special Interest Groups own America

~

Preaching Words of Belief in Debunked Opinion ~ Proves Nothing in Science

~

~ The Religion of Science is Skepticism of Religion in Science ~

~

I do not deny 4.6 Billion years of very extreme Change Change

~

The Published Peer-reviewed

~ Flawed Self-debunking Hypothesis Computer Prediction ~

~ that ~

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

Climate Change

has been further debunked by

Test Proven Reality in Tested Science Knowledge

of

The Scientific Method

~

Settled Science does not exist in the Scientific Method

~

Belief in Hearsay Opinion

~ is ~

Lunatic

Law and Science

~ not ~

Test Proven Reality

~

You ~ can ~ Debunk Political Media Climate Religion

~ but ~

You can ~  not ~ Stop it from Growing

~ proving ~

it is a Religion ~ not ~ Test Proven Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

~ of ~

this

Carbon based Earth

~

science ~ is: to ~ know

belief ~ is: to ~ make believe

~

~ I do not and can not

~ Believe ~

I can only ~ Know ~

by

The Scientific Method

~ while ~

Climate Religion

~ continues ~

to Ignore

Test Proven Carbon and Climate Science Knowledge

that

further debunks

~ Their ~

very flawed self-debunking

~ Belief ~

in

~ Prediction ~

~

~ Show Us ~

Your

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

of

The Scientific Method

~ not ~

Your

Personal Emotional Feelings of Belief

in

Flawed Self-Debunking Peer-reviewed Computer Prediction

~

Computers Predicting the Future

is: not ~

Science or Knowledge

~

Science is Test Proven Knowledge

~ not ~

Belief in Debunked Computer Prediction

Peer-reviewed or not ~

Prediction is not Reality

~

You can debunk Science with Science

~ but ~

you can not stop a Paranoid Religion with Science ~

~

… trust is earned not given.

~

Bruce A. Kershaw

Helena ~ Montana

~

~*~

~

~

~*~

Test ~ Proven ~ Fact

as the level of CO2 continues to increase in to the Atmosphere

the rate of Warming continues to Slow

~ Validating ~

178 years of test proven chemistry,

proving CO2 causes Cooling not Warming,

this is 178 years of test proven Science ignored by Climate Religion,

since day one of the on going climate debate,

the climate debate that Political Media Climate Religion will not debate

and refuses to debate,

proving it is a Religion not Science,

because science is never settled and always open for debate,

when Science is not open for debate,

it is no longer Science.

~

I do not deny Climate Change

~ while ~

Al Gore is a Test Proven Liar and Fraud in Science for Profit

~ and ~

a Very Proven Hypocrite

who will not debate his very debunked belief in debunked bogus Prediction,

Al Gores Religion has been ~ debunked ~ by Very Test Proven Reality.

~

~ to quote ~

then

State of Montana House Representative

Mike Phillips

~ of ~

Bozeman

“Laws are based on Hearsay”

Mike ~ Believes ~ Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

all Climate Change based on debunked Hearsay

~

… why will Climate Religion ~ not ~ debate their Religion ?

why do they ignore test proven fact that debunks their Belief ?

~

$50,000

~ Reward ~

for the

~ Proof ~

beyond the words of Belief in debunked Prediction ~

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change.

~

Prediction is Hypothesis not Fact ~

the Computer Predictions used to prove ~

CARBON ~ BASED ~ HUMANS

~ cause ~

Climate Change

have been debunked by

Hard ~ Tested ~ Scientific ~ Fact

~

Belief in debunked hypothesis,

does not prove Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change,

Belief in debunked hypothesis is Religion not test proven Fact.

~

CBS News

&

Bill Gates ~ MSNBC

~ are ~

The Political Media Climate Religion Channels

~ and ~

Test Proven Frauds in Science ~

why will CBS and MSNBC not debate their Religion,

while rejecting test proven fact,

while looking the other way when test proven fraud is committed,

and ~ why

will they not provide Hard Science Knowledge

to support their Belief in debunked Prediction?

~

CBS and MSNBC

have nothing beyond ~ their ~ words of belief in debunked Prediction,

to prove Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change,

Proving ~

CBS and MSNBC and their Journalist are Test Proven Frauds in Science Knowledge ~

of the Scientific Method.

What do the so called Journalist of CBS and MSNBC have to gain for Lying to the Public ~

MONEY

they are bought and paid for,

caused by their true Belief in zero Fact.

~

that is not Science

~

I can only wonder ~

how much Money did

John Kerry

Bill Gates

Bill and Hillary

and

Joe Biden

give to

~ invest ~

in to

Al Gore and Company’s

Bogus Carbon Credit Scheme ?

There are many Questions,

with zero Answers,

Why ?

~

The Carbon base Humans

~ of ~

The Republic

~ of ~

The United States

~ of ~

America

are being Brain Washed with debunked bogus Science,

by the Test Proven Frauds in Science

CBS News and MSNBC

~

~*~

~

M. Sanjayan

Conservation International

The Nature Conservancy

magazine@tnc.org

are

Test Proven Big Dummy’s in Carbon and Climate Science,

There is zero Science knowledge beyond their belief in

debunked Computer Prediction to

~ Prove ~

Carbon based Humans on this Carbon base Earth

~ cause ~

Climate ~ Warming

~

M. Sanjayan

why do Four Dozen NASA Scientists,

and over 9,000 PhD’s

of over 30,000 Scientists

that I know of ~

disagree with your ~ Belief ~ in Debunked Hypothesis.

why do you reject ~

2 million years of Climate History,

more than a dozen Climate Variables,

and 178 years of Test Proven Chemistry,

all debunking the debunked prediction.

~

I Challenge

M. Sanjayan

to an open Public Debate in Carbon and Climate Science with a

$50,000

Reward

for the proof

beyond his Belief

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change

~

To: Chris ~ in a ~ Hayes

Thank You Chris,

for proving to the Scientific Community your Religion is a Religion.

… the Climate has been Changing for the last 4.6 billion years.

IN ~ TESTED ~ CHEMISTRY

~ FOR ~

THE LAST 178 YEARS

CARBON BASED OXYGEN

~ CO2 ~

CARBON DIOXIDE

~ CAUSES ~

COOLING ~ NOT ~ WARMING

~

Chris,

$50,000

Reward

~ to ~

Your Favorite Charity

for the proof beyond your Religion

~ that ~

Carbon based Humans

caused by this

Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earths Atmosphere

~ while ~

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

~ is ~

~ causing ~

the

Carbon Cycle

causing ~ all

Carbon based Life and Energy

~

the first Atmosphere of this Carbon based Earth

~ was ~

Water Vapor and Carbon based Oxygen

H2O ~ and ~ CO2

causing ~ the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

~ cycle ~

~

Chris,

recently the United Nations IPCC

~ Stated to:

the Carbon based Humans of this Carbon based Earth ~

… as CO2 levels continue to increase in to the Atmosphere

the rate of Climate Warming continues to Slow.

~ This is old Knowledge not new ~

and

Ignored by Climate Religion

~

~*~

The Test Proven Political Media Climate Religion will continue to Grow

~ because ~

it is a Religion not Science,

Climate Religion will continue to Ignore ~

Test Proven Reality

~ because ~

it is a Religion

~ not ~

Tested ~ Science ~ Knowledge

of the Scientific Method.

~*~

~

Belief in debunked Computer Prediction

~ is ~

Lunatic Science

~

Rejecting Fact for Belief in debunked Computer Prediction is Religion

~

Carbon based Humans

~ causing ~

Climate Change

~ is ~

a Test Proven Political Media Lie

~ proven by the Fact ~

when you can not debate your science

~ then ~

it is no longer science

~ then ~

it becomes a Belief ~

belief is: religion

~ not ~

Science

science is: to ~ know

~ not ~

to ~ Believe

believe is: to ~ make believe

~

Anne Hedges

~ and ~

the

Montana Environmental ~ Miss ~ Information Center

~ are ~

Test Proven Liars in Carbon and Climate Science.

Anne Hedges is not a working Scientist in Carbon and Climate Science

and the Montana Environmental Information Center is not a Science Body,

they have not Investigated, Reviewed, Analyzed, and Tested the Science Knowledge,

and have earned zero right to Scientific Opinion.

They have Rejected Test Proven Science Knowledge

of the Scientific Method ~

to Preach their words of Belief in debunked Prediction.

The Hypothesis ~

the Peer-reviewed Computer Prediction,

used as evidence to prove Carbon based Humans cause all Climate Change

has been debunked by Test Proven Fact,

while this Test Proven Knowledge is Ignored by Political Media Climate Religion,

and that is why it is called Climate Religion,

~ because ~

Peer-reviewed Computer Predication is not Science ~ Knowledge or Fact,

while belief in debunked Computer Prediction is not Science ~ Knowledge or Fact,

~ Belief ~

in debunked Peer-reviewed Computer Prediction is Test Proven Religion.

