The Rebuttal ~ Joe Berry & Stanford Woods Institute = Fraud


Energy and all Life is based on Progressive Change

as all Life is the byproduct of Energy

and as all Life creates new energy as the new energy then creates all new Life

in a continuous Energy and Life Cycle and Recycle

for the past 600 million years above sea level

as the Exhaust from the Internal Energy = Hot Liquid Core of this Carbon based Earth

is the cause of all Primary Life = all the Carbon based Plants and Trees

making the Oxygen we Breathe and Carbon based Food we Eat

from water vapor and CO2

causing the Environment for Secondary Carbon based Life = You and Me

as we Exhale CO2 for Plants and Trees the Breathe

and when we Burn dead Plants and Trees

we are making more CO2 for Plants and Trees to Breathe

your car exhaust is making Plants and Trees

as the Earth generates CO2 making Primary Life = Plants and Trees

making the Environment for Secondary Life you and Me

and the more CO2 we make the Greener this Carbon based Earth

and as warm CO2 rises Frozen CO2 Dry Ice is crashing back downward

cooling the air 10 times faster and 20 times longer than frozen water

more than offsetting warm CO2 rising

as weather and climate change go back 4.6 billion years

on this Carbon based Earth

as Paranoia Preaches Paranoia for Votes for Political Power Control and Greed

by those who can Articulate and Comprehend zero Science

proving Political Agenda has nothing to do with Questioned Tested Debated Science

as they continue to reject Science for their Preached Paranoia for Votes

as they continue to Preach to us their Paranoid Prediction

based on proven to be flawed incomplete fraudulent Science

that all the Ice will melt and entire nations will be underwater

and after repeatedly making this Lunatic prediction for over 30 plus years

that never come true

they have changed their Lunatic Fraudulent Prediction for votes from this year to 2030

based on test proven fraud in Science

~ because ~

In Real Physics

~ All Heat Rises ~

and any Climate Science that just ignores ~ all heat rises ~ is Garbage Science

and any Climate Science that just ignores

the past 500 years of Hard Science is Garbage Science

as climate science is a brand new science

and we do not know more than we do know

and you can not just ignore and throw away all real science for Persuaded Belief

as Belief can not debunk Science


Science is based on Question Test Rebuttal Debate

~ Question ~

Is Joe Berry a Fraud because he is a Lunatic

or a Fraud caused by his Ignorance

or is Joe Berry just a Fraud who knows he is a Fraud ?


Joe Berry and his Preached Paranoia are not Real Science

as all of living Breathing Nature has debunk Joe Berry’s Unproven Theory

as Joe’s unproven debunked science rejects basic Physics and Chemistry

for his True Belief in debunked unproven theory he refuses to publicly debate

proving Joe is not a real scientist

as Joe Rejects the past 500 years of hard science debunking his True Belief


Joe will not answer the questions of hard science debunking his belief

Joe will not acknowledge

all heat rises in real physics

as all gases absorb and radiate heat while expanding and rising

including heated CO2

leaving a avoid for Frozen air to come crashing downward

causing the Ice Caps at the Poles of this Carbon based Earth

while more heat has escaped the Atmosphere than Predicted

as Joe will not acknowledge

Frozen CO2 = Dry Ice

cools the air 10 times faster and 20 times longer than frozen water

and as all warm CO2 rises ~ removing ~ heat from the lower Atmosphere

the very frozen CO2 = Dry Ice is crashing back downward

as the frozen CO2 more than offset the heat leaving the lower atmosphere

providing a cooling effect

as Joe will not acknowledge millions of years of known Climate History

further debunking his true Belief

as Joe will not acknowledge Ice Core science

proving Ice ages with much higher levels of CO2 than in the air today

as Joe just ignores more than a dozen climate variables known today

as Joe believes ~ one half ~ of one climate variable defines all climate Science

as Joe told me years ago

their is nothing further to debate

in this brand new Climate Science no one has a real degree in

based only on one fragment of all known climate science

and as his Climate Religion Preaches

the science is settled

in this brand new science

as their settled Lunatic science rejects all known science debunking their true belief

proving it is a Lunatic Paranoid Religion doing test proven harm to the Carbon Cycle

costing trillions of dollars to do only harm to the cause of Green causing the Environment

