If Joe Berry can not prove it then How can you ?


Human caused climate warming is based on a

Scientifically Debunk Unproven Theory

supported by a Climate Study that just ignores many known climate variables

scientifically proving it is not a Scientific Study


~ The Climate Emergency ~

Catastrophic Climate Warming

Catastrophic Ice Melt

Catastrophic Sea Level Rise

is all a Scientifically Proven Lie

for Power Control and Profit for the Few who Publicly fail Grade School Science

and are Harming the cause of Green for Profit


Sea Ice has increased by 40% since 2012

and Sea levels continue to have a very minimal rise and decline

while Humans have been moving to higher ground

for the past 20,000 to 26,000 years

while Sea levels have been much higher than now many times before in the past

of this Carbon based Earths Geological History

and for many years now the Glaciers in Montana are Growing not Shrinking

as the Glaciers have come and gone many times before in Earths Geological History

as this Earth has a known Geological History

of a known Cycle of Ice Ages and Warming Periods

caused by the variable Sun with many known cycles

as the Sun continues to be warmer and brighter

but for now the Ski Seasons in Montana are getting longer

as Montana Winters have become harder and longer over many years

while 1000 years ago Montana had California Climate for 200 years

and it was warmer in Montana during the Dust Bowl of the 1930’s


question test rebuttal debate

~ question ~

How do you stop 4.6 Billion years of variable climate change ?

caused by more than a dozen climate variables

~ missing from the Flawed Incomplete climate study ~

~ question ~

… and how many of the past 40 years of many ~

Computer Ouija Board Doomsday Predictions

of the unknowable future have come true ?

Obviously None

~ question ~

…and how many of the past 1000 years of many Doomsday Predictions

of the unknowable future have come true ?

 Obviously None


…and today only those who Believe In Climate Religion are allowed a Voice ~

scientifically proving only Fascist Brainwashed Ignorance has a Voice in Science

that continues to reject all Question Test Rebuttal Debate

while providing only a false realty doing only proven harm in tested reality


To: Maya van Rossum

Environmental Attorney

who can not Scientifically Prove Humans cause Climate Warming ~

and I will continue to send this page to Maya

maybe everyday maybe not

but no response from Maya Yet

while I will continue to write this science argument to Maya

and I will allow Maya to Rebuttal back

and allow an open public debate in science

as the Laws of Science and the Science of Law are one in the same

July 9 ~11


~ The Rebuttal ~

for the Tested Truth in All of Life and Knowledge

for a Better Life for All


…as we now live with Politically Dictated Science

by those who fail 3rd Grade Science

on this CO2 starved Carbon based Earth

where the cause of Green is:

~ Evaporated by the variable Sun ~

CO2 + Water Vapor + more Sun Energy = Green

causing Food and Oxygen

and causing the carbon cycle with oxygen and hydrogen

while proving the byproduct of carbon based energy is:

all carbon based Life

on this proven to be CO2 starved Carbon based Earth

where this Earth and everything on this carbon based earth

are held together by carbon


There is Far to much Oil in the Ground

to be caused by Dead Dinosaurs

and Far Far to much Oil Far Far to Deep below the Flour of the Oceans

to be caused by Dead Dinosaurs


The Oil


 Hydrogen and Carbon = Hydrocarbon = (HC)

and the oil has always been here

just as Water = Hydrogen and Oxygen = (H2O)

has always been here

where the Carbon based Human Body is:

Carbon Oxygen and Hydrogen

~ caused by ~

The Carbon Cycle


Oxygen and Hydrogen


The Carbon Oxygen Hydrogen Cycle of Recycle

to be continued


and when you remove CO2

~ Carbon and Oxygen bonded together by Heat and Energy ~

 from the Air with CO2 Scrubbers

and then Pump the CO2 into the Ground

you are then removing from the air what Pants and Trees need ~ more ~ of to breathe

and you are removing Oxygen from the air too ~

because you are not allowing the Carbon Cycle to Recycle the Oxygen

that came from the air

 back into the air where it came from ~

while turning under ground water into an Acid

by Those Democratic Billionaires

who reject the Scientific Method of Question Test Rebuttal Debate

as these proven Frauds in science have decide for everyone what is best for everyone

while doing only test proven harm to all of Nature for Profit

~ when ~

reducing the cause of Green and Oxygen will have zero effect on climate change

but will allow Nitrogen from Decomposing soil to further reduce the Cause of Green

and ending the Carbon Cycle above Sea level sooner

and ending all Carbon based Life above Sea level Sooner


The Natural Death of all Life above Sea level will be from a lack of CO2

on this Scientifically proven to be CO2 Starved Carbon based Earth

as Plants and Trees need 3 to 4 times the CO2 than in the air today to breathe Healthy