~

Computer Prediction is called Ouija Board Science in the Scientific Community ~

and in the Court of Law ~

as demonstrated by precedent of the ~

Supreme Court

~ of ~

the

State of Montana

~ where ~

Climate Religion Lost ~ Their Legal Argument,

~ then ~

the Montana Supreme Courts Decision  was Ignored by Climate Religion

~ proving ~

it is a Religion.

~

Ouija Board Science Prediction

~ does not incorporate ~

the last 2 million years of Climate History

~ or ~

more than a dozen Climate Variables,

~ and ~

178 years of Test Proven Chemistry,

with each and all of the above

together or apart

debunking

the

Ouija Board Science Predictions

~

The debunked Predictions

~ Validate ~

178 years of Test Proven Chemistry,

~ ignored by Climate Religion ~

proving

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

~ causes ~

Cooling not Warming

~

Climate Religion has rejected all Test Proven Knowledge that debunks their Belief,

they have rejected all Climate History that debunks their belief,

more than a dozen proven Climate Variables

and all Test proven Chemistry

~

that

debunk ~ their ~ belief

~

That is not Science of the Scientific Method,

that is test proven Religion.

~

I Challenge

Anne Hedges

and the

Montana Environmental

Test ~ Proven

Bogus

~ Miss-Information ~

Center

to an open Public Debate in Carbon and Climate Science Knowledge

~ with a ~

$50,000

Reward

for the Scientific Proof

~ beyond ~

their

Belief

in Debunked Computer Prediction

~ that ~

Carbon based Oxygen

~ regardless ~

of

Carbon based Humans

caused by

Carbon based Oxygen

caused by this

Carbon based Earth

causes

Climate Warming

~

Anne Hedges and Co.

will not debate their Test Proven Religion,

but Anne will continue to Lie to the Public and to the Legislators she is Lobbying,

Anne is a Test Proven Fraud in Science ~

of the Scientific Method.

Anne has zero Test Proven Science Knowledge

to support ~ her ~

Belief in debunked Prediction

~

Increasing

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

in to the Atmosphere,

will make this Carbon based Earth ~

Greener and Healthier for all Plants and Trees,

while ~ making

Food and Oxygen

~ for ~

You and Me

~ to ~

Eat and Breathe

~

Only Big Dummy’s in Science

~ Believe and State to the Public ~

Carbon based Oxygen

(CO2)

Carbon Dioxide

~ is ~

Poison and Pollution

~

~ Science must be Factual not Political ~

Green House Gases are ~ not ~ Harmful to Humans or Nature

~ while ~

Political Media Climate Religion ~ is ~ Harmful to both Humans and Nature

~ on this ~

Carbon based Earth

~ this ~

Carbon based Earth

~ causing ~

the

Carbon Cycle

~ causing ~

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

~ causing ~

All Carbon based Life and Energy

~

What Plants and Trees

~ require ~

to Grow, Live and Breathe

is not

Poison and Pollution

~ if only Plants and Trees required Water,

there would be many today calling ~ Water ~ Poison and Pollution.

~

When the top 1%

~ disagree ~

with the Bottom 99%

that is not a Scientific Consensus

that is

Political Media Climate Religion

~ not ~

Scientific ~ Knowledge

~

~ Climate History has Proven ~

the more Water Vapor and Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) that is Evaporated in to the air

the Greener this Carbon based Planet ~ is ~

This Science knowledge has also been proven by every

professional

and

Scientific

Man ~ Made

Green House

on this

Carbon based Earth

~

To:

~ the ~

Political Media

website

Cowgirl ~ Blog

mntnacowgirl@gmail.com

~

Belief in Debunked Computer Prediction is Religion not Science.

If you ~ Believe ~ Humans cause Climate Change,

don’t believe ~ it

Prove ~ it

~ because ~

believing ~ proves ~ nothing in Science

~ because ~

Belief is: Religion ~ not ~ Science Knowledge

~

Most Adults Living in the United States today would Fail Grade School Science,

and have zero right to any Scientific Opinion.

~

There are many things that are good for Nature that are bad for Carbon based Humans

while many things that are good for Carbon based Humans that are bad for Nature.

~

Climate Change is Very Real

~ One thousand years ago ~

Montana had California Climate for about two hundred years.

~

Prediction is not Science Knowledge

Prediction is: Belief ~ not ~ Fact

~

This Carbon based Earth

~ causing ~

all Carbon based Life

is not

Poison and Pollution

~

~ Carbon based Oxygen ~

CO2

Carbon ~ Dioxide

~

Tested Science tells Us and shows Us

We Carbon based Humans are 20% Carbon Breathing Oxygen ~

Tested Science tells Us and shows Us

All Carbon based Life and all the Oxygen we Breathe,

is made from

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

CO2

Carbon Dioxide

~

I Challenge

Cowgirl Blog

to an open public debate in

Carbon and Climate Science

with a

$50,000

Reward

for their proof beyond their test proven Religion

and test proven Lies

that

Carbon based Humans ~ cause ~ all or any Climate Change ~

Cowgirl Blog

will not debate their Religion.

~

~*~

Climate Religion is Political not Factual

and has been proven to be very dishonest in Science Knowledge

because of their stupidity in Science Knowledge,

and can prove nothing beyond their belief in debunked prediction.

~*~

~

~ Joe Berry ~

Stanford University

Lab Science Professor

can ~ not ~ prove

Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

all ~ or ~ any

Climate Change

~ so ~

how can you ?

~

The United Nations is a Political Body not a Science Body ~

and has yet to provide any Scientific Evidence beyond their debunked Hypothesis,

to prove Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Change.

~

The Test proven Science tells us and shows us ~

as Water Vapor and CO2 levels continue to increase from evaporation,

the rate of Warming continues to Slow.

Water Vapor and CO2 is the by product of Warming,

while off setting Warming.

~

I do not ~ deny ~ Climate Change,

while Political Media Climate Religion calls me a Denier of Climate Change,

why are these Political Media Organizations

with zero comprehension of the Science Knowledge

intentionally lying about me and the Science,

while trying to belittle me with their proven Lies.

~

Very Extreme Climate Change is Very Real

for the last 4.6 Billion Years,

those who call me a denier of Climate Change have yet to prove beyond their

Personal Feelings of Belief in ~ debunked ~ Computer Prediction

that Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

Any Climate Change.

~

~ there is nothing beyond Belief in flawed debunked Hypothesis

to prove Carbon based Humans cause any Climate Change ~

Political Media Climate Religion can not prove with Scientific Evidence,

their Religion is not a Religion

~

The real Crap on this Carbon based Earth is caused by the Political Media belief in

proven hearsay,

preaching their Belief with zero fact tested Science knowledge,

of the Scientific Method.

The Scientific Method has zero meaning to Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion.

~

~ beyond Religion there is Science ~

~

religion is: belief

science is: knowledge

~

There are many Carbon based Scientists on this Carbon based Earth

who ~ believe

Carbon based Humans

on this Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

all ~ Climate Change,

while not one of them can prove it ~ beyond their belief,

nor have they tested the knowledge that debunks their personal feelings of belief

~ in ~

debunked

Prediction

~

I have an on going investigation of

Carbon and Climate Science Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

since the spring of 2007

~

… and thank God we have Chris Hayes ~

of

MSNBC

to set the world and record straight

~ in ~

all of tested Sciences of all of tested Nature,

on this Carbon based Earth ~

This Carbon based Earth

~ causing ~

all

Carbon based Life and Energy.

~

Chris,

you call yourself a Journalist ~

so ~

why do you believe everything you are told to ~ Believe ~

with out investigating

 and testing the Knowledge,

you have past judgment based only on Hearsay and Belief,

and zero Test proven Fact.

~

~ belief is not knowledge ~

Chris,

prove there is knowledge beyond ~ your ~ Belief in debunked prediction.

~

Chris,

you are not even aware

of the

Tested Fact

the

Computer Predictions

have been

~ Debunked ~

there is zero reality in your words of Belief.

~

Carbon based Oxygen is still the cause of all Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth,

and is Test Proven to cause Cooling not Warming since 1835 ~

178 years of Chemistry proves CO2 causes Cooling,

this tested Science has not been

~ debunked ~

nor have the last two million years of Climate History been debunked ~

nor has more than a dozen Climate Variables that we know of been debunked ~

providing

Trillions of climate Variables,

all proving CO2 can not be the cause Warming

~ regardless of Carbon based Humans on this carbon based Earth.

~

Christopher Hayes,

Vise President

Dick Cheney

~ is ~

a Crook for Halliburton,

while you Chris are a test proven Big Dummy in Science,

of the Scientific Method.

