Climate Science ~ vs ~ Climate Religion

~*~

93 million years ago most of Montana was below Sea level

where today in Montana we can hunt for Sea Shells at 8,000 feet above Sea level

while

14 million years ago the sea level was 100 feet higher than today

~ my best guess is ~

the Sea level was not caused by

Carbon based Humans

of this

Carbon based Earth

because

Carbon based Humans have only been around for about 2 million years

while

74,000 years ago

~ there was a super volcano ~

leaving 15 breeding woman in our DNA funnel on this carbon based earth

~ while ~

I’m

still breathing O2 made from CO2

made by 600 million years of the carbon cycle above Sea level

and from many more unknown

hundreds of millions of years of carbon cycle below Sea level

~

I am very Proud and very Happy to be very Alive and very Well

while the rest is: the Icing on the Cake

and yes

I am very un-happy

with

Political Media Climate Religion

because

Climate Religion is based only on

Political Media Hearsay ~ belief ~ in self-debunked computer prediction

with zero test proven fact beyond self-debunked computer prediction

~

Computer Prediction

based on

out-dated ~ incomplete ~ science papers

that ignore all pre-existing test proven Physics ~ Chemistry

and Geology of Climate History

that further debunk the self-debunked computer prediction

while all of the ignored pre-existing science ~ must be debunked ~ in order to prove

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Warming

of this Carbon based Earth

with Man Made

carbon based oxygen = CO2 = carbon dioxide

~

Science ~ debunks ~ Make Believe

~ * ~

~

Politically ~ Correct

does not exist

in the

Scientific Method

~ only ~

Test ~ Proven ~ Fact

and

~ if you do the math ~

there is an infinity of progressively changing

climate variable

not

~ 1 ~

climate variable

~ * ~

~

Climate Science is a very new ~  very real ~ very un-tested Science

and because of

Political Media Belief

it is a new un-tested science that has yet to be

Publicly Debated

because

Political Media Climate Religion

is not allowing the general public to see the test proven facts

~

Political Media Climate Religion

is not permitting the Public to

~ Know ~

Climate and Weather

is caused by many progressive cycles

causing many progressive variables

or to know

Climate History

or to know

180 years of pre-existing test proven Physics and Chemistry

proving

CO2 ~ still ~ causes Cooling

~ All ~

ignored by

Political Media ~ Climate Religion

as Climate Warming continues ~ since ~ 12,000 B.C.

~ as before ~

in-between the Ice ages

of the last Twenty Ice Ages of the last 2 million years

of last 4.6 billion years of very extreme

very progressive ~ very variable

Climate Change

ignored by the so called

Progressive

Political ~ Media

~ while ~

the

~ self-debunked ~

computer climate prediction of the future

~ Validates ~

all of the pre-existing test proven facts

~ still ~

Ignored by Climate Religion

~ as ~

climate warming continues

since

12,000 B.C.

~ as ~

CO2 levels continue to increase caused by Evaporation of Ocean caused by Warming

by the

variable hot liquid core of this carbon based earth

heating the Oceans and lower Atmosphere

and the

~ variable ~

SUN

the rate of continued warming is slowing down not seeding up as predicted

proving

~ the opposite of the prediction is happening ~

~ Proving CO2 still causes Cooling ~ off-setting Warming ~

~ as ~

the Sun continues to be warmer and brighter

while

Water Vapor and Carbon Dioxide is the by product of Warming

causing the First Atmosphere

causing the Carbon Cycle with Oxygen and Hydrogen

causing all Carbon based Life and Energy

on this

Carbon based Earth

while the only thing the Political Media is sharing with the public is:

Climate Paranoia

~ while ~

after 26,000 years of Sea level rise

we can do nothing about

~ we can only ~

continue to move to higher ground

as we have been doing for the last 26,000 years

while the increased levels of water vapor and CO2

evaporated in to the Atmosphere by increased Warming

continue to make this Carbon based Earth

~ Greener ~

and healthier for all carbon based life

~

Water vapor and Carbon dioxide is the by product of warming

off-setting warming

while

causing the Carbon cycle and all Carbon based Life

on this Carbon based Earth

while the pre-existing knowledge has yet to be debunked by

Climate Religion

the

paranoid belief in self-debunked prediction

~ preaching ~

Climate Paranoia

instead of teaching and educating ~ how ~ to deal with the known test proven facts

of the scientific method

like continuing to move to higher ground

and not building 100 foot high walls to keep the Ocean out

~

…it took 147 years to be as warm as it was 147 years ago

and after 4.6 billion years of very extreme progressive variable climate change

there is no such thing as Normal Weather

and when we have Milder Winters here in Montana

they have much Harsher Winters in Germany

and

visa – versa

~  while ~

Prediction is not Science

Prediction is Belief

~ while ~

Belief

~ in ~

self-debunked computer climate prediction of the future

based on

outdated ~ incomplete

Science Papers

that do not acknowledge

known

Climate History

with an infinity climate variable

or acknowledge

180 years of known test proven physics and chemistry

that proves CO2 causes cooling

along with

55 years of test proven emission control science physics and chemistry

~ that most climate scientist are not even aware of ~

Enforced by the EPA ~ while ~ Ignored by the Political EPA

that too proves CO2 causes cooling

~ all ignored by ~

Climate Religion

is: flawed science

and

Proven

Fraud in Science

when proven flawed self-debunked science is used as

~ Scientific Proof ~

Carbon based Humans cause all Climate Change

with

Man Made

carbon ~ based ~ oxygen

=

CO2

=

Carbon Dioxide

~

When Hard Science is Ignored for True Belief

this proves the belief is a religion and not science

while

predicting the future with computers

~ is:

Ouija Board Science

and

That ~ Aint ~ Science

~ because ~

Science is: to Know

~

Science is ~ not ~ make believe in self-debunked computer climate prediction of the future

and

~ when is the last time someone predicted the future and it came true ~

~

so

~ do you believe or do you know ~

~

Steve Running

is the

~ expert in self-debunked prediction of the climate future with his computer ~

based on

~ His ~

Personal Feelings of True Belief

not

~ proven ~

Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

Dear Steve,

why do you and Al Gore continue to ignore test proven fact

~ that you refuse to debate ~

that further debunk ~ your ~ self-debunked computer prediction

while you continue to make believe in your self-debunked computer prediction ?

~ why ~

did you ignore all known climate variables and all climate history

and all test proven physics and chemistry

when you made

~ your ~

self-debunked

Programmed Computer Climate Prediction of the Future

? why do you ignore test proven fact for true belief ?

and then try to convince the Scientific Community it is Science

while the only Carbon based People you have fooled

are the proven fools in science and yourself

~

Years ago

Steve Running

Stated to the world the SUN is not a variable

since then I have yet to find one scientist on this carbon based earth who agrees with Steve

~ knowing ~

the SUN has many Variables caused by many Cycles

while

I have emailed Steve many times over the years

challenging Steve to an open public debate in real science

~ Steve has yet to respond ~

My Educated ~ Prediction ~ Guess

based on fact not belief

Steve Running will not debate ~ his ~ make believe science

in ~ his ~ self-debunked computer Climate Prediction of the Future

~

Steve

~ that’s not science that’s crazy ~

~

just like giving a proven Terrorist

Yasser Arafat

a Nobel Peace Prize

~

~ My Computer has a different Climate Prediction of the Future

than Stevens self-debunked Computer Prediction of the Future ~

~

Steve does not comprehend the ~

Proven Fact Tested knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

and to:

Russell L. Doty

Attorney ~ at ~ Law

who is not a Scientist

who has zero back ground in working science

who is very good at miss-informing

the public with very bogus public statements

with the Blessings

of the Helena Independent Record

&

Montana Cares

~ a ~

Political Organisation

 not ~ a

Science Body

who have zero back ground in working science

but

you have Steve Running

and his ~ Belief ~ in his self-debunked computer climate prediction of the future

&

the

Independent Record

Helena ~ Montana

~ a ~

Politicaly ~ Sided ~ Media ~ Organization

not ~ a

Science Body of Scientist

who have zero back ground in working science

who

can ~ not ~ prove

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

with

Man Made

Carbon based Oxygen

CO2

~ Carbon Dioxide ~

nor will they debate the science of the scientific method

as they continue to ignore the Hard Science

that further debunk their True Belief in self-debunked Prediction

the very same self-debunked belief the

Supreme Court

of the

State of Montana

along with

Four Dozen NASA Scientist and over 9000 PhD’s

of over 30,000 Scientist

have already ruled against

while these proven facts continue to be ignored by

The True Believers

of

self-debunked

~ computer ~

Prediction

~

…when science can not be debated ~

its no longer science of the scientific method

and becomes a ~ test ~ proven

Political Media Religion

while those who ~ Believe ~ the science is settled

are not Scientist

and do not comprehend the science or the scientific method

~

as

Politics and Journalism feed on each others Frenzy

while ignoring true tested science for true desired belief

while pampering the handful of self-debunked so called scientist

who ignore the scientific method for ~ their ~ shared true belief

but can prove nothing with tested science

proving

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming

~

Steve Running

will not Debate His Religion

because only Science can be Debated

and Steve has Zero Science to Debate

nor will any true believer debate the

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

while

the Media

will only allow those who do not comprehend the science

who have earned zero right to Scientific Opinion

to give Scientific Opinion with nothing beyond belief in words

who live in total and complete ~ Denial ~ of the Scientific Method

~

Steve Running

has yet to debunk

the pre-existing test proven science that further debunk his self-debunked prediction

~

From:

Bruce A. Kershaw

Atmospheric Emission Control Science and Emissions Testing

~ everyday ~

for the past 39 years

~ with ~

Fact Tested Knowledge

Ignored by

Climate Religion

~ * ~

~

~ * ~

~ the sky is blue ~

This is ~ Hard ~ Science

not because it is Hard to Learn or Know

but because

it is simple to know by definition

and has yet be debunked

while it is the simple knowledge that further debunk

the

Political Media ~ Climate Religion

because it is the simple ~ Hard ~ knowledge that is ignored by

 ~ Climate Religion ~

as Climate Religion ignores

99.7 % of the scientific community

while the 00.3 % of scientist who ~ Believe ~ in Man Made Climate Change

but have yet to prove with fact tested knowledge beyond their true belief

continue to refuse to debate the Hard ” Simple ” Science of the Scientific Method

while their ~ belief ~ is overshadowed by Test Proven Lies and Test Proven Fraud

as

Politicians ~ Journalist

and

Environmental Extremest

with zero back ground in tested science

who

Preach and Dictate Proven Garbage Science from Belief

while ignoring the

Proven ~ Simple ~ Hard Science of the Scientific Method

Proving

their belief is a

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

not

Science of the Scientific Method

while

the small percentage of Carbon based Humans who call them selves

~ Scientist ~

who put Belief before Test Proven Fact

~ have proven ~

to the scientific community

they are ~ not ~ scientist

while

there is nothing beyond

~ belief in words ~

to prove

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

with

Man Made

Carbon based Oxygen

~*~

~

~ * ~

~ If ~

we reduce

~

two oxygen atoms ~ based to ~ one carbon atom

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

= CO2 =

Carbon Dioxide

levels

by 50% in the Atmosphere

all Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth

above Sea level

will cease to exist

~

The First Atmosphere of this Carbon based Earth was Water Vapor and CO2

causing the Carbon Cycle

causing all Carbon based Life

while

today CO2 is the smallest part of the atmosphere

at ~ 00.04 %

while

Human caused CO2 is at 00.004 %

=

~ Four ~

one-thousandths

of

one percent

=

the equivalent of a sewing thread down the middle of the fifty yard line of a football field

if the atmosphere was the size of a football field

and is to minuscule

and insignificant to matter in any and every way

when compared to an infinity of climate variable

provided by a dozen known Climate Variables

while

Man Made CO2 is

supporting the Carbon Cycle and all Carbon based Life

on this

Carbon based Earth

making this Carbon based Planet

along with the increased Water Vapor

from Evaporation of the Ocean by the variable SUN

Greener

~*~

December 21, 2015

~ The First Day of Winter ~

here

~

where

the Predicted High for today is 30* F

the Predicted Low 21* F

where here

~ the Predictions are wrong far more often than right ~

where

the Record High for today was was 55* F in 1900

the Record Low was -25* F below zero in 1990

where

the normal high and low is 31* F and 11* F

~ at the ~

Bent Shoe ~ Astor Load

Scratchgravel Hills

Helena ~ Montana

~ while ~

this is the first day of summer in the southern hemisphere

where

our shortest day of the year here is the longest day of the year there

in

~ local ~

climate ~ variable

because

the continuously progressively extremely changing climate is different everywhere

for the past 4.6 billion years

caused by an infinity of climate variable

caused by a dozen progressively changing climate variables

~

To:

Lisa Bay

Consulting

lisamaebay@gmail.com

Helena ~ Montana

U.S.A

Carbon ~ based ~ Earth

~

Lisa,

how is Mike doing ?

I have not seen Mike around in a while ~

is he still working the ranch outside of Wolf Creek ?

I hope all is well for You and Mike and the Family

~

Lisa

Belief is not Science in the Scientific Method

Belief ~ is ~ Religion

~ while ~

Science is

Skepticism of Belief ~ Dictating Science

because

~ science is to know ~

not make believe

~

Belief in Computers Predicting the future is not Science of the Scientific Method

~ while ~

Belief

in

self-debunked

Computer Prediction

~ based on ~

outdated incomplete self debunking science papers from the 1800’s

that ignores

All Test Proven Science

and

All Climate History

with

a dozen climate variables

being called proof

Carbon based Humans cause all Climate Change

is:

Political Media Belief = Religion

~ and ~

Test Proven Fraud in Science of the Scientific Method

~ as ~

Atmospheric Warming since 12,000 B.C.

continues

~ and as ~

Water Vapor

and

CO2 levels continue to Increase

from

Evaporation of Ocean

by

the variable

SUN

the CO2 from billions of years of on going volcanic activity below Sea level

~ Benefiting Plants and Trees ~

causing the carbon cycle and all carbon based life and energy

on this

Carbon based Earth

~ the rate of warming continues to slow down ~

not speed up

as

~ Predicted ~

proving

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

carbon and oxygen together

cause

Cooling ~ not ~ Warming

~ Validating ~

millions of years of

Climate History

with

A dozen climate variables

with

180 years of Proven Fact Tested Chemistry

and

55 years of working proven fact tested

Atmospheric Emission Control Science Physics and Chemistry

Enforced by the EPA

All

~ ignored by ~

the EPA

and

Climate Religion

who believe there is only one climate variable

while

believing

carbon is pollution

while

~ Prediction ~

is not

Hypothesis

or

Science in the Scientific Method

Prediction is: Belief

and

carbon with zero color taste smell

causing the carbon cycle

causing all carbon based life and energy

with

oxygen and hydrogen

on this carbon based earth

where everything has carbon in it

is not pollution

~

Water Vapor and Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

caused the first atmosphere

causing the carbon cycle

is:

the by-product of Warming

off setting Warming

not the Cause of Warming

in test proven science of the scientific method

ignored by

Political Media ~ Climate Religion

~ Regards ~

Dr. Bruce Allen Kershaw

Helena ~ Montana

U.S.A.