~ and there can be no open public ~

there can be no Question Test Rebuttal and Debate on this Subject matter

so we can stop wasting many tens of trillions of dollars

to do only Harm to the Carbon Cycle


There have been Ice Ages with many times the CO2 in the Air than today

and this is knowledge ~

missing from the proven to be flawed incomplete Climate Study

as those who Fascistly Dictate Science for Profit

continue to Fail 3rd Grade Science


Joe Berry Stanford University

can not Scientifically Prove Humans cause Climate Warming



~ Reward ~

for the peer-reviewed science

~ Proving ~

Carbon based Humans made by and from this CO2 Starved Carbon based Earth

~ Cause ~

Climate Warming


The Primary source of Heat for this Carbon based Earth


The variable Hot Churning Liquid Core of this Carbon based Earth

Heating the Earths Crust the Oceans and Lower Atmosphere

and variably Melting the Ice from the Bottom Side

as the variable hot spots of this earth variably move

causing ice to melt from the bottom side a

t different rates at different times at different locations

just as volcanic activity above and below sea level variably moves

as Volcanic activity is Interment everywhere

as the majority of volcanic activity is below sea level

causing the majority of CO2 above sea level

causing the carbon cycle above sea level

causing all carbon based life above sea level


The Secondary source of Heat for this Carbon based Earth


The variable Sun with many known cycles

and variably Melting the Ice from the Top Side


Now Incorporate more than a Dozen other climate variables

Missing from the Climate Study


the variable distance between the variable Sun and the variable Earth

and the variable Hole in the Ozone

along with many other known Weather and Climate variables

missing from the proven to be very flawed and incomplete climate study

preached as settled science

~ in a New Science ~

when settled science does not exist

but only if you comprehend 5th Grade Science

and if the Science is Settled then why does the Climate Study continue ?

and why have all the Computer Ouija Board Doomsday Predictions Failed to Happen ?

and if the Science is Settled why are there so many unanswered Questions ?

and why is there more available science missing from the study than in the Study ?

why is there no Question Test Rebuttal Debate allowed by the Study ?

why does the Study reject the Scientific Method ?

why is the Study Full of Proven Lies


The Science is Settled

all proving it is not a real Scientific Study

as we spend many tens of trillions of Dollars on Scientifically Proven lies

that will have zero effect on climate change

but will make many criminal billionaires who got Joe Biden Elected

very much richer

while doing only harm to all living Nature and the Carbon Cycle


Question Test Rebuttal Debate

~ Question ~

Why are we Deliberately doing proven Harm to the Cause of Green

CO2 + Water Vapor + Sun Energy = Green

when it is clearly proven CO2 is the evaporated byproduct of Warming

and not the cause of Warming

Proving Criminal Billionaire Lunatics


Lunatic Political Science Fiction for their Profit Power and Control

Shared with China

as China Starts up a New Coal Fired Power Plant every week

and we send them our coal and oil and natural gas everyday

and China will not be Shutting Down these Brand New Coal Fired Power Plants

anytime in the near future

as we are forced to buy their Green Garbage that Fails before it can pay for itself