~

Chris Hayes does not want to ~ know ~ the Truth,

Chris only wants to believe in debunked Computer Prediction.

~

Chris,

I and tens of thousands of Scientist who disagree with you,

do not deny Climate Change

it is ~ you ~ who is in denial of Test Proven Climate Science,

that you do not comprehend,

and will never comprehend.

~

True Belief Proves nothing in Science,

the only thing Chris Hayes has proven in Climate Science is his Stupidity.

~

Chris Hayes

~ is ~

a Preacher for Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

~not ~

a Scientist of the Scientific Method

Chris does not Comprehend the Scientific Method

~

Chris Hayes can provide nothing beyond his personal feelings of belief

in debunked Political Media Paranoid

Climate Hearsay

to prove Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change on this Carbon based Earth,

Chris has proven ~

he is dumber than a Fifth Grader in Science.

Chris has zero credentials in Science,

Chris has earned zero right to Scientific Opinion of any kind,

Chris Hayes and MSNBC will not debate their test proven Religion.

~

Chris Hayes Truly Believes in the Test Proven Lies ~

he is Preaching to the world

~ Proving ~

Chris Hayes is a Pathological Liar.

~

Climate Change is very real for Billions of years,

while Saying and Preaching

Humans cause all Climate Change does not prove Humans cause any Climate Change.

~

Chris,

thank you for covering only one side of the Story,

the side you believe in and can not prove with tested science,

Tested Science of the Scientific Method.

~

Chris has proven he has zero comprehension the Scientific Method

~

Chris Hayes can not prove ~

Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

all or any Climate Change.

~

Chris is a Test Proven Liar,

a Test Proven Phony,

and a Test Proven Fraud ~

in Carbon and Climate Science of the Scientific Method,

caused by his stupidity in Science.

~

Chris,

I have been Emissions Testing every work day of my life for the past 38 years,

how many tests have you performed over the last 38 years ?

Chris,

you have not tested the Science of the Scientific Method

~ once ~

in the last 38 years,

you just Believe ~

what you are told to believe.

Chris,

the Scientific Method

can not Stop ~ Your ~ Test Proven Religion from Growing

and

in 50 years your Children and Grand Children

will know ~

you are a test proven Big Dummy in science of the scientific method,

because

today

four dozen NASA Scientists

~ that you ignore ~

over 9,000 PhD’s

~ that you ignore ~

of over 30,000

Scientist

that I know of ~

~ that you ignore ~

of the Scientific Method,

dis-agree with ~ your ~ Proven Political Media Climate Religion,

while you have yet to debunk the tested knowledge

that debunks your Belief in zero fact to support your debunked Belief.

Chris,

you have not debunked ~

more than a dozen climate variables ignored by your religion,

you have not debunked ~

the last two million years of Climate History ignored by your Religion

you have not debunked ~

178 years of test proven Chemistry ignored by your Climate Religion,

while every Science that you ignore ~ debunking ~ your Climate Religion.

~

Chris,

we

the Scientists of the Scientific Method

do not deny Climate Change,

while you Chris,

~ deny ~

Test Proven Climate Science Knowledge,

of the Scientific Method,

~ for ~

your personal feelings of belief in debunked Hypothesis

~

Chris,

prove Humans cause Climate Change,

beyond your personal feeling of Political Media belief in

debunked paranoid Climate Religion.

~

~ why ~

will Chris Hayes not debate his climate Religion

?

~ and ~

Thank You Chris

for

Proving

to the Scientific Community ~

Neil Degrasse Tyson

communications@amnh.org

Astrophysicist

~ is ~

a test proven big Dummy in carbon and climate science knowledge

~ of ~

the

Scientific Method

~

Neil

I challenge

~ You ~

to an open public debate in Carbon and Climate Science

with a $50,000 Reward

~ for the proof ~

Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

all or any

Climate Change

Dr. Bruce A. Kershaw

bruce@co2u.info

~

Neil can not prove Carbon based Oxygen ~ is the cause ~ of all or any Climate Warming

or

Climate Change

of the

Atmosphere

of

this

Carbon based Earth

~ regardless ~

of

Carbon  ~ Based ~ Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

where everything Living and not Living has Carbon in it,

with the exception a few microbes.

~

Carbon based Humans,

eating carbon based food ~ made ~ form carbon based oxygen

~ while ~

breathing oxygen ~ made ~ from carbon based oxygen

~

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2)

~ causing ~

the

Carbon Cycle

causing

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

causing all Carbon based Life and Energy

on

this Carbon based Earth ~

~

Carbon based Humans

do not cause all or any Climate Warming

or

Climate Change.

~

Neil is a True Believer ~

not a Scientist of the Scientific Method.

~

…don’t believe me

test the science knowledge ~

~

…from 178 years of test proven chemistry,

of the Scientific Method,

that Neil has not tested and has yet to know,

beyond his

Personal Emotional

Feeling of debunked Belief

~ in ~

debunked

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion.

~

when ~ frozen

- 200 degree

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

carbon dioxide

also known as

Dry Ice

in the upper Atmosphere

comes crashing toward this Carbon based Earth ~

as hot air rises,

CO2 cools the air ten times faster than frozen water.

~

..the Religion of Science is Skepticism

~ of ~

Religion in Science

~

There is 178 years of Test Proven Chemistry Ignored by Political Media Climate Religion,

that proves CO2 causes Cooling not Warming.

~

~ don’t believe me ~ test the science ~

~

Reality and Science

is tested and debated

~ not ~

Preached and Believed

~

Religion

~ is ~

Preached and Believed

~

Belief in debunked Hypothesis is: Religion not Science

~ while ~

Preaching debunked Hypothesis as test proven fact is fraud in Tested Science,

of the Scientific Method

~

Rush Holt,

you have zero science evidence to debunk test proven Knowledge,

test proven knowledge that debunks your personal feelings of belief.

Rush Holt,

you can prove nothing in Climate Science.

~

What is science and what is not ~

Michael Mann

when are you going to debunk the test proven facts that debunked your belief ?

Michael Truly Believes in his proven Lies,

Michael is a Proven Pathological Liar in the Scientific Community,

Michael and his Ouija Board Science Predictions are proven Garbage,

by Test proven Science of the Scientific Method.

Michael will not acknowledge the facts that debunk his Pathological Belief,

his Pathological belief in Political Media Climate Religion.

Michael Mann will not debate his debunked Religion,

as Michael continues to Preach his proven Lies.

Michael Mann

~ can not accept ~

his hypothesis has been debunked by Test Proven Reality,

garbage in ~ garbage out

proven by Reality

~

Preaching debunked Computer Ouija Board Prediction is Proven Fraud not Science.

~

prediction is: ~ not ~ Scientific Fact

computer prediction is: ~ not ~ Scientific Fact

belief in debunked computer prediction is: Test proven Religion

~ not ~

Scientific Fact

of the

Scientific Method

~

Rachel Madow and MSNBC

Rachel,

I have debunked all your words of belief with test proven fact,

and you have yet to debunk the test proven facts with your words of belief.

~

~ finding reality beyond your belief

~ not mine ~

I have no belief

… do you base carbon based life on belief or Test Proven Fact ?

~

The by product of life is death,

the by product of death is new life

~ caused ~

by the carbon cycle ~

~ causing ~

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

~ Cycle ~

causing all carbon based life on this carbon based Earth

for the last 600 million years of above Sea level,

caused by

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon Dioxide

~

…can the political media grow beyond Political Media Climate Religion ?

~

~ real is: knowing fact

real is ~ not ~ belief in debunked predication.

~

~ when is Fox News and MSNBC

going to stop foaming at the mouth

and look at the Tested Science that debunks the belief in debunked Prediction.

~

~ debunking religion proves nothing in science ~

~

Using Religion to debunk Religion

~ proves ~

nothing in Science

~

~ Idiots in Science control our Lives ~

~

Christopher and Rachel

of

Bill Gates ~ MSNBC

thank you once again for proving once again

you are big Dummies

in tested science knowledge of the Scientific method

~ please ~

enlighten

~ me ~

and the world ~

how does your personal feelings of belief in debunked computer prediction

~ debunk ~

more than a dozen climate variables,

two million years of climate history,

and 178 years of test proven chemistry

that

debunk your

~ belief ~

and why do four dozen NASA Scientist,

over 9,000 PhD’s,

of over 30,000 Scientists

~ that I know of ~

disagree with your debunked Belief ?

and why ~

will you not allow the Facts that debunk your pathological belief to be known ?

~ because ~

Political Media Climate Religion dose not acknowledge test proven fact

that debunks their Pathological belief in debunked Prediction,

proving it is a Religion

~ Proving it is not ~

Test Proven Science of the Scientific Method.