Carbon ~ based ~ Earth

~ * ~

~

~*~

This is not a Science Paper

this is a Legal Argument

based on

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

~ a science paper ~

most of you would not comprehend

~ and ~

I am not writing to and for Scientist

I am writing to Politicians ~ Journalist and Environmental Extremest

who have publicly failed grade school science

~ but ~

do not know

they have

Publicly Failed Grade School Science

~ while ~

Repetitiveness

is the key to deprogramming

~*~

~

I  Bruce Allen Kershaw

~ challenge ~

anyone ~ and ~ everyone

to an open public debate

in

Climate Science

~ a new ~

un-tested ~ un-debated

~ science ~

with a

~ $100,000.00 ~

REWARD

for the

~ tested ~

Proof ~ beyond ~ Belief

that

Carbon based Humans

cause

all ~ or ~ any

Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

with the cause of all the Plants and Trees

causing all the oxygen we breathe

all the carbon based food we eat

and

all Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth

with

Man Made

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

while

~ debunking ~

all Climate History

~

Climate History

with

a infinity of climate variable

and

180 years of test proven Chemistry

55 years of test proven

Atmospheric Emission Control Science Physics and Chemistry

and

all preexisting test proven knowledge ignored by

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

that further debunk their

~ Belief ~

in self-debunked

~ Prediction ~

as

Climate Religion refuses to debate the Tested Science

of the

Scientific Method

because

Climate Religion

~ Believes ~

“the science is settled”

when settled science dose not exist in the scientific method

while the only thing that has been settled

is:

how to Brainwash People to Believe

instead of Teaching Carbon based People how to Know and Grow Forward

beyond

Political Media Belief

~

~ Belief ~

with zero hard science to support their true belief in self-debunked prediction

~

~ * ~

~

The

Independent Record

Helena ~ Montana

and

CBS News

~ Investigates ~

is very good at covering only one side of the story

while Ignoring very Proven Fact Tested Knowledge of the Scientific Method

~ that ~

will not ~ go away

~

They are not open minded scientist

~ who look at all the facts ~

they are true believes who only preach their Political Media Belief

with zero test proven fact

~

Tested Knowledge ~ debunks ~ Make Believe in the Scientific Method

while

Excluding Knowledge from Belief is not Science

~ * ~

~

To:

Dr. J. Marshall Shepherd

marshgeo@uga.edu

University of Georgia

Department of Geography

Atmospheric Sciences Program

~

Marshall,

I watched your Interview on CBS News

and because of their Belief

they only cover one side of the story

and as you know ~

Excessive Warming by the Variable Sun

can and will cause

the Ocean level to decline

by

Excessive levels of Water Vapor and Carbon Dioxide evaporating into the Atmosphere

from the Ocean

by the

Very

Variable

~ SUN ~

causing

Deserts to become Green

~ again ~

like many times before over the last 600 million years

of 4.6 billion years

of very extreme very progressive very variable

Climate History ~ of ~ Climate Change

~ for a dozen known variable reasons today ~

providing an infinity of Climate Variable

~ not ~

1

Climate Variable

~

The Ocean has many times the CO2 level than the Atmosphere

while

most of the CO2 in the Atmosphere

comes from billions of years of on going volcanic activity below Sea level

~ so ~

why

?

is there more science missing from the U.N. Climate Study than in the U.N. Climate Study

~ because ~

you can not debunk belief when belief refuses to look at

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

The

United ~ Nations

is not a Science Body

the U.N. is a Political Body of Politicians

who do not comprehend the science or the scientific method

who Ignore Test Proven Fact

for Belief

in

Self-debunked ~ Prediction

while

Believing

only Carbon based Humans can cause ~ all ~ Climate Change

after 4.6 billion years of very extreme progressive variable Climate Change

~

The U.N. Believes

a dozen known Climate Variables do not exist

or

no longer exist

while over 90% of the CO2 going into the air

is not caused by

Carbon based Humans

~

The U.N. can not prove there is only ~ 1 ~ Climate Variable

by Ignoring a Dozen known Climate Variables

while believing only the CO2 caused by Humans cause all Climate Warming

while the plan is to

spend 20 plus Trillion Dollars over the next twenty years

to reduce the cause of the

Carbon Cycle

~ CO2 ~

causing all Carbon based Life

on this Carbon based Earth

to reduce Climate Warming

but this will have Zero effect on the last 14,000 years of

Mild Climate Warming

with many

Little Ice Ages and Mini Ice Ages

with

Previous

Warming Periods ~ much ~ Warmer than Today

while

Hurting the Carbon Cycle

while

lowering Oxygen levels in the Air

and

turning underground Drinking Water into an Acid

~

Real Science of the Scientific Method

is:

Questioned

Reviewed ~ Analyzed ~ Debated

and

Test Proven

~ not ~

Believed while Ignoring Test Proven Fact

~

The official statement by the United Nations

is:

“it is likely”

Humans cause Climate Change

~

The Word “Likely” Proves ~ ZERO ~ in Tested Science

while

four dozen NASA Scientist disagree with the UN

while

over 30,000 Real Scientist

have Signed a Petition

stating their disagreement with the U.N. and their self-debunked Belief

but

 you will not here about these

Real Scientist Ignored by CBS News

because

the more than 9000 PhD’s

of the more than 30,000 Scientist

just in the U.S.A

~ that I know of ~

do not Believe as CBS News Believes

as

CBS News continues to state ~

a scientific consensus

~ that has been proven ~

does ~ not ~ exist

as

the Scientific Community has proven

there is only a Political Media Belief consensus

while

CBS News has yet to provide scientific reference beyond only

Words ~ of ~ Belief

~ while ~

Belief ~ in ~ Words

prove nothing in tested science

~

Growing Forward with Best Regards

Dr. Bruce Allen Kershaw

Scratchgravel Hills

Helena ~ Montana

~

~*~

~

To:

Jim Posewitz

Biologist

and

Tyler Miller

Publisher for the Independent Record Helena Montana

~

Test Proven Facts ~ debunk ~ Opinion

Facts you will never read about in the Helena IR

~

When the Weather Channel is telling me it is 9* outside for my zip code

and my 6 outdoor thermometers are telling me it is 28*

what should I ~ Believe

?

Computers predicting the future based on belief in self-debunked hypothetical conjecture

is not

Science or Knowledge

and proven Fraud does not debunk test proven fact

while Climate Religion Refuses to ~ Look at and Debate ~ the tested knowledge

that further debunk their self-debunked hypothetical conjecture

proving their true belief is a Political Media Religion not Tested Science

as

~ all science is tested and debated ~

while

only Religion is not

~

99.97 % ~ of ~ Geologist

~ Know ~

Carbon based Humans have been moving to higher ground for the past 26,000 years

because

Geologist ~ Know

the Ocean has risen 350 over the last 26,000 years

~ as ~

we now live with the Political Media Climate Paranoia of continued Sea level Rise

by those who believe we can spend 20 plus trillion dollars

to reduce the cause of the

Carbon Cycle

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon ~ Di-oxide

carbon and oxygen together

causing

all the Carbon based Plants and Trees

all the Carbon based Food we eat

and all the Oxygen we breathe

causing

all Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth

~ to stop further Sea level Rise ~

instead of accepting the logical solution conclusion

by continuing to move to higher ground

as we have been doing for the past 26,000 years

~

It is foolish to

~ believe ~

Humans can stop Millions of years of known continued

variable progressive change in nature

and variable Sea level Rise

while knowing

the Ocean was 60 feet higher than today 135,000 years ago

~

Reducing the cause of the Carbon Cycle

the cause of all Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth

will not stop Sea level Rise

it will only prevent the better health for Plants and Trees

while preventing this Carbon based Earth from being Greener

while preventing better Health for You and Me

~

We must learn to adapted to Nature

because

Nature will never learn to adapt to Us

~

Spending Trillions to make all Plants and Trees less Healthy

while reducing oxygen levels in the air

while turning underground water in to an Acid

will not stop continued Sea level Rise

~ and ~

If you are still looking for Atlantis

I would suggest

looking 350 feet below today’s Sea level

~

Most of the Atmosphere is -200*F

while

Heat ~ Still ~ Rises

~

The Big Lie

~ is ~

Gases ~ Trap ~ Heat in the Atmosphere

when Gases do not Trap Heat

~ All Gases ~

absorb heat and radiate heat

while expanding while rising

transferring heat from the lower Atmosphere to the upper Atmosphere

forcing sub zero air from the upper Atmosphere

to the North and South Poles of this Carbon based Earth

as heated air rises

and the faster the lower gases are heated

by the

~ variable ~

Hot Liquid Core

of this

Carbon based Earth

and the

very

~ variable ~

SUN

as the Sun continues to be warmer and brighter over time

with many cycles

the faster all heated gases ~ Air ~ rise

and the faster very heavy cold dense air takes its place

off setting Variable Warming

~

Over 90% of the CO2 in the Atmosphere

comes from

Billions of years of on going Volcanic Activity below Sea level

causing the

First Atmosphere

causing the Carbon Cycle above and below Sea level

while causing Billions of years of Acidification of the Ocean

~

CO2 is the by-product of energy

CO2 can not generate new energy

CO2 can only transfer preexisting energy already in the air

while

increased levels

of

frozen CO2

from the upper Atmosphere

cools the air many times faster than the increased levels of frozen water vapor in the air

that comes crashing to the north and south poles

as heat rises

~

We are Paying

Hundreds of Billions of Dollars

to

Large Corporations

to

Pump CO2 into the Ground

~ this is ~

Harming the Carbon Cycle

while

Turning Underground Water in to an Acid

while

Lowering Oxygen Levels in the Air We Breathe

because

there is no CO2 in the fuel we burn

all the ~ O2 ~ of ~ CO2 ~ comes from the Air we breathe

if the CO2 is caused by Carbon based Humans

~

We are ~ not ~ allowing the Carbon Cycle

caused by

CO2

causing

Plants and Trees

to Breathe the CO2

to

Recycle

the O2 part of CO2

back into the Air where the O2 Oxygen came from

that allowed the Carbon based Fuel to Burn

~

The O2 Oxygen

from the air we breathe

allows

the Hydrogen part of the fuel to Vaporize

causing

the Carbon part of the fuel

to bond to the O2 Oxygen from the Air we Breathe

making

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

~ while ~

Pumping CO2 in to the Ground

is:

Lowering ~ O2 ~ Oxygen levels

while

Turning Clean Underground Drinking Water into an Acid

while

Hurting the Carbon Cycle

Hurting

all Carbon based Life and Energy

on this

Carbon based Earth

~

In Botany Science

Carbon based Plants and Trees need 4 times the CO2

than in the air today

to be at their best level of health

and at 210 ppm

or

half the CO2 level than today

Plants Die

and all carbon based life on this carbon based Earth above Sea level

would cease to exist

~

~ so ~

 Why

~ ? ~

do we have Politicians and Journalist

and

Environmental Extremest

who have publicly failed on every level in Science

with zero comprehension of the scientific method

Dictating Science

~

science is: to know

to know is

knowledge that is

questioned ~ tested ~ debated

~ not ~

Believed

~

Using Incomplete Science Papers

as

Proof

Carbon based Humans

cause all or any

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

is: Proven Fraud

not: Science

~

Incomplete Science Papers

That Ignore

~ all ~

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

~*~

Carbon is not Pollution on a Carbon based Planet

where everything has Carbon in it

causing a Carbon Cycle

causing all Carbon based Life and Energy

while

Climate Change is very real for the past 4.6 billion years

for a dozen ignored reasons

~ while ~

a very small fragment of incomplete science

does not debunk

hundreds of years of fact tested reality

of the

Scientific Method

~ as ~

Climate Religion ~ dictates ~ Science from Belief

and

~ if ~

Jim and Tyler

would like an open public debate in tested knowledge

in climate science physics and chemistry

here in Helena Montana

~ I will be there ~

and if Steve Running or any other Scientist who Believes Carbon based Humans

cause

Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

with

Carbon based Oxygen

would like to join the debate

the more merrily the debate

and when you refuse to debate science

this ~ Proves ~ it is not science

~

Bruce

Trouble Shooting

Diagnostics and Testing

~ every day for the past 39 years ~

in

Atmospheric Emission Science

and

Heat Transfer Science

Fuel System Chemistry

Computer Control Science

Computer Artificial Intelligence

the very rapid process of elimination

based on programmed input information

providing programmed output information

providing a lack of information coming out when a lack of information is going in

while in the past I have been chosen to

Evaluate Education Programs

I was Licensed by the State of California to

Test and Certify Emissions and Emission Control Systems in 1976

October 8, 2011

I received a Doctor Honor

from the

Association of American Physicians and Surgeons

Publishing Peer-reviewed Science and Medicine since 1943

every year

I am Invited to attend the annual meeting of

Doctors of Disaster Preparedness

and to the yearly

International Conference on Climate Change

April 30, 2013

I was Invited to participate in the

London Symposium on Climate Change

at the

Oxford and Cambridge Club, London in June of 2013

and since the spring of 2007

I have an on going Investigation of

Climate Science ~ Climate History

and

Political Media ~ Climate Religion

while by email

I have been called every name in the book

by

PhD’s

who have yet to prove Scientifically

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming

of this Carbon based Earth with Man Made

Carbon based Oxygen

the cause of the Carbon Cycle and all Carbon based life

as they continue to refuse to debate real science of the scientific method

bruce@co2u.info

406-449-7987

~

~ * ~

There is nothing beyond belief in words

to prove

Carbon based Humans

cause

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

with

Carbon based Oxygen

the cause of

~ All ~

Carbon based Life

the

Carbon Cycle

with

Oxygen and Hydrogen

~ * ~

~

November 27, 2015

To:

Joby Warrick & Chris Mooney

reporters for

The Washington Post

~

warrickj@washpost.com

christopher.mooney@washpost.com

~

when a Lunatic with a Gun kills a dozen people

makes the headlines

everyday for months

Glorifying Lunatics with Guns

the 20,000 Carbon based Humans who starve to death everyday ~

do not

~

Investigative

News

~ Journalism ~

is the gathering of all the Facts

to report all the facts with out taking sides or bias

providing all the information to the public

so the public can decide for them self

what is Real

not the gathering of some of the facts to support

just your belief

only providing to the public what you believe

not letting the public decide for them self

what is and what is not

~ Reality ~

based on all the facts

while

Belief ~ based ~ Science

has Zero Reality in Science of the Scientific Method

~ there is zero knowledge in self-debunked belief ~

while

writing about science does not make you a scientist

of the scientific method

or prove you comprehend the tested knowledge

or that you know the difference between what is real and what is not

in tested knowledge

and this is why you

~ Ignore ~

Test Proven Fact and Test Proven Fraud

for

~ your ~

true belief ~ in ~ true belief

because

you do not

~ know ~

~

while science is: to know

you just

Make Believe

~

Joby & Chris

Thank you for Spreading

Climate Paranoia

while

the Glaciers have Melted many times before

and melt during Ice ages too

while

there are more Polar Bears today than before

~ and ~

what was the outcome of your last test or experiment with CO2

while

Your Photo of White Steam coming out of Smoke Stakes

is not

Poison and Pollution

while

this Carbon based Earths

4.6 billion Years

of

ever changing climate

was much warmer 1000 years ago than today for 200 years

~

www.jpands.org/vol12no3/robinson600.pdf

~

while

the official statement

by

the United Nations is

it is “Likely “

Humans cause Climate Change

“Likely”

is a word of Belief

not a word of science

while

words Prove nothing

and

Publishing words of Political Media Belief

prove nothing in Tested Knowledge of the Scientific Method

and this is why you should

~ Investigate the Science ~

not the Politics of those who have publicly failed grade school science

~

Joby & Chris

have you earned the right to Scientific opinion ?

~ have you tested the knowledge ~

or

do you just believe in a belief ?

~

I think you should Interview the more than 9,000 PhD’s

~

www.petitionproject.org

~

who disagree

with

the Politicians

AL Gore and John Kerry

who are not

Scientist

while over 9000 PhD’s proves there is no

~ scientific consensus ~

while the real number of scientist who agree with Al Gore and John Kerry

is

00.03 %

~

John Kerry and his 97% is a Proven Lie

by a Proven Lair

~

Al Gore and John Kerry

are Politicians who has Publicly Failed Grade School Science

who can provide Zero Scientific Reference to support ~ their ~ True Belief

in self-debunked

Prediction

while

Committing

Proven Fraud in Science

for

Profit

with a Corrupt World Wide Carbon Credit Scheme

that will have ZERO effect on Climate Change

while

Al Gore and John Kerry

can not

Explain ~ Debate

or

Prove in any way

anything beyond

~ their ~

Personal

Emotional

Feelings of True Belief

while I have Reviewed Al Gores so called Scientific References

e-mailed to me by Dave Boundy of Repower America

in May of 2010

and they are as Bogus as a Three Dollar Bill

maybe

I am the only Carbon based Human to Request and Review

Al Gores

~ Bogus ~

Scientific References

~

I  then Received a response from Senator John Kerry

June 14, 2010

John Kerry could not provide scientific reference of any kind

proving in any way

Carbon based Humans

cause

Climate Warming

with

Man Made

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

~

while once again

~

John Kerry is a test proven Lair

in Science

~ by ~

Stating to the world

“Plants and Trees can not absorb any more CO2”

when the Opposite is True

in Test Proven Botany Science

Plants and Trees need 4 times More ~ not ~ Less

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

to be Healthy

while

this is just another one of many

very test proven

Political Media Lies

by

John Kerry

~ who refuses to look at or acknowledge test proven fact ~

as

Environmental ~ Extremest

who have publicly failed grade school science

look the other way

for the sake of

~ their ~

self-debunked

True Belief

~

Joby & Chris

Investigate the Tested Knowledge

not the Political Media Belief

Test the Science to Test ~ your ~ True Belief

~

$100,000.00

~ REWARD ~

for the

Test ~ Proven

Scientific References

beyond

~ self – debunked ~

Hypothetical Conjecture

~ Proving ~

Carbon based Humans

cause

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

with

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

~ two oxygen atoms based to one carbon atom ~

with Water Vapor

causing the First Atmosphere

causing

the

Carbon Cycle

and all Carbon based Life and Energy

on this Carbon based Earth

~

CO2 can not ~ Hurt ~ Nature and the Environment

because

CO2 ~ caused ~ Nature and the Environment

causing

all the Oxygen we Breathe

and all the Carbon based Food we Eat

~

www.sjsu.edu/faculty/watkins/CO2plants.htm

~

Investigate

based on Test Proven Fact not Political Media Belief

as

Climate Warming Continues

~ again~

as it happens

off and on between the last 20 Ice Ages of the last 2 million years

while the Rate of Warming is slowing down not speeding up as Predicted

as CO2 levels continue to Increase

while

~ sometimes ~

Warming Speeds Up

~ sometimes ~

Warming Slows Down

~ sometimes ~

Warming Pauses

while

~ sometimes ~

We have Ice Ages

caused by a dozen known ~ ignored ~ Climate Variables

~ not by ~

1

Climate Variable

~

Increased levels of Water Vapor and CO2

evaporated from the Ocean

is the by-product of Climate Warming not the Cause of Climate Warming

while

off setting  Warming

caused by

the

~ very ~

Variable SUN

causing

Nature

the

Carbon Cycle

~

the warming occurs first

then

evaporated

water vapor and CO2 levels

increase

off setting warming

~

Bruce A. Kershaw

Angry Scientist

sponsored

by

no one ~ or ~ anything

along with

Tens of Thousands of Angry Scientist

sponsored by

Truth in Science

Ignored by Climate Religion

Climate Religion

based on

Test Proven Lies

~

~*~

I have e-mailed both Joby and Chris

and we will see if they can e-mail back

the

Fact Tested Knowledge

Proving

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

beyond

~ their ~

true belief ~ in ~ true belief

in the word

“Likely”

~*~

~

One Dozen Climate Variables ~ Ignored ~ by Climate Religion

while

a Greenhouse is a Enclosed Building

so the heated gases can not rise

with zero -200*F air to take its place

while

this Carbon based Earth is not in a Enclosed Building

~

I will not be hearing from

Joby and Chris

because

they can prove nothing in science

with only

~ Belief ~

in

Proven Lies and Proven Fraud

~ but ~

Joby and Chris

will continue to spread

~ Preach ~

Climate Religion

with

Climate Paranoia

based on belief

not

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

as

Joby and Chris

will continue to pretend the facts

that further debunk their self-debunked true belief do not exist

just like

the proven hypocrite

Al Gore

the test proven

Fraud

for

Profit

who can prove nothing with

~ His ~

Pathological Belief

~

~*~

~

November 20, 2015

Bent Shoe ~ Astor Load

Sratchgravel Hills

Helena ~ Montana

~

the expected High for today is 30*

the expected Low for tonight 20*

the normal High/Low is 41/21

the Record High for today was 69* in 1897

the Record Low for today was -15* in 1900

a variable of 85* over 3 years

before there were Power Plants and Automobiles everywhere

back when a Luxury

was a full sized Wood Stove

if you were lucky enough to have a Home

beyond a One Room Shack or Bunkhouse

with a Potbelly Stove

where here in Helena we see and feel -40 below 0* with out the wind chill factor

that is 72* below freezing with out the wind chill factor

back when Transportation for most Carbon based People

was a Carbon based Horse

causing very large piles of

~ free for the taking ~

Carbon based Fertilizer

everywhere

~ while ~

most of the energy used today here in Helena

is to keep from Freezing to Death during Global Warming

and

If there was no Electricity tomorrow

most of the Carbon based Humans

in the Republic of the U.S.A.

would be dead with in three weeks or less

~

The air we breathe is 78.09 % Nitrogen

if you replace 1 % of the Nitrogen with CO2

the Explosion Temperature in a Internal Combustion Chamber drops 500 Degrees

~ while ~

lowering NOX from the Tail Pipe of your Car

lowering ~ O3 Oxygen ~ Heavy Oxygen ~ called Ozone

~

Ozone at ground level causes Respiratory Illness

~

NOx is caused by ~

Nitrogen and Oxygen bonding at 2500* degrees and hotter

~

O3 Oxygen called Ozone is caused by ~

Sun Energy separating the NOx ~ Nitrogen from the Oxygen

causing the Ozone Layer

~

This is NOx Emission Science Enforced by the EPA

since the 1970’s

to lower O3 Oxygen ~ Ozone ~ at ground level

while proving CO2 causes cooling

while making the air we breathe cleaner for Humans not Nature

while

this Emission Science is Enforced by the EPA today

the Politically Active Part of the EPA Ignores this Proven Atmospheric Emission Science

while the EPA has yet to provide any Scientific Reference of any kind

proving

CO2 causes Atmospheric Warming

beyond

the self-debunked prediction

while the science they enforce since the 1970’s only proves

CO2 causes Cooling in a Internal Combustion Chamber

and in the Atmosphere

by

slowing down the rate of warming

not

speeding up the rate of warming

by the

very

~ variable ~

SUN

with many cycles

~ while ~

Frozen CO2 is still called Dry Ice

and cools the air 10 times faster and 20 times longer than frozen water

as increased levels of frozen CO2 and frozen water vapor

continue to come crashing down to the North and South Polls

of this

Carbon based Earth

 ~

a poetic

~ time ~

is every time ~ the sun shines

~ while ~

reality is found and shared

~ while ~

reality is something you see not believe

~ while ~

Political ~ Media ~ Religion

is:

the root of all self-debunked hearsay belief

and of course

most

Death by War

~ and ~

to quote

George Harrison

~ again ~

…here comes the Sun

~

~*~

Since the Spring of 2007

~ My ~

On going Scientific Investigative Report

of

Climate Warming

~*~

~

…to Intentionally Ignore a dozen known Climate Variables

along with

Millions of years of Climate History

and 180 years of Test Proven Chemistry

in a

Politically Based

Prediction Based

Peer-reviewed ~ Published

self-debunked

Climate Study

is:

Fraud ~ in ~ Science

of the

Scientific Method

~ while ~

using the 1896 Arrhenius

~ Incomplete ~

Out ~ Dated

Science Paper

that does not acknowledge

a dozen climate variables

all climate history

and

all proven chemistry

~ as proof ~

Carbon based Humans cause all Climate Warming

of this Carbon based Earth

~ proves only Fraud ~

in Tested Science of the Scientific Method

~

To Publicly State ~

” the Science is settled “

is a Moronic Statement in Science of the Scientific Method

~ while ~

those who do not comprehend the Science ~

and or

the

Scientific Method

have earned zero right to Scientific Opinion

~ as ~

Politicians and Journalist

and

Environmental Extremest

who have publicly failed grade school science

~ Dictate Science ~

from Belief

and

Test Proven Fraud

~ while ~

very extreme

Progressive

very ~ variable

Climate Change is very Real

~ for a dozen reasons ~

for billions years

of this

Carbon ~ based ~ Earth

causing

All Carbon based Life and Energy

with a

Carbon Cycle

with

Oxygen and Hydrogen

caused by

Water Vapor

and

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

Evaporated from the Ocean

by

~ the ~

very ~ variable

SUN

causing

the

First Atmosphere

with a little

N2 = nitrogen and SO2 = sulfur and oxygen together

causing

All

Nature

the

Carbon Cycle

~

~*~

…to make a Scientific Statement

based on self-debunked

Prediction

with zero

~ Fact Tested ~

Scientific Reference

to support a debunked belief

is:

very

Bogus Science

~

when you refuse to look at the tested knowledge that debunks your belief

you are not a scientist

while a real scientist of the scientific method

will admit they are wrong when proven wrong

and will not continue to believe in self-debunked hypothetical conjecture

~ while ~

in science

one Scientist can be right

~ while ~

I admit I am wrong when proven wrong

and

Grow Forward

through

~ The ~

Scientific Method

~

~*~

~

To: Scott Pelley

Editor

CBS News

~

investigates@cbsnews.com

~

Scott

I have 39 years of Atmospheric Emission Science and Testing under by belt

~ while you have zero ~

as I continue my Investigation of Climate Science since the Spring of 2007

~ while you have zero ~

Investigation

of

Tested Knowledge

beyond

Political Media Hearsay Belief

to support ~ your ~ True Belief

~

Scott

why do four dozen NASA Scientist

along with more than

9,000 PhD’s

of

Tens of Thousands of Scientist

just in the Republic of the United States of America

~ disagree ~

with ~ your ~ True Belief

~ while ~

proving there is no Scientific Consensuses

~ while ~

proving there is only a Political Media ~ Hearsay Belief ~ Consensuses

and why will you not listen to scientist who disagree with you

why do ~ you ~ only  allow your True Belief to be Heard

why do you deny a Public Forum for Real Scientific Debate

why

Scott

do you hide from the Public

very well known

~ in the Scientific Community ~

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge of the Scientific Method

why do you Ignore Test Proven Fact for ~ your ~ True Belief

and why do you get to decide what the Public should or should not

~ know ~

in science

why has CBS News turned their backs to the Majority of the Scientific Community

for

Hearsay

Political ~ Media

~ Belief ~

?

