If Joe Berry can not prove it then How can you ?



I Challenge You to an Open Public Debate in Science

with a


~ Reward ~

for the peer-reviewed science proving Humans cause climate warming

as we are now spending many Trillions of Dollars

that will have zero effect on climate warming

while doing only proven Harm to the cause of Green and the Carbon Cycle

and you will have to debunk my science

to prove your self-debunk and proven to be Fraudulent science is tested reality


Science is: to know

and I know Climate Change is Real for the past 4.6 billion Years

while Climate Religion calls me

~ The Denier ~

when I do not deny climate change

scientifically proving they are Mentally Ill and need a Shrink


The Byproduct of Climate Warming

is the Increased Evaporation of CO2 and Water Vapor

by the primary cause of variable warming and cooling

by the variable Sun with many known cycles

as the variable Sun continues to be Warmer and Brighter

while causing a known cycle of Ice Ages and Warming Periods

while Ice Core Science is showing us

Ice Ages with many times the CO2 in the Air than today

further scientifically proving

CO2 is the Byproduct of Warming not the cause of Warming

just as CO2 Physics and Chemistry since 1835 has and continues to Prove

CO2 causes Cooling

CO2 is the Byproduct of Energy making CO2 the Opposite of Energy

and is a Heat and Energy Sponge

and absorbs more heat and energy than the surrounding Gases in the air

while absorbing Heat and Energy away from the surrounding Gases

making the Surrounding gasses cooler not warmer

as all heated gases are warmed and expand and rise

as All Heat Rises in Real Physics

removing heat from the lower atmosphere

causing a void in the lower atmosphere

then filled by very frozen air crashing downward

causing the Ice Caps at the poles of this CO2 starved Carbon based Earth

as Frozen CO2 = Dry Ice is Crashing downward too

and cooling the air ten times faster and twenty times longer

than the Frozen water crashing downward too


The majority of CO2 in the Air is caused by Nature causing more Nature

as all life still comes from the Oceans

as the majority of CO2 in the Air

comes from Billions of years of very variable immeasurable unpredictable

Volcanic Activity below Sea level

as there is many time the CO2 in the Oceans than in the air

while causing the carbon cycle below Sea level

and the number two cause of CO2 in the air is caused by Nature too

and is making more nature

and is produced by Respiration from all the lungs breathing in O2 oxygen

then exhaling CO2 for Plants and Trees to Breathe back in

in a continuous cycle of recycle causing all Living Breathing

Carbon based Nature

caused by this carbon based earth

~ while ~

humans have been moving to higher ground for 20,000 plus years

while the Sea level has been 100 feet higher than today

and it was much warmer in the 1930’s

and much much warmer 1000 years ago for 200 years

and 125,000 years ago the Arctic of Ice today was a Jungle

with all the above ignored by the proven to be Flawed Incomplete climate study

while ignoring more than a dozen other climate variables

scientifically proving it is not a real climate study


The Byproduct of Energy is Life

6CO2 + 6H2O + v ~> C6H12O6 + 6O2

CO2 + Water Vapor + Sun Energy = Green

making Food & Oxygen while causing the Carbon Cycle

causing of All Primary and Secondary Carbon based Life

and Secondary Energy in a continuous cycle with oxygen and hydrogen

in a continuous cycle of recycle

on this scientifically proven to be CO2 starved Carbon based Earth

where everything Breathing and not Breathing has Carbon in it

where Carbon based Pants and Trees

need 3 to 4 times the CO2 than in the air today to Breath Healthy


Carbon based Humans are 20% Carbon


From: Bruce A. Kershaw


[email protected]

To: Maya van Rossum

~ Not a Scientist ~

[email protected]

who has earned zero right to scientific opinion



science is: to know

and the truth in knowledge must always be in question

as the Scientific method is based on Question Test Rebuttal Debate


I have Investigated and Proven Fraud in Climate Science

since the spring of 2007

with my now 47 years of working back ground in

CO2 Physics and Chemistry

Atmospheric Emission Science Physics and Chemistry

and Heat and Energy Transfer Science Physics and Chemistry

along with many years of known Earth Climate History

and Ice and Earth Core Science

with all the above

Debunking the Hypothetical Conjecture = Unproven Theory

Humans cause Climate Warming

along with the Proven Fraud in Climate Science by very scientifically proven Frauds

who provide the world with proven to be

Deliberately Flawed and Incomplete Climate Study

supported with proven to be Deliberately Flawed Science Data

while I have had an ongoing science Argument with

Joe Berry

Stanford University

for many years

and Joe can not prove with Peer-reviewed science

that Carbon based Humans

made by and from this CO2 Starved Carbon based Earth cause climate warming

so how can you ?