~

~ Climate Change is Real ~

but

Carbon based Humans

on

this

Carbon based Earth

do not

~ cause ~

all or any

Climate Change

~

Michael Mann, Rush Holt, Bill Gates,

Chris & Rachel

of

Political Media Climate Religion

~ MSNBC ~

have ~ zero ~ evidence

with zero right to scientific opinion

beyond their debunked prediction

to ~ prove ~

Carbon based Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

All ~ or ~ Any

~ Climate Change ~

they are:

Test Proven Frauds in Science

~ of ~

the

Scientific Method.

 They will not debate their test proven fraud in Science,

proving their belief  is a Religion not Science,

proven by the Scientific Method ~

the Scientific Method they reject for their personal feelings of Belief

~ in ~

debunked prediction.

~

real is: knowing fact ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

the

Scientific Method

has

~ debunked ~

the

Computer ~ Predictions

~*~

~

Emotional Feelings of ~ Your ~ Personal Belief is: not knowledge ~

your personal Belief in ~ Your ~ Words of personal Belief ~ Prove nothing in Science

Science is to know ~

to know is: to find and see tested knowledge beyond ~

your ~ Emotional Feelings of your personal Feelings of Belief in ~ Your ~ Words

of personal feelings of Belief in Belief.

~

Science based on Belief is: not Science

~ because ~

Belief is: Religion

~ not ~

Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

the

Scientific Method

~

I am not a Believer

I am a Scientist of the Scientific Method,

I do not want to hear Your words of Your personal belief ~

because

your ~ words of ~ your ~ personal belief Prove nothing in Tested Science Reality,

I want to see the tested knowledge beyond your personal belief in your words of personal

~ belief ~

~

History defines Reality

~ while ~

some of us look to find to see ~ tested Reality,

~ while ~

some of us never look to find then see Reality

~ while ~

some of us run from Reality

because they see it.

~

…if you do not know what I know ~ then You do not ~ Know ~

~

Ben Franklin, George Washington, Thomas Jefferson ~

and many others ~

were and are smarter than me ~

Ben Franklin was for Freedom of the Press ~

George Washington was against Political Parties ~

Thomas Jefferson was against Slavery ~

~

as I am still Learning from all of them,

~ Learning ~

…the government is: ~ not ~ the Problem

~ the Republican and Democratic Religions are the Problem

~ while ~

the political media ~ feeds ~ on each others un tested Belief

~

I do not Believe in ~

Political Media Religion

of

~ any kind ~

Political Media Climate Religion is not Climate Science.

~

~ In: Science of the Scientific Method ~

Climate Change is: Real

~ while ~

Climate Change

~ caused ~

by Carbon based Humans

on this Carbon based Earth

~ is ~

a Test proven Religion

~ proven ~

by the Scientific Method ~

the Scientific Method

~ ignored ~

by Political Media Climate Religion

~

When you believe in something ~

that you can not prove ~

that is not Science ~

that is: Religion

~

When you reject Test Proven Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method ~

for Belief ~

that is: Religion too

~

…the

Religion of Science is: Skepticism

~ of ~

Religion ~ in ~ Science

~

$50,000

Reward

to

Next Generation

feedback@thenextgeneration.org

For the Proof

Carbon based Humans

on this Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

Climate Change

~

There is no Science in Climate Religion,

there is only Emotional Feelings of Belief in Words of Belief and Money.

~

I Challenge Tom Steyer

and

Next Generation

to an open Public Debate

in

Test ~ Proven

Carbon and Climate Science

Tested Science Knowledge that debunks their Belief in debunked prediction.

~

If you can not debate your so called Science

then it is not Science and proves it is a Religion.

~

Reality is: not ~ based on belief in debunked prediction ~

when four dozen NASA Scientist

over 9,000 PhD’s

of over 30,000 Scientist

~ that I know of ~

disagree with your hypothesis (prediction)

that is not a Scientific consensus.

Joe Romm

is

a Test Proven Liar and Fraud in Climate Science ~

Joe Romm can not Prove Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

all or any

Climate Warming or Climate Change

beyond his Personal Feelings of Belief in debunked hypothesis prediction.

~

Belief is: not Test Proven Fact

Test Proven Fact debunks Belief in debunked prediction.

~

Joe Romm will ~ not ~ acknowledge Test Proven Fact that debunks his make believe,

Joe Romm Ignores and Rejects the Scientific Method ~

proving his belief is Religion with zero Science of the Scientific Method,

Joe Romm is a Puppet for Climate Religion

~ while ~

Steve Kornacki

is not a Scientists,

Steve is a Test Proven Fool,

and a Puppet for MSNBC too,

and has earned zero right to any Scientific Opinion.

~

There is nothing beyond Belief in Debunked Prediction to Prove

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide

or

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

Climate Change,

after 4.6 billion years

of

Very Extreme

Climate Change

on this Carbon based Earth

~ causing ~

the Carbon cycle

~ causing ~

Carbon based Life ~

~ causing ~

all the Carbon based Food we Eat

and all the Oxygen we Breathe,

~ causing ~

new carbon based life

You and Me

made from

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon Dioxide

~

Thomas F. Steyer

media@thenextgeneration.org

you are not a Scientist and have earned Zero right to Scientific Opinion,

Tom you are a Test Proven Liar and Fraud in Carbon and Climate Science,

for the sake of your Personal Feelings of Belief.

Tom,

Why do you deny the Reality

~ for your belief ~

Belief is: Religion

~

Belief in debunked Computer Prediction

is:

not ~ Reality

~

Belief in Hearsay

~ based ~

on debunked Computer Prediction

is:

not ~ Reality

~

…is there proof beyond only your debunked belief ~

that

Carbon based Humans

on this Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

all or any

Climate Change

~

 …everything I have and own,

for the Proof beyond your belief ~

in debunked Computer Prediction

~ that ~

carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Change.

~

All I want

is:

~ Your proof beyond Your belief in debunked Computer prediction ~

~

Ari Melber

~ of ~

MSNBC

is:

a test proven big Dummy

~ in ~

Science

~ of ~

the

Scientific Method

~

Ari,

what happened

to

Fact based Knowledge

~ you don’t care about Scientific Fact ~

you are apart of  ~

Bill Gates ~ MSNBC ~ for the sake of Belief and Money

~ not ~

Test Proven Knowledge of the Scientific Method

~

Ari,

you are a bogus Attorney for Belief and Money not Fact,

you are a test proven fraud in science for Money with zero Fact ~

~

~*~

~

co2uinfo

~ Correction ~

My Personal Professional

~ Apology ~

to:

David Sirota

I was thinking David Corn,

when I called Chris Matthews and David Sirota ~

Pathological Liars

~

David Sirota is ~ not ~ a Pathological Liar ~

David Sirota is: a Realist

and

a Test Proven Idiot in Science

of the Scientific Method.

~

David Sirota,

the next time your in Helena,

let me know ~

so we can do a test together in Science

~ proving ~

CO2 ~ causes ~ Cooling

~ not ~

Warming

~ then go have a Beer at the Tap Room at the Lewis and Clark Brewery on me.

~ Regards ~

Dr. Bruce A. Kershaw

Dyslexic

Atmospheric

Emission Scientist

since 1976

Carbon and Climate Science Investigator

since 2007

Writer ~ Editor

~ for ~

co2uinfo

Class of 1974

Helena High

Helena Montana

bruce@co2u.info

of the

Scientific Method

~

~*~

~

Climate Change is: Real

Climate Warming Paranoia for Profit

~ by ~

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

is:

~ not ~

Science ~ Knowledge

~ of ~

the

Scientific Method

~

Peer-reviewed ~ Belief

~ in ~

debunked ~ prediction

is:

~ not ~

Science knowledge

~ of ~

the

Scientific ~ Method

~

Science is: to ~ know ~

if you have not tested the Science knowledge,

then you do not ~ know ~

and have zero right to Scientific opinion.

~

Sometimes a little Reality beyond ~ Belief ~ can’t Hurt.

~

The ~ Hypothesis

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change is:

test proven ~ Religion

~ not ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

the Scientific Method

~ because ~

Reality is:

Tested ~ not ~ Believed

~

~ to believe is: to make believe ~

~

We Live in a World of Belief

~ where ~

Science is: to Know ~ not ~ Believed

~

Do You Believe Me ?

~

Do not ~ Believe ~ Me

Test the Science Knowledge

~

Science is never settled,

Science is an on going Tested ~ Debate

~ not ~

Believed

~

Belief is: Religion not Science

Science is: to Know ~

~

Should I doubt Religion in Science,

~ If I do ~

that would make me a Skeptic of belief in debunked prediction.

~

Today

Thanks to Politicians and Journalist

who are not Scientist,

who have zero back ground in Science,

who would Fail Grade School Science,

who do not Comprehend the Scientific Method,

Today

we Live in a world where Belief not Test Proven Fact

~ dictate Science ~

to the Scientific Community of the Scientific Method,

to the Scientific Community of Scientists

who have debunked the Hypothesis Belief ~

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

Climate Change

~

Politicians and Journalist

~ of ~

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

do not Question ~ debunked ~ Belief,

they Preach debunked Belief.