~

~ maybe ~

CBS News

should investigate the Science beyond their belief

because

Hiding one side of the story for belief is not real Journalism

while

CBS News can not Explain or Debate or Prove with Fact Tested Science

~ how ~

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~ other wise ~

CBS news should stop Preaching to the Public

something they do not comprehend

and can not explain or debate or prove with tested knowledge

~

Scott

the only thing you have proven to the Scientific Community is

you are not fair and balanced in your reporting to the un-knowing Public

in Climate Science

as you will continue to Ignore

Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

for your

Personal Feelings of True Belief

~

~ Scott ~

Beyond

Political Media Hearsay

~ Belief ~

$100,000.00

Reward

for

the scientific references

proving

Carbon based Humans ~ cause ~ Climate Warming ~ of this ~ Carbon based Earth

with

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

Carbon Dioxide

~ CO2 ~

2 oxygen atoms based to 1 carbon atom

the cause of

all

Nature

~ The Carbon Cycle ~

with

Oxygen and Hydrogen

causing

all

Carbon based Life and Energy

on this

Carbon ~ based ~ Earth

~

In Real Science

The Real Deniers

are those who

Ignore Test Proven Fact for Their Personal Emotional Feelings of True Belief

while

Politically sided so called News

has zero credibility

in tested reality

~

~*~

~

Scott does not

~ know ~

he is Preaching Bogus Science

because

A ~ Scott is not a Scientist of the Scientific Method

and

B ~ Scott did not Investigate the Tested Knowledge

with the Scientific Method

~

Scott just Believes

in the

Political ~ Media

hearsay

~ Belief ~

~

Scott

if you believe Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

Prove It

beyond

Your Personal Emotional Feelings of True Political Media Belief

Confront Tested Reality

by

Confronting ~ Your ~ True Belief

by

Testing the Knowledge to Test Your Belief

~ while ~

Tested Reality ~ debunks ~ Untested Belief

in

~ tested ~

Knowledge

of

The Scientific Method

~

~*~

To: All Political Media Environmental Extremest

~ please stop calling me a ~

Denier of Climate Change

and then

that will be one less

~ proven ~

Political Media Lie

by

Climate Religion

~*~

~

to

~ predict ~

is:

to say in advance

(what one ~ believes ~ will happen)

and

proves nothing in tested science

~

to

~ believe ~

is:

(to have faith)

and

proves nothing in tested science

~

~ faith ~

is:

(a feeling)

and

proves nothing in tested science

~

~*~

~

~ anyone and everyone ~

who

Ignore

Proven Fact Tested

~ Knowledge ~

for

~ their ~

True Feelings of True Belief in self-debunked Prediction

is: not

a

Scientist

of

The Scientific Method

~

~*~

~

~ science ~

is:

to ~ know

~

~ reality ~

is:

what you can see and can prove as fact tested knowledge

~ not ~

what you believe in your mind and can not prove

~

The Scientific Method

is:

new tested knowledge

incorporated into the preexisting known tested knowledge

that

supports ~ or ~ debunks

the preexisting known tested knowledge

~

science is:

defined tested knowledge ~ not ~ a feeling of true belief in self-debunked prediction

science is:

~ never settled ~

science is:

the skepticism of belief dictating science

~ because ~

Belief that Ignores Test Proven Fact

is: not

Tested Reality in Science

~

~*~

bruce@co2u.info

~*~

~

while

we do not know more than we know

~

hopefully

one day

I can stop Attacking Fools in Science

who can prove nothing

and can not admit they do not know

who are Preaching not Teaching

Self-debunked Garbage Science to our Children

that Ignores 99% of all fact tested knowledge

so I can write about

just the Science

while I am sponsored by nothing

and inspired only by Tested Truth

~

Science can only be ~

beyond Belief

as the belief

of

Religious Lunatics

will continue to

destroy

Carbon based Life

as it has for thousands of years

as tens of thousands starve to death everyday

on this

Carbon based Earth

as

we will spend trillions

trying to control Weather we do not and can not control

while

Blaming God for all the Good Weather

while blaming all Carbon based Humans for all the Bad

while

doing only Harm to the Carbon Cycle

~

~*~

~

180 years

of

~ Test Proven Fact ~

beginning

with French Chemist

Charles Thilorier

in 1835

who discovered Dry Ice

but frozen CO2 was not called Dry Ice until the 1920’s

when it was patented

then used to refrigerate while transporting fresh produce

until modern mechanical refrigeration was invented by science

Frozen CO2 is called Dry Ice

because CO2 is never in a natural liquid state

CO2 can be Frozen and when it thaws it instantly becomes a gas

CO2 can only become a liquid when stored under pressure in a container

~

Charles discovery was followed by

60 years of University testing across Europe

followed by world wide testing to the present

~ proving beyond belief ~

CO2 causes Cooling not Warming

caused by CO2 absorbing more heat and energy than the surrounding gases

making the surrounding gases cooler not warmer

while frozen CO2 absorbs heat and energy 10 times faster than frozen water

20 times longer than frozen water

making the surrounding gases cooler not warmer

as

Heat is not Trapped by CO2

because

Heat still Rises

CO2 does not and can not generate new Heat and Energy

CO2 can only Transfer Preexisting

Heat and Energy

that is all ready in the atmosphere

CO2

removes Heat and Energy from the lower Atmosphere

and transfers the Heat and Energy to the upper Atmosphere

causing

increased levels of

Frozen -200 degree CO2 from the upper Atmosphere

to come crashing down to the Earth Poles

cooling the air many times faster than the increased levels of frozen water vapor

caused by increased evaporation of Ocean

caused by increased warming by the variable Sun

the Ocean containing many times the CO2 than the atmosphere

from billions of years of on going volcanic activity below Sea level

Water Vapor and CO2 causing the First Atmosphere causing Nature

The Carbon Cycle

causing

all

Carbon based Life

~

Now add a dozen proven Climate Variables ignored by Climate Religion

~

This is tested knowledge that has yet to be debunked by tested knowledge

~ while ~

Belief

~ in ~

self-debunked

Computer Climate Prediction of the Future

based on flawed incomplete science

is:

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

~ not ~

Proven

Fact Tested Knowledge

of

The Scientific Method

~ while ~

Where I Live

Helena ~ Montana

~ every hour ~

the five day computer weather prognostication is:

self-debunked

and every hour ~ many ~ new five day computer

~ Predictions ~

to choose from

of the weather future are self-debunked

~ every hour ~

where here in Helena Montana the saying goes ~

…if you do not like the weather in Montana

wait 20 minutes

~

I Bruce Allen Kershaw

with

39 years

of

Atmospheric Emission Control Science

Physics ~ Chemistry and Emissions

Testing

~ do not deny ~

Climate Change

~ while ~

I and the Scientific Community

can prove with

Fact Tested Knowledge

Carbon based Humans do not cause Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

with

Man ~ Made

~ CO2 ~

while

Proving Fraud in Science by Political Media Climate Religion

who have publicly failed grade school science

and have earned zero right to scientific opinion

as Climate Religion continues to ignore the

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

for ~ their ~ true belief in self-debunked computer prediction

based on flawed incomplete ~ so called science

~ * ~

I am not a Writer or Journalist

I am a Dyslexic Scientist

who failed English

~

I do not have an Editor

I am ~ all on my own

and I know I am very repetitive

in my less than friendly factual responses

~ to the test proven ~

misinformed public statements by others about science

based on debunked

~ Belief ~

while Repetitive Science Education is very important for the longevity of tested knowledge

that is to easily forgotten or never learned or ignored in this new world of Specialty Science

while

many try to belittle me in their communications with me

based only on our given Titles in Life

while calling me a Denier of something I do not Deny

as Proven Lies by Proven Lairs

continue their effort to discredit me and my life

while I refuse to give up

I refuse to ignore the Test Proven Truth for Proven Pathological Belief

while Climate Religion has yet to provide any Scientific Reference

to support their debunked statements

and hopefully one day I will find an Science Editor

who can Comprehend the

Physics ~ Chemistry

and

Heat Transfer Science

until then

I will make an effort to condense and better my articulation of the tested science

~ while ~

Self-debunked ~ Peer-reviewed

~ Prediction ~

based on

Fact Tested ~ Proven Lies

~ is: not ~

Science

~

~ * ~

Forecast

Prognostication

Hypothetical Conjecture

is:

Prediction

~ not ~

Science

because

science is to know ~ through tested knowledge

~ not ~

belief in self-debunked prediction

~

….and the Political Media Brainwashing of this Carbon based World

~ with ~

Climate Religion

the paranoid belief in self-debunked computer climate prediction of the future

~ while ~

the last 4.6 billion years of very extreme

~ variable ~

progressive climate change

for a dozen known variable reasons

providing an infinity of climate variable

is: very real

~ but ~

not caused by Carbon based Humans of this Carbon based Earth

with

Human

~ caused ~

2 oxygen atoms ~ based to ~ 1 carbon atom

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

the by-product of energy ~ not a cause of energy

and is less than 10% of the CO2 in the Atmosphere

while over 90% of the CO2 going into in the Air every day

is from volcanic activity below sea level

and is the by product of energy

from the Hot Liquid Core of this Carbon based Earth

~ on going for billions of years ~

CO2 causing with water vapor the first atmosphere

causing

~ Nature ~

while CO2 has zero

Color ~ Taste ~ Smell

and once again

Frozen ~ CO2 ~ is called

~ Dry Ice ~

cooling the Air 10 times faster and 20 times longer than frozen water

as increased levels of

Frozen Water Vapor and Frozen CO2

come crashing toward the north and south poles

of this Carbon based Earth

as heat continues to rise at the Equator

with increased levels of water vapor and CO2 from evaporation of Ocean

caused by increased warming by the

Variable Sun

~ while ~

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

is:

the cause of

all

~ Nature ~

the Carbon cycle

with

Oxygen and Hydrogen

the cause of

all

Carbon based Life and Energy

on this

Carbon based Earth

while

increased levels of  water vapor and carbon dioxide

by evaporation of Ocean

caused by increased warming by the

~ very ~

Variable ~ SUN

is off-setting warming

while very beneficial to nature

~ The Carbon Cycle ~

and is not harmful to Carbon based Humans

or any Carbon based Life above and below Sea level

on this Carbon based Earth

~

Atmospheric Warming occurs First

then

Water Vapor and CO2 levels Rise

~

~ * ~

~

Belief

in

Forecast

Prognostication

~ Prediction ~

by

Hypothetical ~ Conjecture

is: not ~

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge of the Scientific Method

~ while ~

Hypothetical Conjecture

are nothing but fancy words

for guessing

based on Belief in unproven science

~ while ~

Belief

in

Self-debunked Computer Prediction

is:

Religion ~ not ~ Science

~

guessing is not science

~ because ~

~ guessing the future is not tested knowledge ~

science is: to know = tested knowledge

~ not ~

belief in guessing the future while ignoring

Test Proven Fact

that proves the guess was wrong

before the guess was made

while the guess has been self-debunked

because the prediction did not happen

because the opposite of the prediction is happening

because as water vapor and CO2 levels increase caused by increased warming

caused by increased Evaporation of Ocean

caused by the variable Sun

the rate of warming is slowing down not speeding up as predicted

off-setting warming

as the variable Sun continues to be warmer and brighter

~ validating ~

180 years of test proven knowledge in chemistry

and

45 years of test proven emission control science

~ science enforced by the EPA today since the 1970’s ~

and is:

Physics ~ Chemistry and Heat Transfer Science

the Politically based EPA does not comprehend

along with

millions of years of climate history

supported by

Geology and Ice Core Samples

~ All ~

Proving CO2 causes Cooling

~ not ~

Warming

~ All ~

Ignored by Climate Religion

who believe in self-debunked prediction

~

This is like

believing it is raining

when the sun is shining

~

I do not believe People who tell me it is raining

when I can see with my own eyes

~ it is not ~

~

~*~

~

David did not test the tested science

David just believes in the hearsay belief ~

~

Do not Pray for me David W. Titley

Look at ~ and Test

the tested scientific knowledge that debunk your true belief in belief

~ and ~

Prove your Religion is not a Test Proven

~ pathological ~

Political Media Religion

because

Praying for Me

will prove nothing in tested science of the Scientific Method

~

~ science is tested and debated knowledge ~

~ while ~

calling prediction or hypothetical conjecture

~ Science ~

is:

Fraud in Science

because

science is: to know

to know is: knowledge

while

self-debunked

Prediction

based on

Hypothetical Conjecture

is: not

knowledge

and not science of the scientific method

~

…because you believe in prediction  ~

does not make self-debunked prediction ~ test proven fact

~ while ~

predicting the future is not tested and debated knowledge

~ while ~

Belief in self-debunked computer Prediction of the future is Religion

~ while ~

one thousand years ago

Montana

had California Climate for 200 years

not caused by

~ CO2 ~

or by

Carbon based Humans

of this

Carbon based Earth

~ while ~

Michael Mann

left this knowledge out of his Hockey Stick

~ while ~

the climate is different everywhere

so every Tree Ring tells a different story

~ as ~

CO2 levels continue to increase

the rate of climate warming continues to slow down

and not speed up

as

~ Predicted ~

by computers

based on Human Belief

programmed into computers

that ignores

all test proven fact

~

I have e-mailed Michael many times

and he has yet to provide a Scientific Reference

to support his belief beyond self-debunked computer prediction

~ while ~

Increased levels of Water Vapor and CO2 is the by product of Increased Warming

the CO2 from billions of years of on going Volcanic activity below Sea level

causing the first atmosphere and the carbon cycle

and all carbon based Life

while

acidifying the ocean over billions of years

while

off setting Warming

not causing Climate Warming

caused by ~ the very variable

SUN

~ while ~

True Believers

reject all of this tested knowledge

for their true belief in hearsay belief

~ as ~

Michael Mann

refuses to debate his Pathological Belief in Belief

while

ignoring

test proven fact of the scientific method

proving

Michael Mann

is a Preacher of Belief in self-debunked computer climate prediction of the future

by Climate Religion

not

a Scientist

of the

Scientific Method

~ * ~

Ignoring Tested Knowledge for True Belief is Religion not Science

while

a large number of working Weather Stations in remote places

all around this Carbon based Earth

have been turned off

and replaced with weather stations placed on the top of Tared Roofs

next to Heating and Air Conditioning outlets

and along very busy paved highways

providing very bogus Weather Measurements

being used as science evidence of Climate Warming

by

Carbon based Humans

~ while ~

Climate Warming

that began ~ this time ~ 14,000 years ago

not

40 or 400 or 4000

years ago

proving the lack of climate history and science knowledge by climate religion

~ while ~

Proving Fraud in Tested Science and Climate History

~

~ as we are now breaking record temperatures of 130 years ago ~

record temperatures set before Power Plants and Automobiles

so it took 130 years to be as warm as 130 ago

~

~ * ~

October 4, 2015

I have received two reply’s from

David Titley

Penn State University

~

In Davids second reply to me

David said he would Pray for me

~ my response was ~

Praying is for Religion not Tested Science

~

If David can not prove or debate his true belief as tested fact

this proves his belief is a political media religion not a science

while David can prove nothing beyond his true belief in

Hypothetical Conjecture

Prognostication

~ Prediction ~

proving

David is a Political Media Preacher not a Science Teacher

who will never

Debate

the

Tested Science

of the

Scientific Method

or look at the tested facts that debunk his true belief

~

David must test the science to earn the right to scientific opinion

beyond his belief in self-debunked computer prediction

based on

Test Proven Bogus Science

~

Belief in self-debunked computer prediction of the future

is not Scientific Hypothesis

or

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~ while ~

True Belief in self-debunked Prediction

is now responsible for

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

while providing nothing beyond

~ their ~

Test Proven Fraud

to support ~ their ~ True Belief

in

self-debunked

Computer

Prediction

~ while ~

David chooses to pray for me

instead of looking at the tested science knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~ while ~