while I have offered a Reward for the science proving Humans cause climate warming

with well over 40,000 Requests since 2007

and nothing

nor will anyone Preaching their Political Media Religion


Doomsday Climate Paranoia

 publicly debate their proven to be

~ Settled ~

Lunatic Political Science Fiction

to profit Billionaires and China

when settled science does not exist in tested reality in science

as the truth in all knowledge must always be in question

the bases for the scientific method

and rejected by the Religion of Doomsday Climate Paranoia

a scientifically proven to be Brainwashed mental disorder

based on Feelings

when there are zero Personal Emotional Feelings

in proven fact tested reality in science

Persuaded Pathological is not Scientifically Factual

and if science is based on feelings then you are a test proven fool

and not a real scientist who

~ knows ~

by question test rebuttal debate

as real science is: to know

and not

Political Media Brainwashed Make Believe

based on proven fraud

based on zero proven science

based on 40 years of

Self Debunk Computer Ouija Board Doomsday Predictions

of the unknowable future

and that why Political Media Preached Paranoid Doomsday Climate Religion

refuses to debate the fact proven Science they just ignore

proving they are wrong proving they are not real scientists

and the Climate Emergency is a Proven Political Pathological Lie

by Scientifically Proven Frauds in Science

who can prove nothing

as we have Brainwashed Green Lunatics Harming the cause of Green

to profit billionaires who publicly fail 5th grade science

and the only thing Climate Religion can scientifically prove in tested reality

  is: their Insanity

Harming the cause of Green

as those who Fail Grade School Science Fascistly Dictate a False Reality

as Brainwashed Words can prove nothing in Questioned Tested Science

and the Preached and Settled Media Lunatic Political Science Fiction

is not open for public debate

because scientifically Test Proven Political Ploy

is never open for Question Test Rebuttal Debate

when the truth in knowledge must always be in question


Question Test Rebuttal Debate


~ while knowing ~

all Gases absorb and radiate heat while expanding and rising

If the Atmosphere was the size of a Football Field

that would make all of the CO2 in the air

the thickness of a dime down the middle of the fifty yard line

and how can something that small trap anything in something that big ?

and of course in real physics it is not possible

and CO2 can not generate new energy it can only transfer preexisting energy upward

as all heat rises in real physics

so Articulate to us how that is possible for so little CO2 in the air

to trap heat in something so big

when CO2 can only transfer heat upward

while froze CO2 = Dry Ice is crashing back downward


Question Test Rebuttal Debate


Why are there so many known climate variables missing from the Climate Study ?

and then Preached as Settled Science when settled science does not exist ?


why did over 30,000 Scientists with over 9,000 of them with PhD’s

Sign a Petition

disagreeing with the proven to be flawed incomplete climate study

while proving there is no Scientific Consensus

as the 97% Scientific consensus is a proven lie started by

John Kerry and Barack Obama


Why did 49 NASA Scientist send a Signed Letter to NASA

disagreeing with NASA on their of Climate Science Beliefs

based on what is now Debunk Unproven Theory

to Predict the unknowable future


why did 87% of the National Academy of Science

not Sign Joe Berry’s Open Letter to the Public

supported by zero peer-reviewed science


why does the Media and Press refuse to allow any

Question Test Rebuttal Debate

to their proven lies and disinformation in climate science

~ why do they reject the scientific method ?

and why has not one of my many

Letters to Editor

since 2007

in scientific rebuttal to test proven lies by the Press ever been Printed

while the media and Press have yet to provide when requested many times

any peer-reviewed scientific reference

to scientifically prove they are not Lairs and Frauds in science


~ to be continued ~


Wisdom is the Ability to use knowledge Constructively while doing no Harm

…here comes the Sun ~

About Bruce A. Kershaw

Born ~ March 27, 1956 at 11:10 pm Long Beach California other wise I'm still breathing O2 made from CO2 and eating food made from CO2 ~ the rest is Icing on the cake ~
This entry was posted in CO2 and Global Warming. Bookmark the permalink.