~

Political Media Climate Religion

was

~ debunked ~

by Test Proven Fact

before there was a

Political Media Climate Religion

~

Michael Mann,

no two Trees are alike,

and your Hockey Stick is as Bogus as a Three Dollar Bill

~ while ~

Belief in Computers Predicting the Future is not Science Knowledge.

Science is: Tested not Believed

How do I Test ~ your ~ Debunked Computer Predictions of the Future,

and how do ~ your ~ debunked Predictions

from the Computers ~ you ~ program to predict the Future

~ prove ~

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Change,

on this Carbon based Earth,

after 4.6 billion years of far more extreme Climate Change,

on this Carbon based Earth,

before there were Carbon based Humans,

on this Carbon based Earth

~cause ~

all climate change ?.

~

Michael

Your ~ Belief

in debunked Computer Prediction is: Test Proven Religion.

~

Michael Mann

~ ignores ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

the Scientific Method

for the sake of his Test Proven Religion

~ Proven by the Scientific Method ~

~

Increased Climate Warming increases CO2 levels,

increased CO2 levels do not increase Warming.

~

Michael is a proven Fraud in Science.

Michael Mann

~ ignores ~

more than a Dozen Climate Variables,

debunking his Religion

Michael Mann

~ ignores ~

the last 2 million years of Climate History,

debunking his Religion

Michael Mann

~ ignores ~

178 years of test proven CO2 Chemistry,

debunking his Religion,

~ while ~

Four Dozen NASA Scientists,

over 9,000 PhD’s

of over 30,000 Scientist

that I know of in the USA

disagree with

Michael Mann

and his True Belief in debunked Prediction.

~

~ a scientist of the Scientific Method would Test the Science ~ not ~ Believe ~

~

As CO2 levels Increase

the rate of Warming

by

the Hot Liquid Core of this Carbon based Earth

Heating the Lower Atmosphere

and by the

Extremely

Very Variable Sun

Heating the Solar System ~

the Warming continues to Slow.

~

Frozen

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide

Cools the Air

ten times faster than frozen water.

-200 Degree F CO2 from the upper atmosphere

plunging toward the Earth

as Hot air rises

cools the air faster than frozen water.

This is test proven chemistry for the last 100 years,

of 178 years of Test Proven Chemistry

proving CO2 causes Cooling

Ignored ~ by

Political Media

~ Paranoid ~

Climate Religion

~

In my on going seven years of investigation of Carbon and Climate Science Knowledge

~ I have yet to talk to a Geologist who agrees with Michael Mann ~

Most of the Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

who agree with Michael Mann ~

are not Scientist

and have earned zero right to any Scientific opinion,

but are True Believers in something they can not Prove with Science Knowledge.

~

That is ~ not ~ a test proven Scientific consensus,

that is test proven Baloney.

No one has taken a poll of all the Scientist on this Carbon based Earth,

of this brand new un tested Hypothesis being called Science.

~

There is a Political Media consensus of debunked belief in prediction

~ not a Scientific Consensus

of the Scientific Method.

~

Providing Test proven misinformation in Science to the Public is Fraud.

~

Michael Mann is a Preacher for Test Proven Climate Religion

not a Scientist of the Scientific Method.

~

Michael,

your Hypothesis was debunked before you thought of it,

by Test Proven Reality of the Scientific Method.

There is zero test proven knowledge to support your

Personal Feelings of ~ belief ~

Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

Climate Change

~

~*~

~

How much is Bill Gates and MSNBC

Paying

Michael Mann

to Preach his Test Proven Religion to the World,

and why do they Ignore Test Proven Science of the Scientific Method for

~ Their True Belief ~

and why will they not debate ~ their ~ True Belief,

in their debunked Hypothesis Belief.

~

MSNBC and Michael Mann

will not debate their Religion

~ proving ~

it is a Religion not Science.

They have zero desire to find and see Test Proven Reality

of the Scientific Method.

~

They Ignore all Test Proven Reality

~ for ~

Their

Personal Emotional Feelings of Belief in debunked Prediction

~

Why will Michael Mann not Test the Science that debunks his Pathological Belief ?

Because it is a Pathological Belief ~ not ~ Science of the Scientific Method,

Michael Mann

can not admit to himself or to the Carbon based People of this Carbon based World

that he is ~ wrong ~ while being Paid to Lie to the world by his Climate Religion.

~

Climate Change is Very Real

~ but ~

not caused by

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2)

or

Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

~

I ~ Challenge

Michael Mann

to an open Public debate in

Carbon and Climate Science,

beyond his Test Proven Religion.

~

Michael Mann

can not debate his debunked Belief,

~ because ~

it is not Science ~ it is debunked Belief in Computers Predicting the Future.

Prediction is not Science Knowledge,

belief in debunked prediction is: Religion,

~ not ~

Science Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

~

~*~

Skepticism is:

Doubting Religion in Science

~*~

~

To: Senator Bernie Sanders

From: Bruce A. Kershaw

~

Dear Bernie,

belief is: not reality

reality is: not believed or predicted

reality is: tested to ~ see reality

~

~ science is: to know ~

belief in debunked prediction is: not knowledge

belief in debunked prediction is: not reality

belief in debunked prediction is: Religion

~

To: Chuck Todd

Political Media

~ Journalist ~

covering only one side of the story,

the side he Believes in and can not prove ~

with Test Proven Science of the Scientific Method.

dailyrundown@msnbc.com

Dear Chuck,

you are not a Scientist of the Scientific Method,

~ but ~

you have an opinion in Climate Science ~ with out testing the Science,

you are a test proven fool in Climate Science,

because

you did not test the Science knowledge that debunks your True Belief,

you can prove nothing in Climate Science,

but you believe in something you can not prove.

that is:

Test Proven Religion not Science..

~ while ~

you will not allow a debate of the Test Proven Scientific Facts ~

that debunk ~ your ~ True Belief in Debunked Prediction,

once again proving it is a Test proven Religion

~ not Science of the Scientific Method.

Chuck,

you have earned zero right to Scientific Opinion,

while you are a test proven lair in Science,

as you Preach ~

you misinform the Public with only your Belief in zero test proven fact,

as you continue to Ignore Test proven Science that debunks your True Belief,

as you look the other way when test proven fraud is committed in Science.

~

Chuck Todd is:

a True Believer who will not Investigate the Test Proven Knowledge,

~ that debunks his True Belief,

proving once again ~ it is: a Religion not Tested Science of the Scientific Method.

~

Chuck Todd dose not want to know the Facts,

Chuck ~ wants ~ only to believe ~

~

I wonder how much

MS = Micro Soft

Bill Gates

NBC

Pays Chuck Todd to Lie and Misinform the Public.

~

Todd is a Puppet for Political Media Climate Religion

~

A ~ Good ~ Journalist Investigates ~ All ~ the Facts,

not just Believe Politicians who would fail Grade School Science.

~

Chuck Todd ~ will not acknowledge the four dozen NASA Scientist

or the more than 9,000 PhD’s

of over 30,000 Scientist

~ that I know of ~

who disagree with Chuck Todd and his Belief in zero Proven Fact.

~

Chuck Todd can Prove nothing beyond his personal feelings of Belief,

Chuck is a Test Proven Phony in Climate Science,

as is all of MSNBC

who can prove nothing beyond their Personal Feeling of Belief,

while rejecting Test Proven Reality ~

of the Scientific Method,

Proving it is a Political Media Climate Religion.

~

Climate Change is Real

Humans causing Climate Change is a Test Proven Lie,

by Political Media Climate Religion

~

~*~

~

Why do ~ Political Media Think Tanks ~ believe ~ instead of think ?

~ because ~

they do not comprehend ~ their ~ belief,

~ because ~

they do not test the Science.

They are Test Proven Belief Tanks ~ not ~ Think Tanks

~ they are Political ~ not ~ Scientific.

~

Political Media Hearsay Belief is:

not ~ test proven Science knowledge

of:

the Scientific Method.

~

~*~

~

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide

~ causes ~

Cooling ~ not ~ Warming

for the last 178 years of Test Proven Chemistry,

Chemistry ~ ignored ~ by Climate Religion.

~

Climate Religion Ignores

more than a dozen Climate variables that debunk Climate Religion

Climate Religion Ignores

the last two million years of Climate History that debunk Climate Religion.

~

Ignoring or Rejecting Test Proven Knowledge before Testing the knowledge

that Debunks your Hypothesis,

is not Science of the Scientific Method,

that is Test Proven Religion.