Belief in Self-debunked Hypothetical Conjecture

is not

Tested Reality in Science

~

Climate Religion will not debate ~ their ~ self-debunked Prediction

based on

Flawed ~ Incomplete

self-debunking

Hypothetical Conjecture

based on

Flawed ~Incomplete

outdated

Science Papers

~ while ~

Committing Test Proven Fraud to support ~ their ~ True Belief

~ while ~

Praying in Science

does not change test proven fact

~

David can not prove there is a God

or

~ Prove ~

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

~

when you can not debate the science

it is no longer science

while

praying for me

proves nothing in tested science

praying only proves ~ your ~ faith in your religion

when there is zero faith or religion in tested science

of the

Scientific Method

~ proving ~

True Believers who refuse to look at tested science

are not

Scientist

~

Belief in self-debunked computer prediction is:

~ the rejection of the scientific method ~

proving

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

~ because ~

Reality in Science ~ is: test proven knowledge ~ not ~ true belief

~ in ~

self-debunked

Prediction of the Future

~

David

Prove I am Wrong

debunk

the tested knowledge that further debunk your true self-debunked belief

Tested Knowledge

that you refuse to acknowledge to exist

proving you are a true believer

and not a scientist

while

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

refuses to debate the tested knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

Belief in self-debunked Prediction

while Ignoring

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

while refusing to debate the science

is:

~ Proven ~

Lunatic Belief

~

Lunatic Belief

does not debunk test proven scientific

Reality

~

There is zero logic or common sense

in

Political Media

Paranoid

Climate Religion

~

~*~

~

~ this is my first e-mail ~

To:

David Titley

dwt12@psu.edu

of

Penn State University

while

David does not comprehend the Physics, Chemistry and Heat Transfer Science

or the Scientific Method

while

Ignoring Test Proven Fact

David can provide zero scientific reference beyond his true belief to support his true belief

~ proving ~

David is a Preacher of Prediction by Hypothetical Conjecture

with zero

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge of the Scientific Method

~

David

you are full of Test Proven Baloney

because

you can not prove

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

with

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

~

Your

Belief in self-debunked Prediction

is not Science of the Scientific Method

I Challenge you David to an open public debate in tested science

not

self-debunked

Computer Prediction

based on

outdated

Incomplete Science Papers

from the 1800’s

that Ignores

a dozen known Climate Variables

and

180 years of test proven chemistry

and

4.6 Billion years

of

Climate History

that further debunk

the self-debunked

Hypothetical Conjecture

and

self-debunked

Computer Prediction

~

I have e-mailed this statement to David Titley

and wait for his response and his scientific references

proving

Carbon based Humans

cause

all or any

Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

beyond

the

Make Believe Science

with

~ Zero ~

Scientific Method

~

David will not be debating ~ his ~ true belief

in his test proven flawed incomplete bogus science

~ while ~

David can not prove his Religion is not a Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

~

~ make believe is not science ~

~

~*~

~ The Religion of Science is Skepticism of Religion in Science ~

Who’s Religion should Dictate and Control Science and Government ?

as the Political Media continues to ignore test proven fact for their true belief

~*~

~

What do you call a person who

continues to Believe in and Preach

Failed ~ self-debunked ~ Prediction

for the sake of

Profit

~ while ~

Al Gore is: mostly Hydrogen

20% Carbon

while breathing

Oxygen

caused by the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

~ Cycle ~

caused by

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

from the

Hot Liquid Core of this Carbon based Earth

as the

Very Variable

Hot Churning  Liquid Core

causing

Variable Hot Spots and Volcanic Activity

from 25 miles below the surface of this Carbon based Earth

while

Heating the Ocean and lower Atmosphere

of this

Carbon based Earth

with the help of the

~ very ~

Variable Sun

as the variable Sun continues to be warmer and brighter over time

with a 3 million mile ~ variable ~ distance

between this Carbon based Earth and the Very Variable Sun

while the Variable size of the Ozone Hole is caused by variable density of the Atmosphere

caused by the variable solar activity by the Variable Sun

causing a variable of energy to inter and escape the atmosphere

causing

20 Ice ages and 20 global warming periods

in just the last 2 million years

with the Ocean 350 feet lower than today 26,000 years ago

and 60 feet higher than today 135,000 years ago

of

4.6 billion years of very Extreme Progressive Variable Climate Change

for a dozen known variable variables

with Water Vapor and CO2 the by product of Climate Warming

while offsetting Warming

with 180 years of test proven Chemistry

and

Climate History

proving CO2 causes Cooling not Warming

~

All of this Knowledge is Ignored by Climate Religion

~ while ~

Al Gore is not a Scientist of the Scientific Method

Al Gore has Publicly Failed Grade School Science

Al Gore dose not Represent the Scientific Community

as the proven Hypocrite Al Gore makes his Fortune

with a very corrupted word wide Carbon Credit Scheme

~ since ~

the spring of 2007

I have made e-mail request

from all the Organizations Al Gore has founded or represents

for the Scientific References

proving

Carbon based Humans

cause

Climate Warming

and the only thing they can prove is their ability to block my e-mails

after providing

proven

Bogus

References

~ while ~

Glacier Ice Melts and falls into the Ocean during Ice Ages too

caused by the Hot Liquid Core of this Carbon based Earth heating and melting the Glaciers

from the bottom side

and by direct Sun Energy separating the frozen Water

Sun Energy separating the Hydrogen from the Oxygen

from the top side

during Ice ages too

while

the evidence is very clear

the Glaciers have melted many times before in the last 2 million years

of the last 4.6 Billion years of

Very ~ Extreme

Very ~ Progressive

Climate Change

for many Vary Variable reasons

and all ignored by Al Gore

~

Al Gore is a Test Proven Political Media Liar and Fraud in Science

proven by the Scientific Community ignored by Climate Religion

while

Al Gore will not publicly debate

~ His ~

Emotional Feelings of True Belief

in self-debunked computer prediction

based on debunked Hypothetical Conjecture

based on zero proven fact tested knowledge of the scientific method

~

Al Gore Ignores Fact Tested Knowledge for ~ His ~ True Pathological

~ Lunatic Belief ~

~

Make Believe does not debunk hundreds of years of Test Proven Fact

of the

Scientific Method

~

~*~

Water Vapor

and

~ CO2 ~

causing the first atmosphere

causing

the Carbon cycle

causing

~ all ~

Nature

causing

~ all ~

Carbon based Life and Energy on this Carbon based Earth

is:

~ not ~

poison ~ or ~ pollution

on this

Carbon based Earth

where

~ everything ~

has Carbon in it

~

…why does Political Media Religion control this Carbon based Earth ?

~ while knowing ~

very extreme

progressive

variable

Climate Change is Real

for the last 4.6 billion years

for a dozen known ~ variable ~ reasons

providing an

Infinity of Climate Variable

~ while knowing ~

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

by

Carbon based Humans

is a ~ test proven ~ Pathological Consensus ~ not ~ a Scientific Consensus

~*~

~ ? ~

Why do some carbon based People continue to Believe in self-debunked

Computer Prediction

based on

Flawed ~ Incomplete ~ Science

~ ? ~

~*~

while this explains why some

Politicians and Journalist

and

Environmental Extremest

who would fail grade school science

are Preaching Lies to the Public

because

Climate Religion

truly believe in their ~ test proven ~ political media lies

~*~

~ while ~

…once again ~

there is no longer

Separation of Church and State

and ~ or

Separation

of

Church and Science

~ as ~

Political Media Religion

continues

trying to control

the

Government and Science

with ~ their ~ True Belief

~ while ~

97 %

is:

a fact tested proven

Political Media Lie

~

Less than 1 % of the Scientific Community

~ believe ~

but can not prove

with

tested knowledge

that

Carbon based Humans

cause

Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

with

carbon ~ based ~ oxygen

CO2

carbon ~ dioxide

as

Test Proven Fraud continues by Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

~*~

~

The

Scientific Method

~ vs ~

Climate Religion

…why should 4.6 billion years of very extreme progressive variable climate change

~ for a dozen known reasons ~

stop

?

~ * ~

~ Test Proven Scientific Fact ~

The by product

of

burning carbon based fuel

is:

new carbon based life and energy

on this

Carbon based Earth

through

the carbon cycle

with

oxygen and hydrogen

while

the more efficiently carbon based fuel is burned

the higher the level of

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide is produced

for plants and trees to breathe

making oxygen for us to breathe

while

becoming our carbon based food

while

the less efficiently carbon based fuel is burned

the higher level of

Carbon based Oxygen = CO = Carbon Monoxide is produced

while

the Hydrocarbons from Burning Coal

make a forest Healthier and Stronger

~

There are many examples of what may be bad for Carbon based Humans

is very good for Carbon based Nature the Carbon cycle

while

the

United Nations

can ~ not ~ prove

with

Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

that

Carbon based Humans

cause

all ~ or ~ any

Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

~ with ~

2 oxygen atoms ~ based to ~ 1 carbon atom

=

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

the cause of the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

causing

all Carbon based Life and Energy

on this

Carbon based Earth

~ so ~

how can you prove

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

all ~ or ~ any

Climate Change ~ or ~ Climate Warming

when

the United Nations can prove nothing

beyond

self-debunked

Prediction

?

~

The UN states it is ~ likely ~ Humans cause Climate Change

~ while ~

likely is: a feeling

~ not ~

a test proven fact

likely

is:

a word of true belief and proves nothing in tested knowledge

of

the scientific method

~ while ~

words prove nothing in tested science

~

The word Likely is the basses for all belief

in

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

while the U.N. lives with a proven history of proven fraud in climate science

along with ~ their ~ Scientist

who have proven to be far less than Honorable

~

~*~

~

~ to ~

www.Mtcares.org

Montana Cares

and

John Soderberg & Mike Phillips

~

~ Excluding Fact Tested Knowledge from Hearsay Belief is not Science ~

~

I Challenge Montana Cares

to an open public debate

with a

$100,000.00

~ REWARD ~

for the proof beyond their

hearsay

~ Belief ~

Carbon based Humans

cause

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~

Prove your Political Media Climate Religion

~ is not ~

a Test Proven Religion

~ while ~

Steven W. Running

Ignores

Proven Fact Test Knowledge of the Scientific Method

for his self-debunked Computer Prediction of the Future

Prediction based on

outdated

incomplete

self-debunking science papers from the 1800’s

that ignores

180 years of test proven chemistry

and

a dozen climate variables

with each variable a variable

causing a continuous progression of variable

providing and proving an ~ Infinity ~ of progressive climate variable

for the last 4.6 billion years

~ while ~

Steven W. Running

who I have emailed many times since 2007

will not debate his true belief

in self-debunked

Prediction

or

~ Debate ~

the test proven facts

that further debunk his self-debunked prediction

Steven W. Running

will not acknowledge test proven fact for the sake of his

Test Proven

self-debunked

Hypothetical Conjecture

Prediction

~ Steven W. Running ~

believes ~ and ~ preaches

the Very Variable ~ SUN ~ is not a Variable

as the Variable ~ SUN ~ continues to be Warmer and Brighter over time

Steven believes there is only ~ 1 ~ climate variable

when there are a Dozen Known Variable Variables

providing an infinity of climate variable

~

~ make believe science is: science-fiction not tested reality in science ~

~

Steven W. Running

~ can prove zero ~

and

will not debate

~ his ~

Religion

or the Tested Science he Ignores

for

~ his ~

True Belief

~

~*~

Self-debunked

Hypothetical Conjecture

~ Prediction ~

is not

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge of the Scientific Method

or

Tested Reality

~

Science is Tested and Debated

~ not ~

Make Believe

~

Hypothetical Conjecture is not Knowledge

~ while ~

science is: to know

not

Political Media ~ Make Believe

in

self-debunked

Prediction

~

Self -debunked Prediction

does not debunk hundreds of years

of

preexisting

Hard Science of the Scientific Method

~ while ~

Mike Phillips

is a Politician not a Scientist

who has

Publicly Failed Grade School Science

and has earned ~ zero ~ right to any scientific opinion

while knowing

Mike’s Belief in Political Media Hearsay

~ is not ~

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge of the Scientific Method

~ Mike ~

why do four dozen NASA Scientist Disagree with you

and over 9,000 PhD’s

of over 32,000 Scientist that I know of who disagree with you too

along the the Supreme Court of the State of Montana

who disagree with your Political Media Religion

~ Mike ~

why do they disagree with you ?

while

Mike can not answer that very import question

because

there is no science in his Pathological

True Belief

?