CO2 + Water Vapor + Sun Energy = Green

as only the proven frauds are allowed a voice in the media

and those who have proven the fraud in science are called Deniers and Skeptics

as real science is based on

~ skepticism ~

” the doctrine that the truth in all knowledge must always be in Question “

as skepticism is the bases for the Scientific Method

to Question Test Rebuttal Debate

as Climate Religion Preaches skepticism is a Mental Flaw

as they make believe to question the truth to find and know the truth

is a mental disorder

proving they are Lunatics

as they Preach debunked unproven theory is settled science

proving they failed and reject 5th grade science

and as Scientifically Proven

you can not stop Lunatic Persuaded Make Believe

with test proven facts debunking the Belief = Pathological

as the Media who have earned zero right to scientific opinion

worship the test proven Frauds doing harm to the Environment for Profit

as the Media continues to Preach test proven Lies in Science

as they continue to Preach their Doomsday Climate Paranoia

based on test proven fraud in science

as they refuse to allow rebuttal to test proven Lies

Proven Lies they Truly Believe for their Political Agenda


knowing settled science does not exist in real science

while debunked unproven theory is Preached as Settled Science

and this can only Prove they are Lunatics and Frauds



the vast Majority of the Atmosphere is – 200 degrees below zero


as long as all heat rises in real physics


frozen air is always crashing downward to fill the void of warm air rising


there will always be Ice Caps at the Poles of this Carbon based Earth


of what test proven Frauds and Lunatic Preach for Profit


and only Lunatics just Ignore 500 years of hard science

debunking their Lunatic Paranoid Climate Religion

as Proven fact tested fraud in science is Preached as proven fact tested reality by the Media

who can only prove they failed 3rd grade science

as their Opinion is based on test proven Ignorance

 they refuse to debate


their Lunatic Paranoid Science is Settled

and so what is their to question test rebuttal debate in this brand new science

they do not comprehend

as they Fraudulently Preach Doomsday Paranoia to our Youth

doing only Harm to the Environment

because they reject the scientific method for Lunatic Paranoid Political Agenda


to be continued


science = to know

and Preached Fear of the Unknowable Future based on Debunked Unproven Theory

is Paranoia not Science

as only real Scientists can admit they are wrong when proven wrong

and Learn and Know and Grow Forward

as True Believers believe they are never wrong and always right

even when proven wrong

as you can not stop Pathological Belief with Factual Science

as you can debunk belief with knowledge but can not stop belief with knowledge

as True Believers are Blinded by their Belief

as belief refuses to debate the knowledge

as belief rejects knowledge for belief

and opinion based on unquestioned belief is not real science

as the truth in knowledge must always be in Question

as real science is to know = factual and not belief = pathological

and we can not allow ourselves to just believe in proven Pathological Lies

and then Preach the Unquestioned Proven Lies are Science

as we live with very proven Fraud in Science today

that is just ignored by the True Believers who own and control the Media

who reject Question Test Rebuttal Debate to find the Truth in Science

as NASA Data Debunk

Catastrophic Climate Warming

and Debunk the Sea level is Rising

and prove a 40% increase in Sea Ice

as 49 NASA Scientists who have zero voice in the media agree with this Data

while the NASA Political Wing Nuts who do have a voice in the Media

do not share the Truth of their own Data

as they continue to Preach their Political Media Doomsday Climate Paranoia

based on many Proven Lies they just believe in based on zero question test debate

while ignoring their own Data proving they are Political Lairs

as NASA will not allow Public Question Test Rebuttal Debate of their proven Lies

as the U.N. IPCC state it is likely Humans cause climate warming

based on Proven to be a Flawed Incomplete Study

based on Proven to be Political Lies and Proven to be Fraudulent Data

as Likely is Belief not Science

as it is likely to rain tomorrow but likely does not scientifically prove it will rain

just as it is likely the next over due supper volcano will kill all but 15 breeding woman

just like 74,000 years ago and proven by our DNA Funnel

just as we are likely to have another 20 Ice Ages over the next 2 million years

and we are just as likely to all die from the next Asteroid

or from Nuclear War

and the majority of us in the USA would die

in under 30 days if our Power Grid was shut off for less than 30 days


CO2 + Water Vapor + Sun Energy = Green = Food and Oxygen and the Environment

as Ignorance Dictate Ignorance

spending trillions to reduce the cause of Green

as the cause of Green is the evaporated byproduct of climate warming

not the cause of climate warming

as scientifically proven and Ignored by the Preached Belief in Ignorance

and is proven Political Media Insanity and not Real Science

by those who continue to refuse to allow Question Test Rebuttal Debate

as they reject the scientific method for Preached Fraudulent Lunatic Belief

and belief in debunked unproven theory is Political Science Fiction doing only Harm

as the True Believers just ignore the harm they are doing to the Environment

as they refuse to learn and know and grow forward beyond their Lunatic make believe

as the cause of the Carbon Cycle with Oxygen and Hydrogen

causing all Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth

is not Toxic Poison and Pollution

as Preached by Political Media Brainwashed Lunatics

and the only thing they have scientifically proven is their Ignorance

and when you refuse to acknowledge the very real very logical

Questions of Real Science

then you are not a Real Scientist

as the bases for all science is to Question the Truth in Knowledge and when their can be no Questions then their can be no Truth and when you can not apply the very Basics of  Physics and Chemistry to your Climate Science its not real

and if there was zero CO2 there would be zero Greenhouse

and the more CO2 the Greener the Greenhouse


To: Joe Berry

Stanford University

About Bruce A. Kershaw

Born ~ March 27, 1956 at 11:10 pm Long Beach California other wise I'm still breathing O2 made from CO2 and eating food made from CO2 ~ the rest is Icing on the cake ~
This entry was posted in CO2 and Global Warming. Bookmark the permalink.