~

Chris Matthews and David Corn are Test Proven Pathological Liars,

who do not comprehend the words ~

Hypothesis ~ Debunked ~ and Believe,

who have zero Science Credentials,

and have earned zero right to any Scientific Opinion.

History will prove they are complete fools in Science.

~

David,

dcorn@motherjones.com

I have e-mailed you a few times,

Chris,

hardball@msnbc.com

I have e-mailed you hundreds of times,

with a reward for the Proof ~

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change.

Chris,

you keep using the word Science but you have yet to show the world this Science,

where are you hiding this Science you keep talking about and have yet to prove exist,

beyond your ~

Personal Feelings of Belief in your Debunk Hypothesis Prediction.

~

Chris and David,

why will your Religion ~ not ~ debate the Science?

~

The Ice has been melting ~

on this Carbon based Earth for 14,000 years,

not 40 years.

~

All the Ice on this Carbon based Earth,

has melted many times before,

there have been 20 Major Ice Ages in just the last 2 million years,

of  the last billion years of Ice ages,

on this Carbon based Earth ~

with some Ice Ages with higher levels of CO2 than today,

with Global Warming much warmer than this warming period between the Ice Ages,

with lower levels of CO2 than today.

~

Physicist

Michio Kaku

stated on MSNBC

~ maybe ~

Humans cause Climate Change,

while four dozen NASA Scientists

over 9,000 PhD’s

of over 30,000 Scientists

~ that I know of ~

just in the USA,

disagree with your ~ Belief ~ in Debunk Hypothesis.

~

That is not a Scientific Consensus.

~

Chris and David

who have zero right to scientific opinion

~ believe in ~

Political Media Climate Religion,

they believe in bogus Science

because

they are not smart enough to comprehend the knowledge that debunks their true belief.

~

Al Gore and Bill Nye

were caught

committing Test Proven Fraud in Science together,

while Chris and David look the other way.

~

I was told the EPA is being Investigated.

The EPA

Enforces (NOx) Emission Science Chemistry since 1970′s

that proves CO2 causes Cooling not Warming.

NOx Emission Science Chemistry I was Licensed to Test

for the State of California staring in 1976.

~

This is Test Proven Emission Science Chemistry only Automotive Scientists know,

while most PhD’s Teaching our children how to believe instead of who test the Knowledge

are not a where of and do not Comprehend.

~

Chris and David,

Belief in Computers Predicting the Future is: not Science Knowledge.

~

Maybe when MSNBC is done foaming at the mouth about ~ their ~ Test Proven Religion,

they will investigate the Science

of

the Scientific Method,

that debunks their Pathological ~ Belief ~

~

Climate Change is Real,

~ but ~

not caused by Carbon based Humans

on this Carbon based Earth.

~

Belief is: Religion not Test Proven Fact.

~

…does your ~ Belief ~ allow you to

~ See ~

Test Proven Reality?

~

Global Warming and Global Cooling is continuous for billions of years.

~

I agree with the tested reality,

~ climate change is: real ~

but

I do ~ not ~ agree with the belief in debunked prediction.

~

Nature will out live Humanity,

till one day ~

this Carbon based Earth’s Star we call the Sun ~

Vaporizes this Carbon based Earth.

~

Prediction is: Belief

Belief is: Prediction

~ causing ~

Religion

~

science is: to know

Prediction is: not Knowledge

Political Media Climate Religion is: not Reality or Science

~

Chris and David can prove nothing in Science,

they are Test Proven Lairs and Frauds in Climate Science,

because they are to stupid in Science to know it,

proving ~ their ~ Pathological belief is a Religion not Science,

they do not comprehend the words ~

Scientific Method

they are Political Media True Believers ~ not ~ Scientists of the Scientific Method,

they are Brain Washing the Public

with the Test Proven Garbage in their Pathological Political Media Talking Heads,

they are not just full of Test Proven Baloney they are Test Proven Frauds in Science

of the Scientific Method,

show us your test proven knowledge,

don’t preach to us your Religious Belief.

Don’t ~ tell me Chris ~ show me ~

Don’t ~ say it David ~ prove it ~

beyond your Pathological Belief.

Chris and David can Prove nothing.

Climate Religion can Prove nothing.

The Ocean has risen 350 feet in the last 26,000 years.

~

If you have not tested the Science then you have zero right to Scientific opinion.

Polling the non-Scientist Public about Science they have not tested

Proves nothing in Science.

Climate Religion will continue because it is a Religion not Science.

Climate Religion ~ rejects ~ the Scientific Method

for their feelings of belief in debunked Prediction.

The Ice will continue to melt ~

regardless of the level or percentage of

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide in the Atmosphere.

~

Water Vapor

and

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide

~ the CO2 caused by ~

Un-measurable Volcanic Activity below Sea Level

~ causing ~

up to seventy times the CO2 level the in the Ocean than in the Atmosphere

Evaporated from the Ocean

~ causing ~

the ~ Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ cycle

~ causing ~

all Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth,

above and below Sea level.

~

Climate Change is Real,

Climate Change caused by Humans is a Test Proven Religion,

proven by the Scientific Method.

~

~*~

~

Radley Horton

rh142@columbia.edu

~

Radley,

you have much to learn ~

from my 38 years of daily work experience in Emission Science.

Radley,

I Challenge you to an open Public Debate in Carbon and Climate Science,

with a

$50,000 Reward

for the proof

Carbon based Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

~ beyond ~

Your Personal Emotional Feelings of Belief

in

Debunked Hypothesis Perdition

that

Humans

~ cause ~

all or any

Climate Change.

~

Tested Reality ~ debunks ~ Belief in Prediction

~

Radley,

are you a True Believer ?

~ or ~

are you a Scientist of the Scientific Method ?

~

Belief

in

Debunked ~ Hypothesis ~ Prediction

is

Test ~ Proven ~ Religion

not

Science Knowledge

of

the

Scientific Method

~

~*~

The Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method is:

~ as ~

the level of

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide

~ continues ~

to rise

the rate of

Atmospheric Warming

~ continues ~

to slow down.

~*~

~

…there is nothing beyond belief in ~ debunked ~ prediction

~ to prove ~

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

Climate Change

on this

Carbon based Earth

~

~*~

Dr. Bruce A. Kershaw

Emission Science Chemistry

since 1976

Helena ~ Montana

bruce@co2u.info

~*~

~

~ From ~

my on going

Climate Science Investigation

six hours a day

since the spring of 2007

~

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

Carbon ~ Dioxide

One Carbon Atom ~ and ~ Two Oxygen Atoms

~ together ~

(CO2)

~ regardless ~

of

Carbon based Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

does not and can not

~ cause ~

Climate Warming ~ or ~ Climate Change

~

…the hardest part of finding tested reality for some is: accepting it ~

and for some it is much harder to find

and for others ~ never find.

~

 science is: test proven fact

~ not ~

belief ~ in ~ belief

~

Science is: the Art of Tested Reality

~ because ~

Science is: to Know

~

Political Science is: the Art of Political Deception Perception

~

Prediction is: not ~ Test Proven Fact

Belief in Prediction is: not ~ Knowledge or Reality

Belief in Prediction is: not ~ Science

~ because ~

science is: to ~ know

~

~ Words Prove Nothing in Science ~

The two ~ words ~ used by the United Nations

to prove

Humans cause ~ all ~ Climate Change

are

the words

Extremely and Likely

the words extremely likely

are ~ not ~ words of Hard Science Knowledge,

they are the words of

Firm ~ Belief

and

Prove nothing

in

Science of the Scientific Method.

~

The EPA

enforces emission science chemistry

since the 1970′s

that proves CO2 ~ causes ~ Cooling,

by lowering Combustion Temperatures 500 degrees

to lower (NOx) Nitrogen bonded to Oxygen emissions

to lower (O3) Oxygen emissions

~ Called Ozone ~

at ground level

to make the air we Breathe Cleaner

for

Humans ~ not ~ Nature

Nature ~ causing ~ Carbon based Humans.

~

Dry Ice is: Pure CO2

and cools the Air ten times faster than frozen water,

and now there is much more Dry Ice in the Atmosphere at -200* f

cooling the air ten times faster than frozen water

as it plunges toward the Earth as more Hot air rises.

~

178 years of Test Proven Chemistry proves CO2 causes Cooling not Warming,

~ while ~

this

Test Proven Knowledge is Ignored by

Political Media Climate Religion

~

~

Believing is: not Knowing

Belief does not ~ debunk ~ Test proven Fact

~ debunked ~

un ~ testable

Computer Predictions

do not ~ debunk ~ Test Proven Fact.

~

Prediction is: not Fact

Belief in debunked Prediction

~ based ~

on Test Proven Flawed Hypothesis

is ~ not ~ Science Knowledge

~ or ~

Tested Reality.