~

Belief

~ in ~

Self-debunked Prediction is Religion not Science

Political Media Religion ~ is not ~ Science

Montana Cares is a Political Media Church

not a Science Body

and can prove nothing with

Tested Knowledge of the Scientific Method

~ as ~

We live with the real threat of

Total Nuclear Destruction of all Life on this Carbon based Earth everyday

while tens of thousands are Starving to Death everyday

with over 40,000 underfeed Children just in Montana U.S.A.

as increased levels of Water Vapor and CO2

make this Carbon based Earth Greener not Browner

to grow more Carbon based food not less Carbon based Food

from

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon ~ Dioxide

for Carbon ~ based ~ People to eat

while

~ there are those ~

who are willing to spend

Tens of Trillions of Dollars

trying to stop 4.6 billion years of very extreme very progressive very variable

Climate Change

based on Belief in Political Media Hearsay

while doing only harm to the Carbon Cycle and all Carbon based Life

of this Carbon based Earth

~ while it has been proven ~

CO2 causes Cooling not Warming

while this tested knowledge continues to be Ignored by Climate Religion

for the sake of

Personal Feelings

of

True Belief

~ proving ~

Steve and Mike

~ are ~

Test Proven

Pathological Frauds in Science

~*~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~*~

~ to ~

John Rundquist

Helena ~ Montana

and the

Montana Environmental

~ test proven ~

~ mis ~

Information Center

meic.org

meic@meic.org

~

John,

why will the

Helena Independent Record

~ Publish ~

Your Belief Opinion

with zero scientific reference

and will not Publish test proven scientific fact with scientific reference

why

has the IR taken sides in science they do not comprehend

~ while ~

…what you know ~

can be measured

~ while ~

what you do not know

~ can not ~

because

what you do not know ~ is ~ more than you know

~

I Challenge you

John Rundquist

to an open public debate in tested Climate knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

with a

$100,000.00

~ Reward ~

for the fact tested measured knowledge

proving

Carbon based Humans

cause

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

with

Man Made

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

~ while ~

Human caused CO2 in the Atmosphere is less than 10% of the CO2 in the Atmosphere

~ thee equivalent of ~

a sewing tread down the middle of the fifty yard line of a football field

if

the atmosphere was the size of a football field

~

~ John can prove nothing beyond his Belief ~

while the

MEIC

is a Political Media Body not a Science Body

providing only their Belief to the Public

~ with ~

Zero

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

Political Media Climate Religion ~ is: not ~ Scientific Fact

because

science is to know

~ not ~

make believe

~

Preaching Climate Religion is not Science

while

Climate Religion will not debate the Tested Science

of the

Scientific Method

~ so why does ~

Political Media Climate Religion

Ignore

test proven fact

for Belief in

Self-debunked Computer Prediction of the Future

~ ? ~

and why do they refuse to debate the science

~ because ~

they are a test proven

Political Media Religion

with

Zero Tested Science

to support their true belief

~

There is nothing beyond Words of Belief

to prove

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Warming of this carbon based Earth

~ while ~

Words Prove Nothing in Science

~

Science ~ is: to ~ know

~ not ~

belief in words

or

self-debunked

Computer Prediction of the Future

~

John Rundquist

and the

MEIC

will not debate

~ their ~

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

~ while ~

Science is: Tested and Debated Knowledge

~ not ~

Personal Emotional Feelings

of

True Belief

in

self-debunked

Computer Prediction of the Future

~

Self-debunked prediction does not debunk hard science of the scientific method

while hearsay belief is not tested knowledge

~

John,

the United Nations can not prove Humans cause Climate Warming

so how can you ?

John,

what you believe is the opposite

of test proven reality

~

Just

Believing

is: not ~ Science

Just Believing is: Religion

~

I have been emailing reward offers to meic.org for many years

for the Proof

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

and still nothing

because

they can prove

~ nothing ~

beyond

Test Proven

Make Believe

~

From:

bruce@co2u.info

39 years

Atmospheric Emission Science

and

my on going Climate Science Investigation since the Spring of 2007

with over 40,000 e-mail request since 2007

with a reward

for the measured fact tested scientific references

~ Proving ~

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Warming of this Carbon based Earth

with

(two oxygen atoms ~ based ~ to one carbon atom)

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

CO2

Carbon Dioxide

di ~ is ~ two

oxide ~ is ~ oxygen

C ~ O2

Carbon and Oxygen

bonded together by energy and heat

~ the ~

Bases for the Carbon Cycle

and all Carbon based Life and Energy on this Carbon based Earth

while

many who would fail grade school science

believe

carbon

~ is ~

Poison and Pollution

and

dioxide = oxygen

~ is ~

Poison and Pollution

when in fact

all the oxygen we breathe today

and all the Carbon based Food we eat

comes from

~ CO2 ~

through the Carbon Cycle

~ while ~

The

~ 1896 ~

Arrhenius Paper

is an incomplete outdated science paper

that ignores a dozen known Climate Variables

while being used as

~ Proof ~

Carbon based Humans cause all Climate Change

by many Scientist and Organizations

~

The Arrhenius Paper

proves only one thing

~ in ~

Tested Knowledge of the Scientific Method

~ Fraud ~

by those using it as

~ Proof ~

Carbon based Humans cause all Climate Change

~

Climate Change is: Real

~ but ~

not caused by

Carbon based Humans

of this

Carbon based Earth

while

no one ~ can prove ~ otherwise

with

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

of

~ the ~

Scientific Method

while

one small fragment of incomplete knowledge

that ignores all known tested knowledge

can not debunk all known test proven knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

~*~

~

~ to ~

Matthew Elsaesser

City Commissioner

Helena ~ Montana

~

Matthew,

it was good to see you again at the Lewis and Clark Tap Room

this time with the Mayor of Helena Montana

Jim Smith

and thank you for introducing me to the Mayor,

as he very quickly slipped away ~

from knowing me

from all the many e-mails I have have sent to him ~

over the many years

as he was running from Reality,

something some politicians are very good at ~

while

Jim has been a Positive part of the Helena Community for many years

~

Matthew,

If you believe it ~

its called Religion

If you can prove it ~

with fact test knowledge of the scientific method

then it is called science

and if you can not debate it

or answer the logical questions

then

its not real

~

Matthew

why does your Climate Religion

call ~ White Steam

coming out of Smoke Stakes

Pollution ?

 and

the cause of the Carbon Cycle and all Carbon based Life and Energy

on this

Carbon based Earth

with zero

Color ~ Taste ~ Smell

Pollution ?

~

Matthew can not publicly debate his Belief

because

his belief

is:

not science

~

Matthew,

your ~ Belief ~ is:

~ a ~

test proven

Religion

~ Matthew refuses to look at test proven knowledge for the sake of his true Belief ~

proving

Matthew has Failed

Grade School Science

because

Matthew does not comprehend tested knowledge

or the Scientific Method

Matthew is a true believer

with zero scientific reference beyond

Words

of

Political Media

~ true ~

Belief

~

Matthew

can prove

~ Nothing ~

with

Tested ~ Knowledge

~

Matthew

$ 100,000.00

~ Reward ~

for the scientific references

~ proving ~

Carbon based Humans

causes all or any

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~

Matthew

Prove your Religion is not a Religion

~

Matthew can prove nothing beyond ~ his ~ True Belief

while

Preaching his True Belief

proving once again

it is a test proven

Religion

~ not ~

Tested ~ Science

of the

Scientific Method

because

if you can not prove it

its not real

~

I have sent Matthew many reward offers for many years

and still Matthew can prove nothing with science

~ proving ~

Mathew’s Religion

~ is:

a Political Media Religion

committing

Political Fraud in Science

~

Matthew can prove Nothing

beyond

his

~ belief ~

in self-debunked Computer Prediction

~

while

~ many ~

Politicians

are

Test Proven Professional Liars

telling you what you want to here

regardless of the truth

for

Votes

~ while ~

Politicians and Journalist

~ never ~

debate ~ their ~ belief

in

Carbon based Humans cause all Climate Change of this Carbon based Earth

because

they have zero science

as they believe in

test proven

Hearsay

in

Political Media Lies

test proven by

~ the ~

Scientific Community

of the

Scientific Method

Ignored

by

Climate Religion

for their true belief

~

Politicians and Journalist feed on each others make believe Science

causing

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

while their Paranoid Religion can answer zero questions

in tested science

test proving

their belief is a religion

~ not ~

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

Belief is not Knowledge

Belief is Religion

while

skepticism is caused by those with feelings of true belief and faith as science

as true believers can not acknowledge tested reality

because they are controlled by their true belief in

~ test proven ~

self-debunked prediction

~

Politicians and Journalist

are the least knowledgeable in Climate Science

while

Dictating Bogus Science to the World

Bogus Science based only on Belief and ~ zero ~ Scientific Reference

while

Matthew has been for the most part a positive not a negative over all for the City of Helena

but

Matthew

is not

a scientist of the scientific method

and has earned ~ zero ~ right to

Scientific Opinion

Matthew’s true belief is not test proven science

while his true belief is harming this carbon based Earth and the carbon cycle

not

Helping this Carbon based Earth

~ causing ~

all

Carbon based Life and Energy

~

Matthew

you are doing a very good job reducing plastic from going back in the ground

~ where it came from ~

while my focus has been on Starvation

and

Nuclear Waste above and below Sea level

and the harm to the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen ~ Cycle

by

Climate Religion

~

Matthew,

~ maybe ~

one day we will deal with science together beyond your religion

and remind me to

~ too ~

buy you two Beers

~

~*~

~

~ to ~

Keila Szpaller

…do you know or do you believe ~

keila.szpaller@missoulian.com

~ while ~

Ice core samples show us ~

there have been Ice Ages with much higher levels of CO2 in the Atmosphere than today

while

~ science is skepticism of belief as science ~

~ Keila ~

are you

~ a ~

Investigative Journalist

Being ~ Neutral

while

Investigating all sides of a very important scientific Issue

or

do you just believe what you are told and want to believe

~ a ~

True Believer

taking sides in something you do not comprehend

and can not explain or prove with scientific reference

beyond

Political Media Hearsay

True ~ Belief

while

deciding for yourself what the public should be allowed to know or not know or believe

or

~ a ~

True Journalist

sharing all sides with the public

so the unknowing public can decide for them self

what is real and what is not

in tested reality

~ Keila ~

are you apart of

Political Media True Belief

or

Tested Reality

?