and what is most Interesting to me

the majority of my readers live in China

where they are far better educated in Science

than in America where the majority of People fail 3rd Grade Science

and Political Media Brainwashed Lunatic Climate Religion is doing very well

~ while ~

Joe Berry & Steve Running

are on the Same Climate Science Team

and Steve has Preached to all of us since 2007

” the Sun is not a climate variable “

while Joe says the variable Sun with many known cycles ~ is ~ a climate variable

proving there is no scientific consensus on the same climate science team

while Steve Running has Clearly Proven over the many years to me

that he is a proven Lair and Fraud in Science


not one of their Computer Ouija Board Climate Predictions

of the unknowable future

based on their Debunk unproven theory

obviously has not Come True

only further Debunking their already Self Debunk unproven theory

while the ~ next ~ Ouija Board Climate Doomsday Prediction is in 2030

and when that Doomsday fails to happen too

just like all the many other failed doomsday’s

do not worry


there will always be the next computer Ouija Board Doomsday Climate Prediction

to keep you Paranoid

so they can control your life based on your Fear of the unknown

based on ~ their ~ proven fraud in science

and your Political Media Brainwashed Make Believe


The Number One Climate Variable of many Climate Variables

is the Variable Sun with many known Cycles

causing many Ice Ages and Warming Periods

as the Variable Sun made of Hydrogen Atoms Colliding making Helium

  continues to be Warmer and Brighter over time

and will one day Vaporize this CO2 starved carbon based earth

and Ending the Religion of

Computer Ouija Board Doomsday Climate Paranoia Forever


The Tested Truth in Knowledge

is always Silenced by Religion and Fascism

as it is always the Truth that is Censored


Billions of Years of Known Climate Change are very Real

and caused by many climate variables known today

that are just missing from the scientifically proven to be

Deliberately Flawed and Incomplete Climate Study


The United Nations is a Criminal Political Body and not a Science Body

as we continue to give our hard earned money away

to those who Stab America in the Back

and today are Profiting from their Climate Religion

as the U.N. is taking more Power and Control

over All of We the Carbon based People of this Carbon based Earth

based on Proven Fraud in Science


The Political Media Religion of Doomsday Climate Paranoia


the unproven theory

that as Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide Levels Increase

Climate Warming Increases

and this is Scientifically Debunk Unproven Theory


Increased Variable Warming by the Variable Sun

with many known cycles

Increases the Evaporation of CO2 and Water Vapor

causing Green causing the Carbon Cycle

on this CO2 starved Carbon based Earth

scientifically proving

the Debunk Unproven Theory is Backwards Science

because science data good or bad can be interpreted in many ways

Good or Bad

and sometimes Deliberately Bad for Political Agenda

as the Tested Truth in Science is Silenced

as scientifically proven to be

Lunatic Political Science Fiction for Profit continues to Destroy Tested Reality

while doing only Harm to the cause of all living nature

based on their proven to be Debunk Backwards Science

based on zero open public question test rebuttal debate

scientifically proving fascism in Science

as the words of belief can prove nothing in tested science

and Preached Hearsay Political Science Fiction is: not Tested Reality


CO2 + Water Vapor + Sun Energy = Green

scientifically proving the byproduct of energy is life

while proving the evaporated byproduct of warming is not the cause of warming

proving the evaporated byproduct of warming is the cause of Green

while Debunking the unproven theory Humans cause climate warming


it is not my job to Prove Climate Religion is Wrong

it is the Job of the

Preached Political Media Religion

of Doomsday Climate Paranoia for Profit Power and Control

over our daily lives

to Prove they are Right


the only thing they have scientifically proven is their Fraud in Science


~ Letter to the Editor ~

The Rebuttal

That You Silence and Ignore for Political Ploy

Since the Spring of 2007

July 7 ~ 8



science is: to know

and tested reality is based on tested science ~

~ knowing ~

Weather Stations

on the coldest parts of this Carbon based Earth

have been Turned Off

and can no longer be used to Average Weather Data and Temperatures

with the Warm Weather Stations

proving a change in how Weather and Temperatures are now Measured

providing warmer averages

now used as proof of global warming when nothing has changed

because we no longer have real the cold temperatures to average with the warm

providing a Flawed and False Reality


Now Add the Very Real and Very Proven and Well Documented Fact

~ New Warm Weather Stations ~

have been

Deliberately Placed On

~ Black Tared Roof Tops ~

next to

Heating and Air-Conditioning Outlet Vents

and new Weather Stations placed along very Hot very Busy

Paved Black Highways

and all proven to be Deliberately Flawed and False Temperature Data

that can no longer be Averaged with Cold Weather Station Data

 with this Deliberately Flawed and False Temperature Data

being used as Scientific Proof of Catastrophic Climate Warming

while only proving Fraud in Climate Science

by proven Frauds in Science who have a proven Political Agenda

~ while ~

 Ocean Temperature Measurements

have been based only on the Warm Temperature measurements

that were not averaged with the Cold Temperature measurements

as now Admitted by some of the Scientists taking the Measurements


There is no Climate Emergency

as the very proven Fraud in Climate Science continues in every way Possible


The Proof is in the Pudding

because here in Montana for many years now

the number of days above 50 Degrees F

continue to Decline

as the number of days below 50 Degrees F

continue to Increase

as the amount of energy needed for Cooling in the Summers continues to Decrease

as the amount of energy needed for Heating in the Winters continues to Increase

regardless of the Temperature Doomsday Paranoia

Preached by Proven to be Political Frauds in Science


Paranoid Doomsday Climate Religion is:

a scientifically proven to be Political Media Brainwashed Mental Illness

based on proven fraud in science

as the Media and Press continue to Silence the tested reality in science

as they Preach their test proven lies without rebuttal

as those who have Publicly proven they Fail Grade School Science

Dictate Science

as they Reject the Scientific Method

as they Reject all question Test Rebuttal debate

for Political agenda while doing only proven harm to the carbon cycle

Costing Many Tens of Trillions of Dollars to Profit Billionaires

who now dictate how you live your now UN-Free life

~ while ~

not one Dime

of the Tens of Trillions of proven to be Wasted Dollars

will have any effect on climate change

on this CO2 starved Carbon based Earth

where the Byproduct of Energy is the cause of all Carbon based Life

and Preached Doomsday Paranoia

for what has been scientifically proven to be

Fascist Fraudulent Political Agenda

is not

proven fact tested reality in science


The Fraud has been Proven and the Garbage Science Debunk


Persuaded Belief is not Science

…as the truth in knowledge must always be in question ~

so what do you just believe and what do you not just believe

that is the Question

when science is: to know ~

knowledge and belief are Opposites

…and when you can not Admit you are proven wrong

then you are not a Scientist ~

…and when your science is based on ~

Political Media Brainwashed Feelings of Belief

then it is scientifically known as and called a test proven religion ~

because Pathological is not Factual in Tested Reality


My Science Argument

based on my on going Investigation since 2007

…my ongoing work in progress ~

~ The Rebuttal ~

To: Maya van Rossum



Green Amendments For The Generations


About Bruce A. Kershaw

Born ~ March 27, 1956 at 11:10 pm Long Beach California other wise I'm still breathing O2 made from CO2 and eating food made from CO2 ~ the rest is Icing on the cake ~
This entry was posted in CO2 and Global Warming. Bookmark the permalink.