~

The National Climate Assessment is Based on Belief

~ in ~

Computers Predicting the Future

~ based on ~

Flawed ~ Debunked ~ Hypothesis

Belief

~ not ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method.

~

The Assessment Ignores ~ Test Proven Knowledge

~ the assessment ignores ~

all Climate Variables

all Climate History

and all Test Proven Chemistry

~

Ignored

~ because ~

the knowledge debunks ~ their ~ belief.

~

Climate Religion ~ refuses ~ Debate their Belief,

because

they can prove nothing

but ~ Belief

in Debunk Hypothesis.

~

~*~

Scientific Assessment of the Political Media Assessment

of

the Belief in Computers Predicting the Future

based on Belief

with zero Test Proven Fact.

~*~

~

Katharine Hayhoe

katharine.hahoe@ttu.edu

Political Scientist ~ not ~ Climate Scientist

~

Katharine,

Science Knowledge is never ~ Settled ~ in the Scientific Method,

Bloodletting and Burning Witches at the Stake was settled Science too.

~

~ Extreme Climate Change is Very Real ~

for the past 4.6 Billion Years.

Climate Change is Very Real Today

~ but ~

not caused by

Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth.

Ignoring reality dose not debunk reality.

There are more than a Dozen Known Climate Variables,

Two Million years of Climate History,

and 178 years of Test Proven Chemistry,

that Debunk your Assessment,

this is very import very proven

Climate and Carbon Science Knowledge

~ missing ~

from your Assessment ~

of your Political Media Belief in your Computers Predicting the Future,

maybe you should incorporate all Climate Knowledge in to ~ your ~ Predictions,

not just your debunked belief in your belief in Computers Predicting the Future

~ also known in the Scientific Community as ~

Ouija Board Science.

~

Katharine,

Chris Hayes of MSNBC called you a Climate Scientist,

that is a proven Lie.

~

Katharine,

Climate Change is: Real

~

Humans causing Climate Change is:

~ Debunked ~

Political Media Hypothesis Belief in Prediction

~ Debunked ~

by Test Proven Fact

 Ignored by your Belief in debunked prediction.

~

Katharine,

I challenge you to an open public debate in Carbon and Climate Science.

~

Katharine will not debate her Climate Religion,

just like Chris Hayes or Anyone at MSNBC

because

~ they can not prove ~

in any way

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change on this Carbon based Earth,

they reject Test Proven Knowledge for their True Pathological Belief.

~

Katharine is a Test Proven Lair,

~ because ~

Katharine is not smart enough to Comprehend

~ the ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method

~ that ~

debunks her true belief

~ because ~

Katharine is a Political Scientists ~ not ~ a Scientist of the Scientific Method

Katharine has never ~ Investigated, Reviewed, Analyzed or Tested ~

the Science Knowledge,

that debunks her ~ True Belief ~

~

Katharine is the Author of the National Climate Assessment,

Katharine is a Preacher for Political Media Climate Religion

~ not ~

a Scientist of the Scientific Method.

Katharine is a Test Proven Lair and Phony in Science.

~

Climate Change is Real

~

Katharine

can not ~ prove ~ in any way

Carbon based Humans or Carbon based Oxygen (CO2)

~ cause ~

Climate Change

on this Carbon based Earth.

~

Katharine Believes what she is told to

~ believe ~

That is not Test Proven Knowledge,

that is Belief in ~ debunked ~ Prediction.

~

Katharine Hayhoe

your Climate Assessment is not Science,

it is a Bogus Political Statement

for Political Media Climate Religion.

Katharine your true Belief has been debunked by Test Proven Reality.

Test Proven Reality you will continue to Ignore,

for the sake of your True Belief in zero Test Proven Fact.

~

There is nothing beyond Bogus and Debunked

~ Prediction ~

to prove Humans cause Climate Change.

~

Katharine Hayhoe

has earned zero right to Scientific Opinion

of

The Scientific Method

~

Katharine Hayhoe will not debate her

~ Test Proven ~

Political Media Climate Religion.

~

Katharine,

your Debunked Belief ~ has yet to prove in any way

that

Humans cause Climate Change.

~

~*~

Test Proven Reality

~ in ~

Carbon and Climate Science

~*~

~

To: John Podesta

Counselor to President Obama

~ You are not a Scientist ~

giving you zero right to Scientific opinion.

Climate Change is Real

~ but ~

not ~ Caused ~ by

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide

~ or ~

by

Carbon based Humans

~ on this ~

Carbon based Earth

~

John,

Your Assessment Ignores

more than a dozen Climate Variables

all Climate History

and

178 years of Test Proven Chemistry

that

~ debunks ~

Your Climate Assessment

based on

Debunked Prediction Hypothesis ~ not ~ Test Proven Fact

John,

your true belief is

Test Proven to be

Flawed Unproven Debunked Hypothesis Prediction

~ causing ~

Climate Paranoia

~

There is more Science Missing from the Assessment than in the Assessment.

The ~ missing ~ Science

~ debunks ~

The Flawed Assessment

~

The National Climate Assessment

is based solely on flawed and debunked Belief.

~

John,

you should invite the

Four dozen NASA Scientists

and the more than 9000 PhD’s

out of more than 30,000 Scientists

of the Scientific Method

~ that I know of ~

who disagree with You and the Climate Studies,

and invite them to the White House,

and get their two cents worth,

instead of ignoring them.

~

The Presidents Statements on Climate Change

are based on Stupidity not Test Proven Fact,

why does the White House Ignore Test Proven Knowledge that debunks ~ their ~ Belief ?

~ MONEY ~

and

the Test Proven Stupidity

of

Special Interest Groups

that would and have Failed Grade School Science.

Climate Belief is not Climate Science of the Scientific Method,

it is Political Media Climate Religion,

by Very Closed Minds.

~

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide

is:

the by-product of Climate Warming not the cause of Climate Warming.

~

The White House Climate Assessment

is:

Test Proven

Bogus Political Media Garbage

~ not ~

Climate Science

~ while ~

Predictions are only wrong 99.9999% of the time,

~ while ~

the Belief in debunked Prediction is Religion.

~

John,

The Assessment

does not prove in any way

Carbon based Humans ~

on this

Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

All or Any

Climate Change

~

~*~

~

To:

Juliet Eilperin

~ of ~

The Washington Post

White House Corespondent

~ and ~

Alex Wagner ~ and ~ MSNBC

~ sponsored ~

Opinion ~ not ~ Test Proven Fact

misleading

misinforming

Humanity

with only words of Belief

~ with zero  ~

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge

~ of ~

The Scientific Method

~

MS~NBC

is:

Stating to the World ~

97 % of Scientists Agree that Humans cause ~ all ~ Climate Change,

that is:

a very

~ Proven ~

very

~ Documented ~

Political Media Lie

~ while ~

The President of the United States

Barack Obama

can ~ not ~ prove

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide

~ regardless ~

of

Carbon based  Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

~ cause ~

All ~ or ~ Any

Climate Warming

~ causing ~

All or Any

Climate Change

~

The White House has Political Media ~ Belief ~ Support ~ not ~ Scientific Support.

~

Four Dozen NASA Scientists,

over 9000 PhD’s

of over 30,000 Scientists

~ that I know of ~

just in the United States

disagree with the

~

some say 200

some say 240

some say 300

~

~ so called ~

Scientist of the

National Climate Assessment

who are Political ~ not ~ Scientific

Who can prove nothing ~

in Tested Science Knowledge ~ of ~ the Scientific Method

beyond only their

Political Words of Feeling of Belief.

~

That is not a ~ Scientific ~ Consensus.

~

There is a Political Media ~ Belief ~ Consensus

of

Words of Political Media Feelings of Belief ~

that

Prove nothing

in Tested Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method.

~

I Challenge the White House Political Media National Climate Assessment

~ to an open public debate in ~

Climate Science Knowledge

~ not ~

Political Media Climate Belief

~ with a ~

$25,000 Reward

for the Scientific Proof

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

All or Any

Climate Warming

causing

All and Any

Climate Change

~

~*~

~

To: The American Lung Association

~ Smog ~

is:

Smoke and Fog together,

most of the Smoke on this Carbon based Earth is caused by Nature

~ not ~

by Carbon based Humans

~ while ~

all of the Fog on this Carbon based Earth is caused by Nature

~ not ~

by Carbon based Humans,

while your Bogus Political Definition of Smog with your Bogus Political Evaluation of

Air Quality in Helena Montana

Proves

only your lack of Comprehension of Atmospheric Emission Science,

and Changes Nothing in Nature

while your statements provide Zero Scientific usefulness,

other than try to make Carbon based Humans feel guilty for burning wood to survive.