$100,000.00

~ REWARD ~

for the scientific references

~ Proving ~

Carbon based Humans

cause

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~ where ~

All Carbon based Life and Energy on this Carbon based Earth

comes from and through the Ocean

with the help of the Variable Sun

as the Sun becomes warmer and brighter over time

until one day the Variable Sun Vaporizes this Carbon based Earth

as the Variable Hot Churning Liquid Core of this Carbon based Earth

Heating the lower Atmosphere of this Carbon based Earth

continues to cool

while causing though volcanic activity and evaporation

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

Cycle

the Key to all Carbon based Life and Energy

on this Carbon based Earth

where everything has carbon in it

~

CO2

the cause of Carbon Cycle

~ from ~

4 billion plus years of

Volcanic Activity

Below Sea Level

causing with evaporated water vapor

by the Sun

the first Atmosphere

causing

the first Environment

causing

~ all ~

Nature

while

Acidifying the Ocean

for the last 4 billion plus years

~

as

Warming Increases

by the

Variable

SUN

Increased

Evaporation of Ocean

containing

many times the level of CO2 than the Atmosphere

from volcanic activity below Sea level

Rises

in to the -200 degree Air

forcing

-200 degree Air

with increased levels of Frozen Water Vapor and Frozen CO2

to come crashing down to this Carbon based Earths Poles

while

Frozen CO2 cools the Air many times faster and longer than Frozen Water

while increased evaporation of Ocean

containing many times the CO2 than the Atmosphere

increases Cloud Cover

while proving

Heat ~ still ~ Rises

~

Water Vapor and CO2 is the by product of Warming

while

off-setting increased Warming by the Variable Sun

~

CO2 does not Trap Heat

CO2 Transfers Heat

away from the lower Atmosphere

while

increased levels of

Frozen Water Vapor and CO2 from the upper Atmosphere

fills the void of negative pressure ~ a vacuum at the Earths Poles

caused by Heat Rising

off-setting

Warming by the Variable

SUN

~

Frozen CO2 is called

~ DRY ICE ~

and cools the Air 10 times faster and 20 times longer than frozen water

while

~ NOx ~

Emission Science

Enforced by the EPA

since the 1970’s

Proves

CO2 causes Cooling

~ too ~

and is tested knowledge

Ignored by

the

EPA

and by some so called

Climate Scientist

because

they obviously to not comprehend

the

Physics and Chemistry

that has been apart of my Professional Life

every ~ day

since 1976 ~ 39 years

~

NOx Emission Science Enforced by the EPA

to lower NOx

to lower ~ O3 ~ Oxygen called Ozone at ground level

to reduce Respiratory Illness

proving the EPA

does not comprehend

the

NOx Emission Science Physics and Chemistry they Enforce

since the 1970’s

making the Air we Breathe Cleaner

using the CO2 from the Tail Pipe of your car

to replace 1 percent of the Nitrogen in the combustion chamber with CO2

making the combustion chamber of your engine 1% CO2

to lower the the Explosion Temperature in your Engine 500 degrees

to lower NOx to lower Ozone

making the air cleaner

~

NOx is Nitrogen and Oxygen bonding at 2500 degrees and Hotter

then separated by Sun Energy causing O3 ~ Oxygen ~ Ozone

~

Lighting and Forest Fire cause NOx

causing the Ozone Layer

Protecting Us

from Sun Energy

while

The EPA is Run by Politicians

who would Fail Grade School Science

while

the first NOx Emission control Device

was on a 1971 Buick 350 cid V8 Gasoline Engine

in the State of California

using CO2 to make the Air Cleaner

by reducing

~ NOx ~

reducing O3 ~ Oxygen ~ Ozone at ground level

by making the combustion chamber 7% exhaust

with an EGR Valve

Exhaust Gas Recycle ~ Valve

replacing nitrogen with nitrogen from the exhaust

while making the combustion chamber 1% CO2

minus 1% nitrogen

while maintaining a 14.7 to 1 Air to Fuel Ratio

~

Nitrogen is 78.09% of the air and in the combustion chamber

and does not burn or vaporize in combustion

while

substituting 1% of the nitrogen with CO2

the CO2 can not burn or vaporize in combustion

but further retards combustion while acting like a heat sponge

making the surrounding gases cooler

lowering the combustion Temperature 500 degrees

~ while ~

The Ozone hole is a Continuous Climate Variable

for many variable reasons

controlling much of the energy that enters and escape the Atmosphere

and is only one of many examples of Climate Science

Ignored by

Climate Religion

~

Climate Religion

is based on

Hypothetical Conjecture

and

self-debunk Prediction

and flawed incomplete out dated Science Papers from the 1800’s

that does not incorporate

a dozen known Climate Variables

while the so called scientific consensus

is a proven Political Media Lie

by

Climate Religion who are Committing Test Proven Fraud in Science

as

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

 continues to refuse to debate the

~ proven fact tested knowledge ~

of the

Scientific Method

as

Climate Religion

continues to ignore

a dozen

known

Climate Variables

and

All Climate History

for

True

Make Believe

with

~ Zero ~

Hard Science

~

The Majority of Scientist are not True Believes

because

science is: to know

not

make believe

~

There is more tested knowledge missing from Climate Religion

than in Climate Religion

while

Climate Religion

will never acknowledge tested knowledge missing from there true belief

~

~ Keila ~

Do you Know the Knowledge

~ or ~

Do you Believe in the Belief

~ Keila ~

if you do not or can not comprehend this tested knowledge

then you have earned zero right to scientific opinion

Bruce

39 years Atmospheric Emission Science

while

I do not need a Computer to Predict the Future

~ I can use ~

Tarot Cards or Ouija Board or Flip a Coin

to

Predict ~ the ~ Future

~ as ~

self-debunked

Computer Prediction

is used to prove

Carbon based Humans cause Climate Change

~ as ~

Test Proven Fraud

by

Climate Religion

continues to grow on

while

Science debunks Climate Religion

while

Climate Religion will not acknowledge Tested Science

while

the number one cause of dirty Air here in Montana is

Carbon based Nature

while the words Likely and Unlikely

prove the very same thing in science

~ nothing ~

because

words prove nothing in science

~ conclusion ~

based on

Proven fact Tested Knowledge of the Scientific Method

CO2

~ still ~

causes

Cooling

off-setting

Warming

~

~ * ~

~

~ to ~

Michael DeGrandpre

michael.degrandpre@umontana.edu

University ~ of ~ Montana

~

Michael,

I enjoyed meeting your mother years ago

while picking out a beautiful peace of art work by your brother Dan

in your Mothers Basement here in Helena

in trade for work on Dan’s car many years ago

I think it was 1984

and thank you for communicating with me after my email to you a few years ago

and letting me know how Dan is doing ~

Dan is a very gifted Artist

as I love his work on my walls today and everyday

while you are a knowledgeable Scientist

while there is always ~ new ~ knowledge to learn and know

~ everyday ~

in test knowledge of the

Scientific Method

while

I look forward to meeting you one day and debating this tested reality ~

Bruce

~

Michael,

I have been working with Sensors and Analyzers and Test Equipment

~ everyday ~

of many types since 1972 ~

can your new sensor determine

how much CO2 and Acidification

in and of the Ocean is caused by Carbon based Humans

~ vs ~

how much CO2 and Acidification in and of the Ocean is caused by 4 billion plus years

of on going

~ continues ~

very ~ variable

volcanic activity below Sea level

from more than a thousand volcanic outlets that we know of ~

and

how does CO2 fall into the Ocean as Water is evaporated upward

containing many times the CO2 level than the atmosphere

from volcanic activity below Sea level

that caused the first Atmosphere and first Environment

causing

Carbon based Nature the Carbon Cycle

?

…while not one ~

Carbon ~ based ~ Human

on this

Carbon ~ based ~ Earth

can prove

with

Tested Knowledge

that

Carbon based Humans cause all or any Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

while ~ many

Carbon based Humans

continue to preach

~ their ~

Hypothetical Conjecture

while using incomplete science papers from the 1800’s

as proof in science

while providing nothing beyond self-debunked prediction to support there Belief

~ in ~

Carbon based Humans of this Carbon based Earth

cause

~ all ~

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~ with ~

Zero

Hard Science of any kind

~

~*~

while as CO2 levels continue to increase

the rate of Atmospheric Warming continues to slow down

~ not ~

Speed Up as Predicted

by

Steve Running and his Computer

~ validating ~

CO2 causes Cooling not Warming

while further validating 180 years of test proven chemistry

Ignored by so called Climate Scientist

while

Prediction is not Hypothesis

or

Science of the Scientific Method

science is: to know

while many Scientist continue to believe in self-debunked computer prediction

while using incomplete science paper as scientific proof for profit

while Ignoring tested knowledge that debunk their self-debunked belief

~

in tested science this is called test proven fraud

~

Why does Steve Running Ignore All known Climate History

and more than a dozen Climate Variables

each Variable with many variables giving us an infinity of Climate Variable

~ not ~

1

Climate Variable

for ~ All ~ Climate Change for the last 4.6 billion years

of far more extreme Climate Change than today

long before Carbon based Humans on this Carbon based Earth

when making his

Climate Predictions of the Future

while ~ knowing

ignoring fact for faith

is:

Religion not Science

while refusing to debate his true belief

in

Self-debunked

Prediction

while further ignoring preexisting test proven fact

for

~ debunked ~

Hypothetical Conjuncture

?

how can anyone make any prediction

based on only one factor when there is an infinity of factor

while all predictions that I know of in my life time are self-debunked

regardless of any factors

~

~*~

~

This

Carbon based Earth

causing

~ all ~

Carbon base Life and Energy

above and below Sea level

after

4.6 billion years of very extreme

progressive

very variable

Climate Change

~ while ~

Belief ~ in ~ Faith

~ in ~

Science

is:

~ not ~

knowledge

of

the scientific method

~ causing ~

Skepticism

of

belief in faith in science

~ because ~

science is: to know

~ not ~

make ~ believe

~ while ~

Blaming Humans for all or any Acidification the Ocean

is:

Bogus Hypothetical Conjecture

~ at best ~

while those who ~ believe ~ Humans are responsible

for all or any Acidification of the Ocean

will not debate the tested knowledge

that debunks their belief

making ~ their ~ belief

Bogus Science

~ not ~

Proven Fact Test Knowledge

of

The Scientific Method

~ while maybe ~

they do not comprehend the tested knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~ while ~

this Carbon based Earth continues to make Carbon based Oxygen

~ everyday ~

24/7

for billions of years

mostly from

Volcanic Activity below Sea level

from

hundreds of active Volcanic outlets today

of over a thousand known Volcanic outlets below Sea level

with another 50 ~ Major ~ short term Volcanic eruptions per year below Sea level

caused by the Hot Liquid Core of this Carbon base Earth

causing all Carbon based Plant Life in the Ocean

causing the Carbon Cycle below Seal level

while Oxygenating the Ocean

causing new

Carbon based Life in the Ocean

known as

all the Fish in the Sea

while

causing with water vapor

from Evaporation of Water and Ocean by the Variable Sun

the first

Atmosphere

causing

Nature

causing

the first Carbon based Life above Sea level

Plants and Trees

causing

more

Oxygen in the Atmosphere

while causing

The Carbon Cycle above Sea level

for the last 600 million years above sea level

with

Oxygen and Hydrogen

causing new

Carbon based Life

you and me

~ while ~

CO2 at 150 ppm (00.0150%) of the atmosphere

nothing will grow

~ while ~

CO2 at 210 ppm (00.0210%) of the atmosphere

Plants and Trees start Dying

~ while ~

CO2 at 400 ppm (00.0400%) of the atmosphere

Plants and Trees are starving for more CO2

~ while ~

CO2 at 1500 ppm (00.1500%) of the atmosphere

Plants and Trees are no longer starving for more CO2

and are at optimum health

while becoming our Carbon based Food

while making all the Oxygen we Breathe

from

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

~ while ~

John Kerry

Preaches

Plants and Trees can no longer absorb any more CO2

that Plants and Trees have absorbed all the CO2 they possibly can ~

John Kerry

who truly

believes his Lies

~ a Pathological Liar ~

has Failed Grade School Science

~

The Carbon Cycle

made from

Water Vapor

and

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

~ while ~

there is zero green on this carbon based earth when there is to little CO2

while increased Atmospheric warming increases water vapor

containing many times the of CO2 than the Atmosphere

making this Carbon based Earth Greener

~ not ~

Browner

~ while ~

…hope is the desire for something you wish could be ~

but has yet to be and may never be

Hope is: a Feeling

a wish

~ not ~

Tested Knowledge

~ while ~

…trust is earned not given ~

unless

she is a beautiful woman

then you trust her

with all your

Mind ~ Hart ~ Spirit

Living in your Soul

~ until ~

she proves to you ~ she can not be trusted

while

Emotional Feelings of True Belief

Prove Nothing in Tested Science

because

science is: to know

~ not ~

emotional

feelings of true belief

~

science is based on

proven fact tested knowledge of the scientific method

~ not ~

emotional

feelings

of

true

belief

in

self-debunked prediction of the future

because

there are no feelings

in

proven fact tested knowledge of the scientific method

because

there are no feelings in science

there are no emotions in science

there is no trust or faith or belief in tested science

there is only fact tested knowledge

with zero

Belief

because

belief in self-debunked prediction is belief in a feeling

~ not ~

test knowledge

because

science is: to know

not

make believe

in

feelings ~ of ~ belief

because

belief is: religion ~ not ~ science

~

when you place your Science in Belief in Faith

it is no longer Science

and when you Ignore the Tested Science

that debunks your Emotional Feelings of True Belief

that is called Religion

and when you Ignore Tested Science for Profit

that is called

~ Test Proven Fraud in Science ~

by those who choose to ignore

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

for

Belief ~ for ~ Profit

based on

Self-debunked

Hypothetical ~ Conjecture

with

~ Zero ~

Test Proven Knowledge

proving

Carbon based Humans

cause

all or any

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~

This Carbon based Earth

causing

The Carbon Cycle

and

All

Carbon based Life and Energy

with

Oxygen and Hydrogen

Water is:

H2O = Hydrogen and Oxygen

Gasoline is:

HC = Hydrogen and Carbon

when you add O2 = Oxygen to the HC = Hydrogen and Carbon

the Oxygen allows the Hydrogen to Vaporize making heat and energy

causing the Carbon to bond to the Oxygen from the Atmosphere

making

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

making

Plants and Trees

making

Oxygen

Contributing to the Carbon Cycle

~ not ~

Harming the Carbon Cycle

while

~ the humans body is:

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

the by product of the carbon cycle

while the

~ Cause ~

of the

Carbon Cycle

causing and making

all the

Carbon based Food We Eat

and all the

Oxygen We Breathe

is not

Pollution

~ while ~

Pumping CO2 in to the Ground

lowers Oxygen levels

because

you are not allowing the Carbon Cycle to Recycle the Oxygen from the Atmosphere

that allowed the Hydrogen to Vaporize

to go back in to the Atmosphere where it came from

while

turning under ground water in to an

~ Acid ~

~

The cause of the Carbon Cycle

 is the by product of Warming

while off-setting Warming

by

The Very Variable Sun

~

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

causes

Cooling ~ not ~ Warming

in

Tested Science

proving the

Hypothetical ~ Conjecture

is Test Proven to be

~ Backwards ~

causing a

~ Religion ~

by ~ of

self-debunked prediction

by true believers who would Fail Grade School Science

~

Belief in self-debunked Prediction

by

Flawed

Hypothetical Conjecture

is: not

Tested Science of the Scientific Method

~

?

why do carbon based humans

~ believe ~

the cause of the

First Atmosphere

causing

Nature

causing

the

Carbon Cycle

causing all carbon based life on this carbon based earth

while

causing all the carbon based food we eat and all the oxygen we breathe

~ is ~

Pollution

the answer is

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

~ not ~

Tested ~ Science

~

Carbon ~ is ~ Life

Carbon is the cause of ~ all ~ Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth

while

Pumping CO2 in to the Ground

lowers oxygen levels in the atmosphere

while

increasing nitrogen levels

while

turning under ground water in to an acid

as

Energy Company’s

~ Profit ~

from

Pumping CO2 in to the Ground

~

Climate Religion

is:

Harming this Carbon based Earth

~ not ~

Saving this Carbon based Earth

for the sake of belief not fact

as they continue to ignore

~ Fact Tested Knowledge ~

for

Make ~ Believe

in

self-debunked

Prediction

~

~ * ~

~

~ to ~

~ thee ~

Citizens Climate Lobby

ccl@citizensclimatelobby.org

~

~ Their ~

Science is Backwards

~ because ~

it is based on belief instead of tested knowledge

~

James Hansen and Katharine Hayhoe

~ do not ~

comprehend

the last 60 years of

Atmospheric Emission Science

Physics and Chemistry

or

They Choose to Ignore

the last 60 years

of

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

while

they can not prove with tested science

that

Carbon based Humans

of this

Carbon based Earth

cause

Climate Warming

because

Hypothetical Conjecture

~ Feelings of Belief ~

is  not

Proven Fact Test Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

while

James and Katharine

~ continue ~

to ignore

~ all ~

known

Fact Tested Knowledge

that further debunk ~ their ~ true feelings of belief

in

~ their ~

self-debunked

Hypothetical Conjecture

as they continue to Preach and Profit from ~ their ~ True Make Believe

while

~ Dictated ~

Political Media Feelings of Belief

is not

Tested ~ Debated ~ Science

of the

Scientific Method

while

~ a Carbon Tax will have zero effect on Climate Change ~

but

~ will make Energy Company’s and Billionaires very richer ~

while

for the last 18 years

as

CO2 levels have continued to increase

the rate of Climate Warming continues to slow down

~ not ~

speed up

debunking the computer climate prediction

while

further proving

CO2 ~ still ~ causes cooling

validating

180 years of test prove chemistry

Ignored by

Climate Religion

while

Climate History Further Debunk

Climate Religion

~ Example ~

~ Montana had California Climate for 200 years 1000 years ago ~

~

There are a ~ dozen ~ known climate variables

~ Example ~

~ the Very Variable Sun and Very Variable Distance between the Earth and Sun ~

Ignored by Climate Religion

while there have been

~ 20 Ice ages in the last 2 million years ~

with warming in between the Ice ages much warmer than today

while the Ocean has risen 350 feet in the last 26,000 years

and was 60 feet higher than today 135,000 years ago

while this warming period began 14,000 years ago not 40 years ago

while

~ All ~

of this

Knowledge

is

completely

Ignored by

Climate Religion

~ While ~

over 90 % of the CO2 going into the Atmosphere every day

is not caused by Carbon based Humans

it is caused by the Hot Liquid Core of this Carbon based Earth

through Volcanic activity below Sea Level

Evaporated

by the

~ very ~

Variable ~ Sun

causing

all Carbon based Life on this Carbon based Earth

while

Acidifying the Ocean over billions of years

while

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

is obsessed with stopping and removing

Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

while

CO2 and Water Vapor

caused of the first Atmosphere

causing Nature

causing the Carbon Cycle

causing

all Carbon based Life and Energy on this Carbon based Earth

~ while ~

All of this knowledge and much much more known knowledge

~ is ~

Ignored

for self-debunked prediction

based on

Flawed

Hypothetical ~ Conjecture

and

Flawed

Incomplete self-debunked Science Papers from the 1800’s

while

a Carbon Tax will do ~ nothing ~ for the on going

4.6 billion years of

Progressive

for many reasons

Climate Warming and Cooling

with the cost of a carbon tax on the backs of the poorest of the poor

a Carbon Tax on the cause of all Carbon based Life

on this Carbon based Earth

where everything living and not living has carbon in it

~

a carbon tax has nothing to do with saving this Carbon based Earth

or Carbon based Humans

from Carbon

~ it’s all about Money and Power ~

a carbon tax will make the rich people richer and poor people poorer

and will have zero effect on the many ~ Ignored ~ variables for Climate Change

while

Science is Tested and Debated

not

Dictated

while

Climate Religion Refuses to Debate

~ their ~

Test Proven Religion and Test Proven Fraud

~ while ~

18 years of self-debunked computer prediction proves nothing

while a carbon tax scam will do nothing

but

make

Poor

Carbon based People

poorer

while

this carbon tax will be a Tax on the cause of all carbon based life

on this carbon based Earth

and would be the same as taxing the oxygen we all breathe

~

this will be a carbon tax on the carbon cycle

causing all carbon based life on this carbon based earth

and all the carbon based food we eat

and all the Oxygen we breathe

all made from

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

while

Carbon based Fraud

continues to Grow

on this

Carbon based Earth

by

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

proving the

Citizens Climate Lobby

is

Political ~ Religion

not

Tested knowledge of the Scientific Method

as they continue to refuse to debate the Scientific Facts

because

a Carbon Tax on the Carbon Cycle has nothing to do with Scientific Fact

while evaporated water vapor containing CO2 continues to cause cooling

off-setting

Variable Climate Warming

by the

Variable Sun

that

continues to be warmer and brighter over time

till one day

The Variable Sun

Vaporizes

this

Carbon based Earth

while

some so called climate scientist

who state

the Sun is not a Climate Variable

proving

only their ~ tested ~  stupidity

in Climate Science

while the majority of Climate Religion

are those who would Fail Grade School Science

because

they do not comprehend the tested knowledge

that further debunk the self-debunked prediction

based on ~ test proven ~ flawed science

while

Carbon based Humans

have zero control over

Nature

of the

Progressive Infinity of Climate Variable

of this

Carbon based Earth

~

~*~

Climate Change is Real

~ but ~

not caused by

Carbon based Humans of this Carbon based Earth

where

Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

is:

the cause of the carbon cycle

and

all carbon based life and energy

with

Oxygen ~ and ~ Hydrogen

while

some scientist choose to ignore

test proven reality

for

self-debunked belief

for

profit

~ *~

~

I Challenge

the

Citizens Climate Lobby

~ Scientists ~

all of them

to an

Open Public Debate

with a

$100,000.00

~ REWARD ~

for the

Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~ Proving ~

Carbon based Humans

of this

Carbon based Earth

cause

All or Any

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~

thee so called scientists

employed by climate religion

will continue to Ignore test proven reality

for their

Pay Cheek

for

Selling a Carbon Tax

~ that ~

will do nothing

but

give them a bigger pay cheek

~ while ~

This Carbon based Earth

causing

All

Carbon based Life

above and below

Sea Level

with

two oxygen atoms ~ based to ~ one carbon atom

Carbon ~ based ~ Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

Carbon Dioxide

di = two = 2

oxide = oxygen

causing with

Water Vapor = H2O

the first

Atmosphere

causing

the first

Environment

causing

the

Carbon ~ Oxygen ~ Hydrogen

Cycle

causing

the first

Carbon based Life

Plants and Trees

causing

You and Me

~ while ~

Hypothetical ~ Conjecture

with

Self-debunked

Computer Prediction

based on

flawed

~ Incomplete ~

outdated

Science Papers from the 1800’s

that ignores all known modern test proven fact

Proves

Nothing

but

Fraud

by those using the self-debunked

Prediction

and the incomplete self-debunked

Science Papers

as proof

Carbon based Humans

cause

all or any

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~

the

Citizens Climate Lobby

are

test proven

Carbon based Frauds

for

Money and Power

with

Zero Science to Prove

Carbon based Humans

cause

all or any

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

while

Ignoring

All

Proven Fact Test Knowledge

debunking

~ their ~

Belief

in

Test ~ Proven

~ bogus ~

Garbage ~ Science

while

calling ~ it ~ science

does not make it

Real

or

Complete

or

Tested ~ Knowledge

of

~ the ~

Scientific Method

~

No One

will

Debate ~ their ~ Make Believe ~ in ~ Bogus Science

~

The Citizens Climate Lobby

is not a science body

they are a

Political Media Body

with paid for scientists

~ who ~

can not prove

Carbon based Humans

cause

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

with

Tested ~ Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

Climate Religion

can not debunk the tested knowledge that debunks

~ their ~

Test Proven Religion

~

Climate Religion

~ is ~

Test Proven Fraud in Science

~

Climate Change is Real

but

not caused by carbon based you and me

or

carbon based oxygen

~ CO2 ~

carbon dioxide

while

there are many variables

with

many variables

for

climate change

on this carbon based earth

ignored by climate religion

not

~ 1 ~

while

the

Citizens Climate Lobby

is:

about

Profit

in

~ trillions of dollars in carbon credits ~

Money ~ not ~ Science

10 to 20 trillion over the next 10 to 20 years

paid for by the poorest of the poor

that could be used to feed a lot of starving people

and reduce

Contamination of this Carbon based Earth

of

on going

Nuclear Radiation Poisoning

from

~ Real ~

Man Made

Nuclear ~ Radiation ~ Pollution

in the Air and the Ocean

causing

Birth Defects

Dead Births

sort and long term Illness leading to slow death

above and below Sea level

while we live in a world where Nuclear Weapons in the hands of Lunatics

while we are preoccupied

with removing the cause of all carbon based Life

through Belief not Knowledge for Profit

~

we are

Blood-Letting

again

for

Profit

based on

Belief in Fraud in Science

~ not ~

Test proven Fact

of the

Scientific Method

~

we are focused on spending trillions to end the causes of life

rather than preventing the causes of death

for the sake of Political Media Belief

caused by

test proven

Stupidity in Science

and

Greed

~

Climate Religion refuses to acknowledge tested knowledge

for the sake of Pathological Belief and Profit

~ dictating science is not testing science ~

while profit over rules tested reality

as they will not test or debate real science

while they can not disprove their Religion is a test proven Religion

~ for ~

Profit

~ while ~

those who would fail Grade School Science continue to

Join

and

Donate

to the

Political Media Paranoid Climate Religion

Climate Religion

based on

Proven

Political Media Lies and Fraud

as the Carbon Scam continues to Grow on

doing only harm

to this Carbon based Earth and the Carbon Cycle and all Carbon based Life

for

Self-debunked Prediction

based on

Bogus Science

and

Test Proven Fraud

~ while ~

only frauds in science never debate the science

because

there is nothing beyond

self-debunked

Prediction

to prove Carbon based Humans cause Climate Warming

with overwhelming tested knowledge

further debunking

the self-debunked

Prediction of the Future

~ proving ~

It’s all about

~ Power ~

through

~ Money ~

and

~ Belief ~

with

~ zero ~

Science

of the

Scientific ~ Method

~

Belief in self-debunked prediction while refusing to look at the tested knowledge

that further debunk ~ their ~ Belief

is

~ Lunatic ~

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

~ and is not ~

Proven Fact Tested Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

~ so prove I am wrong ~

Test and Debate

the

Real Science

because

real science is tested and debated

not

~ Dictated ~

Preached and Believed

while dictating how we can and can not live our daily life

as they continue to Brain Wash them selves and the rest of this Carbon based World

while

~ they want to believe ~

they

are saving this carbon based Earth and all carbon based Life from carbon

while doing only Harm

to the carbon cycle and all carbon based life

while

they can prove nothing

beyond

Make Believe

in

Hypothetical Conjecture

and

~ Self-debunked ~

Computer Prediction of the Future

based on flawed incomplete self-debunked science papers of the 1800’s

that ignores all test proven modern fact and all climate history

~

Pathological Belief is not Scientific Reality

nor is

Proven Lies and Proven Fraud

by

Climate Religion

this is why climate religion will not debate their religion

because

it is a

Test Proven

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

by

Politicians and Journalist

who have publicly

Failed

Grade School Science

with their bought and paid for Scientists

who Ignore test proven reality

who will not admit they are wrong

while profiting from their

Hypothetical Conjecture

and proven lies

while

doing only harm to the carbon cycle

and all carbon based Life

~

Climate Religion

wants your money

and to control every part of your

Carbon based Life

~

Climate Religion

~ dose not want ~

Test Proven Knowledge

of the

Scientific Method

~

I do not belong to any Political Party

I have not profited in any way

from anyone or anything

in fact I have only spent my money on my on going

Independent

~ Investigation ~

since the spring of 2007

~

~*~

~ Einstein ~

had a title

he was a Patent Office Clerk

who could not spell

~ * ~

Bruce A. Kershaw

~ title ~

Automotive Master Technician

~ Independent ~

dyslexic

Scientist of the Scientific Method

39 years

~ Automotive ~

Atmospheric Emission Science

Physics ~ and ~ Chemistry

who can not spell

~

My guess is most PhD’s

can not fix their Car

and do not realize

there is more science in the car they drive every day than the science in the class they teach

~ and when ~

NASA is Stumped

they call an Auto Mechanic

My Helena High Auto Shop Teacher

Allan E. Walter

Unionville ~Montana

and another

Auto Mechanic who is the Brother

of my friend

Bill

Helena ~ Montana

~

a Title

has nothing to do with knowledge

only a fool would believe a ~ Title ~ limits someones knowledge of or experience

~

You do not have to be a PhD

to debunk a PhD with Tested Knowledge a PhD does not Comprehend

while

many PhD’s continue to try to belittle me

because

I just fix cars

they can’t fix

~

I know many people with a paid for education and many who are self educated

most of the self educated I know

can go circles around the many of those who are still paying for their education

PhD’s are good at looking down on others they call Lay People

because Lay People are beneath them

while not all PhD’s but many so called PhD’s

don’t know their Butt from a Hole in the Ground

as many Science Teachers are Preaching Garbage Science to our Children

~

bruce@co2u.info

Helena ~ Montana

U.S.A.

Carbon ~ based ~ Earth

~ causing ~

all

carbon based life and energy

with

Carbon

Oxygen

and

Hydrogen

caused by

Water Vapor and Carbon based Oxygen = CO2 = Carbon Dioxide

Evaporated

from the

Ocean

by the

~ Variable ~

SUN

~*~

~

~*~

~ while those who would fail grade school science continue to dictate science ~

while

Ignoring

new and pre-existing knowledge for

Belief in Prediction

these Environmental Extremest

are not a part of

Science or Reality

because

science is:

reviewed ~ analyzed

and

tested

not

believed

preached

and

Dictated

because

science is: to know ~ not ~ make believe

while

Ignoring Tested Reality

does not make it go away

for future Generations

to ~ know

~ not ~

Make Believe

while

the

United Nations

continues to State

Carbon based Humans

of this

Carbon based Earth

are responsible for

~ all ~

Climate Change

and

Acidification of the Ocean

~

~ this is a ~

Test Proven Lie

based on

Test Proven Stupidity

~ causing ~

Political Media ~ Paranoid ~ Climate Religion

by

Environmental

~ Extremist ~

who have

Publicly ~ Failed

Grade School Science

~

~ science is skepticism of belief as science ~

because

science is: to know

as the Arrogance

of Fools

continues to Rule

this Carbon based Earth

where you can not stop a Test Proven Religion

with Tested Science

of

~ the ~

Scientific Method

~

Belief is still Religion not Science

while

there are no test proven measured facts to prove

Carbon based Humans

~ cause ~

all ~ or ~ any

Climate Warming

of this

Carbon based Earth

~ causing ~

All

carbon ~ based

Life and Energy

~

The more we Carbon based Humans add Carbon based Oxygen

~ CO2 ~

to the Atmosphere

of this Carbon based Earth

the Greener the Healthier the Nature of this Carbon based Earth

~ causing all Carbon based Life and Energy will be ~

~

There can be no Faith in Science and Government

based on Hearsay Belief

Science can only be

~ test proven fact ~

of the

Scientific Method

~ * ~

~

About Bruce A. Kershaw

Born ~ March 27, 1956 at 11:10 pm Long Beach California other wise I'm still breathing O2 made from CO2 and eating food made from CO2 ~ the rest is Icing on the cake ~
This entry was posted in CO2 and Global Warming. Bookmark the permalink.