~

The American Lung Association,

has given Helena Montana an F- for Air Quality,

I wonder if  the F- is to God the cause of all dirty air caused by Nature in Helena,

your just to the Carbon based Humans of Helena who must Burn Carbon based Wood

to keep from from Freezing to Death during Global Warming,

when it is only – 30* F below Zero outside,

that’s only 60 plus degrees colder than water freezing,

~ sometimes ~

weeks at a time.

~

The first Emission Control Device on an Automobile was in 1960

Today

the air we breathe is very much cleaner than before

and continues to be cleaner not dirtier,

and for those who burn wood to survive the cold of Global Warming here in Helena,

are in fact burning their carbon based Wood very cleanly than in years past,

and as the ash from the wood fuel falls to the ground it does no harm to the soil,

the Ash in fact helps promote Healthy rejuvenation of Mineral depleted soil.

~

Photos and Videos

~ of ~

White Steam coming out of Smoke Stakes is: not ~ Pollution

~

The Public Statements by the American Lung Association are Political

~ not ~

Factual or Informative

they ~ are

~ Deceptive ~

in nature

~

~*~

~

Published

Peer-Reviewed

Computer Prediction

based

on what is

Test Proven Flawed Science Hypothesis

only proves

Stupidity

by

Politicians and Journalist

who are

the

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

~

Politics and Religion

~ control ~

this

Carbon based Earth

~ Not ~

Test Proven Reality

~

…when will Political Media Climate Belief

~ Stop ~

and Test the Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method,

that debunks their ~ True Belief.

~

I do not Believe

~ I Look Test and See ~

to Find ~ Know and See

Tested Reality.

~

…on this Carbon based Earth ~

~

~*~

~

Carbon based Humans

~ eat ~

Carbon based Food,

of All the Carbon based Foods we Carbon based Humans Eat

on this Carbon based Earth,

~ Corn ~

contains more

Carbon

than all the other Carbon based Foods.

~

…a recent study by the U.S. Government Shows us ~

when Corn Ethanol is added to Gasoline

it Produces more CO2 than Gasoline without Corn Ethanol.

~

I knew that seven Years ago from my daily Testing with my 4- Gas Emissions Analyzer,

I have been using Emissions Analyzers Professionally since 1976.

~

The U.S. Government spent Millions ~ hopefully not Billions of Dollars,

to tell Me what I already know,

from my 36 Years of Daily Work Experience in Emissions Testing.

~

Gasoline is: (HC) ~ Hydrocarbon ~ Hydrogen and Carbon,

Hydrogen with out the Carbon is:

~ { Rocket Fuel } ~

Hydrogen and Carbon together is far more Stable than Hydrogen without Carbon.

~

I do not wish to drive around Helena Montana

~ with ~

very unstable Rocket Fuel in the fuel tank of my Carbon based Car,

I would prefer stable Carbon based Hydrogen over unstable Hydrogen,

just in case I should ever be in a serious car accident.

Carbon Retards Energy while lowering the Explosion Temperature,

making the Hydrogen more Stable and Safer to work with and use as Safer Energy,

~ causing ~

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide

and is what the Carbon based Food we grow requires to Breathe

~ while ~

our Carbon based Food is making the Oxygen we Breathe

made from the Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide,

making this Carbon based Earth

Very Alive and Very Green

called the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

~ Cycle ~

recycle

~

Emission Science Chemistry Enforced by the EPA since 1970′s

uses

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide

to lower combustion Temperatures 500 Degrees

to lower ~ (NOx) Emissions

to Lower ~ (O3) Oxygen ~ called Ozone

at ground level

to Lower Respiratory Illness.

~

Chemistry Enforced by the EPA

Proves

~ CO2 ~

is a Refrigerant in combustion to make the Air we Breathe

~ cleaner ~

since 1970′s

~

Dry Ice

is

Pure CO2 Frozen

and

Cools the Air Ten Times Faster than Frozen Water,

Twenty Times Longer than Frozen Water.

~

178 years of Test Proven ~ CO2 ~ Chemistry

Ignored by Climate Religion

~ proves ~

Carbon based Oxygen ~ CO2 ~ Carbon Dioxide

Retards Energy while absorbing Energy like a Sponge,

making the surrounding Gases Cooler,

CO2 causes Cooling ~ not ~ Warming,

~ while ~

causing

all Carbon based Life,

on this carbon based Earth.

~

~ Now ~

add more than a dozen proven

Climate Variables

~ Ignored ~

and missing

from

Climate Religion

~ proving ~

Carbon based Humans

do not

~ cause ~

Climate Change

~

Today we are Pumping CO2 into the Ground,

when CO2 finds its way to underground Water,

it turns the Water in to an Acid.

~

When removing or preventing CO2 from being

Recycled

by the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

~ Cycle ~

you are removing the O2 of CO2

that came from the air we Breathe and used to Burn the (HC) Hydrogen Carbon fuel.

Pumping CO2 in to the Ground is not allowing the O2 From the Air we Breathe

to be recycled back in to the air we Breathe

~ where it came from ~

reducing the level of Oxygen in the air we breathe,

~ while ~

reducing the Carbon based Oxygen required by Plants and Trees to live

and make Oxygen from.

~

~*~

Growing Forward

~*~

~

science ~ is: to ~ know

~ belief in debunked prediction by Computers

based on

Test Proven Flawed Science by Flawed Hypothesis

~ is:

not ~ knowledge

~

To: Steve Kornacki ~

Carol Davenport ~

Alex Bozmoski ~

Sam Stein ~

You are Journalist ~ not ~ Scientists ~

You have earned ~ zero ~ right to any Scientific Opinion,

while

Bill Nye

the Science Guy,

is a Test Proven Fraud in Science,

paid by Bill Gates and Al Gore,

who are Test proven Frauds in Science too.

Steve,

Al Gore and Bill Nye,

were caught Red Handed doing a Bogus Experiment

to prove Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) and Carbon based Humans

cause

~ all ~

Climate Change.

~

Steve,

why don’t you talk to one of the four dozen NASA Scientists,

or one of the more than 9,000 PhD’s

of more than over 30,000 Scientists

~ that I know of ~

who disagree with the

~ Test Proven Frauds in Science ~

Steve,

no one I know of ~ Denies ~ Climate Change,

~ while ~

Climate Religion

~ lives in denial ~

of more than a dozen

Proven Natural Variable Progressive Climate Factors for Climate Change,

Millions of Years of Climate History

and

178 years of Test Proven Chemistry

~ that proves ~

Carbon based Oxygen (CO2) Carbon Dioxide

causes

Cooling ~ not ~ Warming

~

Steve,

Why don’t you investigate the Science,

instead of just believing the Test Proven Frauds in Science.

~

The Climate Science Consensus ~ is:

a ~ Test ~ Proven Lie

invented by

Paranoid Political Media Climate Religion.

Regards

Dr. Bruce A. Kershaw

~

P.S.

Steve,

how much is Bill Gates Paying You to support

Political Media Fraud in Science?

~ and ~

why does MSNBC

~ Look ~

the other way when Test Proven Fraud is committed in Science?

~

Climate Change is a Test Proven Fact,

Climate Change caused by Carbon based Humans

on this

Carbon based Earth

~ is:

 a Test Proven Political Media Religion

in denial of

Proven Fact Tested Science Knowledge of the Scientific Method.

~

I am not in denial of Climate Change

~ while ~

I reject Test Proven Fraud in Climate Science.

Test Proven Fraud

by

Political Media Climate Religion

~

~ they are Liars and Frauds ~

caused ~ by ~ their

paranoid ~ pathological

~ Belief ~

in

Stupidity for the sake of Belief

~

while for many others

Climate Religion

~ is:

just for ~ Profit

~

~*~

$50,000

Reward

for the proof

Greenhouse Gases

are no longer the ~ by-product ~ of Atmospheric Warming

and are now the ~ cause ~ of Atmospheric Warming

~*~

~

~ Ignoring ~

Proven Fact Tested Science

of

The Scientific Method

for

Personal Emotional Feelings of Belief

in

Debunked ~ Prediction

and

Fraud

is

Test Proven

Political Media Climate Religion

~ not ~

Knowledge

~

…weather it is belief in God

or belief in Test Proven Fraud ~

Religion is Religion

~

Those who Truly believe with all their Hart and Soul

that

Carbon is Poison and Pollution

on this Carbon based Earth ~

Carbon

causing the Carbon cycle ~

Carbon

causing all Carbon based Life

all the carbon based food we Eat

and all the Oxygen we Carbon based Humans Breathe

on this Carbon based Earth

are

Test Proven Fools

~ not ~

Scientists

of the Scientific Method.

~

~*~

~

Science of the Scientific Method

has nothing to do with

Politics and Religion

~ while ~

Political Media Climate Religion

~ Dictates ~

Science to Scientists of the Scientific Method.

~

Test Proven

Science Fiction

does not prove

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

Climate Change

~*~

~